A Case Study in Mismatched Fund Returns
Why do a fund's returns sometimes differ from its underlying index? A longstanding legal principle holds the key.


Over the past 12 months, the Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLK) – a member of the Kiplinger ETF 20, our favorite exchange-traded funds – has returned a loss of 10.5%, lagging a 5.0% loss in the S&P 500 Information Technology Index.
Both the ETF and the index are weighted by market value and include the same companies – the 69 tech stocks that are members of the S&P 500 stock index. So, what gives?
Weighting matters when it comes to fund returns
The weighting of stocks in the ETF varies from their weighting in the index, thanks to a rule in the Investment Company Act, enacted in 1940, that governs how mutual funds and ETFs should maintain diversification.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
"The index doesn't have to adhere to the 1940 Investment Company Act, but the fund does," says Matthew Bartolini, head of ETF research in the Americas for State Street Global Advisors.
The diversification rules are designed to avoid risk from stock concentration in funds.
Chiefly, the rules prescribe that no single stock can make up more than 25% of any given fund's assets and that the sum of any stocks in the fund with a 5% or greater stake must add up to less than 50%.
Ergo, Apple (AAPL), Microsoft (MSFT) and Nvidia (NVDA) – top holdings in both the Technology Select Sector ETF and the Information Technology index – make up 41% of the ETF but account for roughly 60% of the Info Tech index.
The variation in the weighting of holdings had little impact on relative returns in 2022 and 2023, when the ETF and the Info Tech index posted similar gains.
But 2024 was different, thanks to mega-size gains in a handful of mega-size companies. The ETF logged a 21.6% gain that calendar year; the Info Tech index, 36.6%.
"It has been an anomalous market," says Bartolini. Of course, many of those mega-size firms have given back some of those gains recently, and that may mean the ETF will close the gap in relative performance.
The Technology Select Sector SPDR is a solid tech fund. The ETF's 10-year 17.4% annualized return beat 89% of its peers.
This item first appeared in Kiplinger Personal Finance Magazine, a monthly, trustworthy source of advice and guidance. Subscribe to help you make more money and keep more of the money you make here.
Related Content
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Nellie joined Kiplinger in August 2011 after a seven-year stint in Hong Kong. There, she worked for the Wall Street Journal Asia, where as lifestyle editor, she launched and edited Scene Asia, an online guide to food, wine, entertainment and the arts in Asia. Prior to that, she was an editor at Weekend Journal, the Friday lifestyle section of the Wall Street Journal Asia. Kiplinger isn't Nellie's first foray into personal finance: She has also worked at SmartMoney (rising from fact-checker to senior writer), and she was a senior editor at Money.
-
How to Shop Smarter as Tariffs Drive Up Prices in 2025
Tariff fatigue is real. Here’s how to save as prices rise and uncertainty grows.
-
Retirement Reimagined: Finding Your Tribe in LGBTQ-Focused Communities
Demand for LGBTQ retirement communities in the U.S. is high, but inventory is not easy to find. Here are some safe havens to explore.
-
The $1 Million Retirement Question: Are You Being Tax-Smart About Your Pension?
A financial planner raises some key considerations for navigating retirement with a pension and recommends four strategies.
-
The Costly Mistake You Might Be Making With Your First 401(k)
Most people start contributing to their retirement savings later in life. That could be a big-time mistake, literally costing you thousands of dollars.
-
Why I Trust Bonds, Even Now
Columnist Jeffrey Kosnett explains why he stands by investing in bonds.
-
An Estate Planning Attorney's Guide to the Importance of POAs
Regularly updating your financial and health care power of attorney documents ensures they reflect your current intentions and circumstances. It's also important to clearly communicate your wishes to your chosen agents.
-
Divorce and Your Home: An Expert's Guide to Avoiding a Tax Bomb
Your home is probably your biggest asset, so if you're getting a divorce, the stakes are high. Keep it? Sell it? You need to have a good plan in place for how to handle it.
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Grapple for Peace Trade Gains
Of course dramatic tension is high on Fed Day, only this time it's about war and peace as well as monetary policy.
-
Fewer Agents, Fewer Audits: How IRS Staff Cuts Are Changing Enforcement
Significant reductions in the IRS workforce appear to be increasing the number of 'no change' audit closures. The shift could potentially increase the overall tax gap — the difference between taxes that should have been paid and those that were.
-
What if You Could Increase Your Retirement Income by 50% to 75%? Here's How
Combining IRA investments, lifetime income annuities and a HECM into one plan could significantly increase your retirement income and liquid savings compared to traditional planning.