college

Should Colleges Give Preference to Applicants From Wealthy Families?

Every admitted student should meet the college’s basic academic qualifications.

Q. I hear that admissions offices at some elite colleges favor the sons and daughters of rich families, in anticipation of large donations after enrollment. Do you think this is ethical?

A. No, if the rich applicant’s family has no previous connection to the school. Colleges should never solicit or accept large donations from such a family if a child is in or about to enter the admissions process—a corrupt practice revealed in Daniel Golden’s 2006 exposé, The Price of Admission.

But an admissions preference for a qualified applicant whose alumni parents or grandparents have long supported the college as passionate volunteers and donors? That’s okay. It’s just one of many weightings given to applicants of all sorts.

In an ideal world that has never existed, admissions decisions would be based solely on factors for which the applicant is personally responsible, such as grades, test scores, demonstrated leadership, athletic or artistic talents, and a record of helping others. No weight would be given to factors over which an applicant has no personal control, such as race, sex, geography and the socio­economic circumstances of the family, whether high or low.

But for decades, colleges have gone far beyond individual traits in deciding whom to admit. To craft a well-rounded, multitalented student body that reflects the diversity of their region, if not the nation, they routinely admit applicants who might be academically less stellar (by the numbers, which are themselves not highly reliable) than the college’s typical freshman.

Band directors and sports coaches will get the musicians and athletes they need, even if the academic bar is lowered a bit for the top recruits. Underrepresented racial minorities will be cut some slack, especially if they have shown grit in overcoming poverty. For geographic diversity, an applicant from rural North Dakota will get the nod over an academically similar (or better) candidate from Westchester County, N.Y.

All of these preferences—like the alumni donor preference—strike me as legitimate, provided that every admitted student meets the college’s basic academic qualifications.

Have a money-and-ethics question you’d like answered in this column? Write to editor in chief Knight Kiplinger at ethics@kiplinger.com.

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
Should You Take an Extra Big RMD This Year?
required minimum distributions (RMDs)

Should You Take an Extra Big RMD This Year?

Sometimes only taking the minimum IRA distribution can be a costly mistake. When deciding how much to withdraw this year, you need to consider the big…
November 23, 2021
The Berkshire Hathaway Portfolio: All 41 Warren Buffett Stocks Ranked
stocks

The Berkshire Hathaway Portfolio: All 41 Warren Buffett Stocks Ranked

The Berkshire Hathaway portfolio is a diverse set of blue chips, and increasingly, lesser-known growth bets. Here's a look at every stock picked by Wa…
November 16, 2021

Recommended

Honey, We Need to Talk About Money
Women & Money

Honey, We Need to Talk About Money

Instead of focusing on the numbers, couples might have more success discussing their goals.
November 24, 2021
How to Choose the Right Payment App
banking

How to Choose the Right Payment App

Using PayPal, Venmo, Zelle and other apps is convenient, but there are pros and cons to each.
November 23, 2021
Shop for a New Wireless Plan and Save Big
Smart Buying

Shop for a New Wireless Plan and Save Big

Competition is fierce, and carriers are dangling free phones and streaming subscriptions.
November 23, 2021
Are You Financially Ready to Have Children?
family savings

Are You Financially Ready to Have Children?

Yes, children are expensive. Can you handle it? A financial planner with a new baby at home has some helpful suggestions and guidelines for all the po…
November 22, 2021