Is a 401(k) Really the Best Way to Save for Retirement?
I think it's better to pay taxes on your retirement savings while you are working, than to pay later when you are retired.
If you read any article over the past 30 years on how to save for retirement, you can pretty much guarantee that somewhere in that article, the author will tell you that you should do your best to maximize your contributions to your 401(k) / 403(b) plan if you can. The three reasons for doing so are familiar:
First, a 401(k) / 403(b) contribution represents “forced savings." This is a good thing. With that being said, if you are an adult, then this should not be a big issue for you.
Second, with your 401(k) / 403(b) you receive a tax deduction on your contribution. Often you will hear or read the argument that you should save tax today while you are working and paying a higher tax rate. You should pay taxes later when you are retired and in a lower tax bracket. (We will look into this one a bit later.)

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Third, you may get a company match on your contribution. That company match represents “free” money. This is a very good thing!
Given these three positive reasons for using your company retirement savings program, whether it be a 401(k) or 403(b) or something else that is similar, why wouldn’t a prudent person jump right on board?
Here’s why.
Reason #1: You create an enormous tax liability
Think about it this way. Let’s say you are saving $18,000 per year in your 401(k) or 403(b). You are deferring income tax on $18,000 each year you deposit the money. But when you retire, you may have built up an account worth $1 or $2 million. That is $1 or $2 million that has never been taxed! And you, or your heirs, will pay tax on every penny of it.
You saved tax on your seed, but you will owe tax on your harvest.
Reason #2: You are NOT in a lower tax rate bracket in retirement
401(k) and 403(b) plan providers will often tell you to take your tax deduction today and pay tax later when you are retired and in a lower bracket. Just one problem: Do you really want to be in a lower tax bracket when you retire?
Think about it. Do you want to retire with a lower standard of living? You save for 30 years, and if you do a good job, you get to retire into the SAME standard of living. This means you will have about the same amount of income, which means the same tax rate. But now your home is paid for, your children are gone, and your tax deductions have vanished.
The taxes you owe increase, and that assumes tax rates do not rise in the future. What do you think the odds are on that?
Reason #3: You are now a target
You might agree that the good folks in Washington, D.C., have a spending problem. But how are they going to pay for it all?
You can bet your last dollar that they all know that there are trillions of dollars sitting in 401(k) and 403(b) plans that have never been taxed. This is like candy to a baby, and they want it. Do you really want the bulk of your retirement dollars sitting in the crosshairs of a government with a spending habit?
What you should do:
1. Only put the minimum in your 401(k) / 403(b) to get your company match. Free money is a good thing. Take advantage of your employer match. Adding in additional funds beyond that is a mistake.
Note: If your company allows your contribution to be put into a Roth 401(k), then by all means, max that out. It is okay to max out your 401(k) into a Roth option, but not the traditional one.
2. Any additional dollars should go into Roth IRAs that will be tax-free for life. If you make too much money to contribute to a Roth IRA, just deposit your money into a non-tax deductible IRA, and convert it to a Roth the next day.
Note: Please verify this approach will work with your accountant. If you already have traditional IRAs out there, it may not work.
3. Look into “maximum-funded life insurance” as a 401(k) option. Be careful on this one, but if you have a really good financial person on your side, they can help you set it up in the proper way.
When it comes to taxes on your retirement plans, Uncle Sam takes a “pay me now or pay me later” approach. You know that in life, it is almost always better to just pay me now. The same is true with taxes and retirement.
It is okay to pay a little now to be tax-free later. In fact, it’s better than okay.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Michael Reese, CFP, CLU, ChFC, CTS is the founder and principal of Centennial Advisors LLC, with offices in Austin, Texas, and Traverse City, Mich. Michael's vision is to help American retirees "re-think" how they manage their financial portfolios during their retirement years. His focus is to help retirees enjoy financial security in any economy, something that he believes is sorely lacking in today's financial world.
-
Retire in Costa Rica With These Three Tax Benefits
Retirement Taxes Costa Rica may be a good place for retirement if you like the low cost of living and savings for your heirs.
By Kate Schubel Published
-
Five Ways to Ease Caregiver Stress
Caregiver stress is real. Here are five techniques to protect your health and happiness while caring for a loved one.
By MP Dunleavey Published
-
Financial Strategies Borrowed From the Big Game's Playbook
Like the best football teams, you can win at financial planning by executing a strategy, making halftime adjustments and staying focused on the ultimate prize.
By Frank J. Legan Published
-
Three Ways to Plan Now for a Social Security Shortfall Later
The outlook for Social Security is gloomy, but you can save now to protect against benefit cuts later. If the cuts don't happen, you'll still be better off.
By Tyler Jones Published
-
The Future of 1031 Exchanges Under Trump Looks Bright
As a real estate investor himself, President Trump appears poised to preserve the tax-deferring power of this strategy. But you still must follow the rules.
By Edward E. Fernandez Published
-
Empowering Widows: Five Goals for Financial Security in 2025
Tackling these strategies one at a time, whether it's updating estate planning or reassessing investments, can help put you on track for financial stability.
By Stacy Francis, CFP®, CDFA®, CES™ Published
-
Market Volatility Tempting You to Get Out? Read This First
If you're retired, or soon will be, riding out a roller-coaster market can be nerve-racking. Try to hold steady and focus on balancing your investments.
By Lauren Ivester Published
-
Retirement Income Planning for Unfunded Health Care Costs
Retirement income plans often don't include late-in-life health or long-term care expenses. Here's how to cover for the unplanned withdrawals to pay for those.
By Jerry Golden, Investment Adviser Representative Published
-
Federal Employees Buyout Offer: Five Things to Consider
Federal workers have a constellation of retirement benefits, and assessing them can get complicated fast. Here are five high-stakes decisions to focus on.
By Ben Kautz, CFP® Published
-
Five Reasons Not to Give Your Child Power of Attorney
When drawing up powers of attorney, older parents will most likely name adult children as their representatives. But is that always the smart choice?
By Peter Newman, CFA Published