Warnock, Walker and Georgia's Messy Midterm Election

Control next year of the Senate, currently evenly split between the parties, could come down to a few thousand votes in Georgia. Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock is facing an extremely tough challenge from Republican Herschel Walker, a political newcomer with strong backing from former President Trump.

 With the polls and political handicappers showing essentially a dead heat, we recently traveled around the Peach State and spoke with dozens of voters to get a better sense of what’s on their minds and how the race is leaning.

 For the first time ever in Georgia, two black men won their parties’ nominations for a Senate seat. But in the black community, in cities and small towns, there is no doubt who has the upper hand. It’s Warnock, by a wide margin. Hardly any black voters had a kind word to say about Walker, despite his legendary status as a Heisman Trophy-winning University of Georgia running back in the early 1980s.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

Rural vs. urban matters

Interest in the race among black voters seems to hinge more on a dislike for Walker than enthusiasm for Warnock, a potentially worrying scenario for the Democrat, as positive support tends to drive voter turnout more than dislike of the opposing candidate.

Not surprisingly, liberal-leaning Atlanta and its close suburbs are Warnock territory. And with about 30 percent of the state’s population living in the Atlanta metro area, that’s a lot of potential votes for the incumbent.

But there’s a far different sentiment outside the capital city. In rural and small-town Georgia, Walker is immensely popular among white voters. In fact, it’s almost universal, aside from college towns like Athens, home to the state’s flagship university. Here, white voters appear energized by Walker’s campaign and seem eager to vote.

Time and time again, we heard Republican voters say they like Walker because he shares their conservative values. And Trump’s backing of Walker certainly helps in this regard, many said.

Walker, who has struggled with gaffes on the campaign trail, also performed reasonably well during the race’s only debate this month, helping quell worries in the Republican Party that he isn’t ready for prime time.

Will GOP voters stay home?

Another major motivator for Republicans is to “correct” the 2020 Senate elections. Because of a mid-term retirement, Georgia that year held two Senate elections. In normal years, the Democratic candidates would’ve faced a tough – and possibly insurmountable – path to victory. But many GOP voters stayed home in the two runoff contests held weeks after the November election as a protest of what they said was a “stolen” win for Joe Biden. They look at Warnock and fellow Democratic Sen. Jon Ossoff as “fluke” winners and vow that such a scenario won’t happen again.

 Still, we did meet some voters from each party who said they’re not completely impressed by either candidate and will vote for the “lesser of two evils” – though that “lesser” candidate almost always matched those voters’ party preferences. We also ran across a few folks who said they’re disgusted with politics and won’t vote, though only a small handful.

Political baggage carried by both candidates doesn’t seem to matter much to their supporters. Pro-life Walker has been accused of paying for abortions for multiple women, which he denies. And Warnock has been involved in a messy divorce, with his wife accusing him of running over her foot with his car, which he also denies. In an earlier era, these alleged transgressions would’ve disqualified both from winning. But not now, as neither candidate’s base seems bothered much by the allegations.

For governor, Abrams looks strong

The governor’s race should help increase voter turnout this year, since it’s on the minds of voters as much as, or possibly more, than the Senate race. We sensed more enthusiasm among Democratic voters for Stacey Abrams, the party’s nominee, than for Warnock. While not a flattering position for the senator, this should help boost turnout for him. Conversely, we witnessed outsized disdain among Republican voters for Abrams. While most like GOP candidate Brian Kemp, they loathe Abrams and fear she would pull the state far more to the political left than Warnock would be capable of doing in the Senate.

Beyond the candidates, the race also is a proxy battle for political supremacy in Georgia. In short, the candidates on the ballot seem to matter less than the parties they represent, a scenario we’ve seen repeated across the country in the past few election cycles. More than one Republican told us that if Democrats win in November, they’ll move from the state. Political power sharing isn’t an option in the modern winner-take-all mood of voters of both parties, in Georgia and elsewhere.

One thing to keep in mind is that the Senate winner may not be decided until a January runoff. Per Georgia election law, a runoff is triggered if neither candidate wins 50%, a plausible scenario, since Libertarian Senate candidate Chase Oliver could be a wildcard and siphon off enough votes to prevent either candidate from clearing the 50% bar.

So, who will win? Warnock does have a slight edge in polling, though polling has been frustratingly unreliable in recent elections and shouldn’t be used as a clear benchmark for how the race will end up. And in many of those polls, Warnock’s lead has shrunk in recent weeks to within the margin of error. But early voting is already underway in Georgia, so time is running out. At this point, we have to rate the race as a tossup, though a lot can – and may – happen between now and Election Day that could change our forecast.