Behold, a Tax Loophole
A change in the definition of dependent will help some upper-income families with younger and boomerang children take advantage of an accidental tax break.

Thanks to a recent tax simplification law designed to clarify who can claim a child as a dependent, some upper-income families with both younger children and older "boomerang" kids living at home could benefit from an unintended loophole.
One leading tax expert predicts that Congress will likely shut it down once the embarrassing gaffe becomes widely known. But it is unlikely any congressional action would affect 2005 returns due this year.
Under the old rules, to claim a child as a dependent and get the benefit of the $3,200 personal exemption and the $1,000 child tax credit for those younger than 17, you had to provide more than half of that person's support. But now a sibling can claim a brother or sister as a dependent even if he or she doesn't pony up one dime for support -- as long as the parents don't also claim the child as a dependent.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
The new definition of a qualifying child is also the key for claiming head-of-household filing status and the earned-income tax credit for low-income families.
Kathy Burlison, director of tax implementation for HR Block, says the big winners of this accidental tax break are upper-income families who lose the benefit of the child tax credit when their joint income exceeds $110,000 and even wealthier families whose ability to claim personal exemptions is phased out once their joint income tops $218,950. "The key message here is sometimes you have to look not just at your own tax return, but that of your whole household for tax saving opportunities," she says.
To illustrate, Burlison cites the example of a married couple with $240,000 of income and two children, Larry, 21, and Gail, 15. Larry is not in school and earned $13,000 last year, so he can't be claimed as a dependent because of his age. (If he were a full-time student, he could qualify as a dependent through age 24.) Under the new rules, Gail can be claimed as a dependent child by either her parents or by her brother.
Because of their income, the parents get no child credit for Gail, and her dependency exemption is squeezed, resulting in a tax savings of $866. But if Larry claims his sister as a dependent, he qualfies for tax savings of nearly $3,500, thanks to the dependency exemption, child credit and an earned-income credit worth $2,662. It may be legal, but is it right?
"It appears that this approach is allowed under the current law, even though it obviously isn't the intended result," says tax expert Kaye Thomas of Fairmark.com. "But to see thousands of dollars in tax benefits going to kids living at home with upper-income parents is just bizarre."
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

-
Four Surprising Signs You’ll Never Retire (and How to Fix Them)
Gearing up to retire? If any of these four signs ring true, you may want to make some changes before you do.
-
Stocks Rise After Trump-Powell Fed Tour: Stock Market Today
Nvidia hit a new all-time high intraday, but another renowned semiconductor name and some less iconic stocks were bigger movers Friday.
-
Five Ways Trump’s 2025 Tax Bill Could Boost Your Tax Refund (or Shrink It)
Tax Refunds The tax code is changing again, and if you’re filing for 2025, Trump’s ‘big beautiful’ bill could mean a bigger refund next year, a smaller one, or something in between. Here are five ways the new law could impact your bottom line.
-
New SALT Deduction Could Put Thousands Back in California Homeowners’ Pockets
Tax Breaks The federal state and local sales tax (SALT) deduction cap is higher this year, and could translate into bigger savings for Golden State homeowners.
-
Money for Your Kids? Three Ways Trump's ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ Impacts Your Child's Finances
Tax Tips The Trump tax bill could help your child with future education and homebuying costs. Here’s how.
-
New Cap on Gambling Loss Deductions Begins Soon: What to Know Now
Tax Changes A gambling losses tax deduction cap in Trump’s “big beautiful bill” is causing an uproar. Here’s what you need to know.
-
Key 2025 Tax Changes for Parents in Trump's Megabill
Tax Changes Are you a parent? The so-called ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ (OBBB) impacts several key tax incentives that can affect your family this year and beyond.
-
Elon Musk and Most Taxpayers Don't Like What's in Trump's 'Big Beautiful Bill'
Tax Policy President Trump is betting big on his newest tax cuts, signed into law on July 4. But not everyone is on board.
-
2025 SALT Cap Could Hurt Top 'Hidden Home Cost'
Tax Deductions The GOP tax bill could make hidden homeowner costs worse for you. Here’s how.
-
No Social Security Tax Changes in Trump’s 'Big Bill'? What Retirees Need to Know
Tax Policy Eliminating taxes on Social Security benefits is missing from President Trump’s tax overhaul. Here’s why and what an alternative offering could mean for retirement taxes.