Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.

SMART INSIGHTS FROM PROFESSIONAL ADVISERS

A Do-It-Yourself Replacement for Indexed Annuities

Consider building a portfolio of CDs and index funds to protect your principal and potentially boost returns.

iStock

Indexed annuities and other principal-protected products have experienced strong sales in recent years. Investor fear stemming from the financial crisis of 2007 and 2008, along with persistent low interest rates, might offer an explanation for this. Unfortunately, the return potential offered by these vehicles usually leaves a lot to be desired.

SEE ALSO: Are Annuities Right for You?

Complex features including caps, participation rates, surrender periods and returns linked to proprietary indices rarely benefit the investor. Additionally, these products typically do not benefit from dividends, which are the source of a large portion of stock market returns. The marketing material may tout high returns, but they often shows hypothetical back-tested performance from a time period with significantly higher interest rates than today, setting unrealistic expectations. Indexed annuities may also carry credit risk in the unlikely event that the company issuing the product does not have the financial capacity to meet its obligations.

Fortunately, if fear of the market crashing keeps you up at night, a portfolio featuring two simple components may provide greater safety and performance than the majority of indexed annuity products.

The first component of this approach, comprising the majority of investment dollars, is the purchase of one or more certificates of deposit. There are banks offering CDs insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation with rates of more than 2% for a 10-year term. You can also obtain rates over 2% utilizing brokered CDs available on most brokerage platforms.

Advertisement

The second component involves purchasing a low-cost index mutual fund, representing the global stock market. Utilizing this strategy, the investor can rest assured that the value of the CDs at maturity will be at least equal to the entire original investment.

Here’s an example: Robert has $100,000 that he would like to invest but he prefers to avoid taking too much market risk. He does not anticipate needing to access this investment for ten years. First, he could invest $81,000 in a 10-year CD with an interest rate of 2.2%. At the end of ten years, this $81,000 invested in the CD would be worth a bit more than $100,000.

At the same time, he could invest the remaining $19,000 in a low-cost global stock index fund, with dividend reinvestment, to help him benefit from the power of compounding. Regardless of the return of the index fund, his CD will be worth more than the initial $100,000 at maturity. If the index fund were to return an average 9% a year, the value of his original $100,000 investment would be worth approximately $145,000 after 10 years. Even in an unfavorable (and unlikely) scenario in which the stock market decreased 25% over the 10-year period, the CD combined with the index fund would still show a gain of approximately $14,000.

Impact of Early Withdrawal

One important consideration for utilizing CDs is the likelihood of needing to access the principal before maturity. CDs purchased from a bank that are accessed before maturity are usually subject to an early withdrawal penalty. As a basis of comparison, the surrender charges for early withdrawal from indexed annuities are typically much higher than these penalties. Brokered CDs pay out the face value at maturity, but can be sold prior to maturity. The value of the CD may be lower or higher than the original purchase price, depending on interest rate movements and your ability to sell the CD at a favorable price. For these reasons, this strategy is best when you don’t foresee needing to access the investment until maturity.

Advertisement

Tax Implications

There are also tax implications if you are not implementing this strategy in a retirement account such as an IRA or Roth IRA. You must pay taxes annually on the interest income generated by the CD and the dividends from the index fund. You may be able to lessen this tax impact by implementing tax-exempt municipal bonds instead of CDs, but this does create additional risks and challenges.

The capital gains you realize from the eventual sale of the index fund also must be considered, but long-term capital gains rates for investments held over a year help to soften the tax impact.

Indexed annuities provide deferral on taxes until withdrawals are made, but these withdrawals can be subject to complex tax treatment at ordinary income rates. Indexed annuities are typically not favorable assets to inherit, as they do not receive the step-up in basis available for most other investments.

The homemade strategy described in this article provides similar psychological benefits with regards to loss avoidance as indexed annuities, as long as the CDs are held until maturity. This strategy also benefits from greater transparency along with a strong likelihood of providing higher returns than indexed annuity products.

Advertisement

See Also: Trade an Annuity for a Better One

Kevin Peacock is the founding partner of Astra Capital Management based in New York City. His firm specializes in investment management that integrates alternative investments with traditional asset allocation.

Comments are suppressed in compliance with industry guidelines. Click here to learn more and read more articles from the author.

This article was written by and presents the views of our contributing adviser, not the Kiplinger editorial staff. You can check adviser records with the SEC or with FINRA.