I Wouldn't Use These Types of CD Accounts Right Now
The good news is you can earn over 4% on many CDs. However, there are 3 types of CDs I wouldn’t currently recommend.
In a world of not many sure things, a certificate of deposit is a rarity. You can store money in it, helping you earn a guaranteed return on investment.
They're perfect for short-term goals. Need to save for a vacation home, a dream trip or a side business you wanted to start up since retiring? A CD can help you reach them.
Best of all, some CDs still offer rates above 4%, which can help you stay ahead of inflation — at least for now. The annual inflation rate rose to 3.3% for the 12 months ending in March, up from 2.4%, according to data from the U.S. Labor Department.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Things to consider with a CD
CDs work best when you view a portion of your money as untouchable until you reach your goals. The reason for this is if you open a certificate of deposit and need to withdraw your money before your term expires, banks don’t like it.
In turn, you’ll have to pay an early termination fee, since removing a portion of your money from a CD closes it. That penalty fee will likely offset the interest you earned. If you want more flexibility in savings, either consider a no-penalty CD or a high-yield savings account.
Even so, CDs are excellent saving vehicles. I’ve used them for three and six month savings goals, and they’ve done well for me.
With these things in mind, there are many CD types available. Here are three I would recommend against, at least for the time being.
1. Long-term CDs
Long-term CDs allow you to set money aside for three to five, even 10 years in some cases. When interest rates on savings are high, it’s a home run option for risk-averse savers.
CDs come with fixed interest rates, meaning the rate you lock in is the one you’ll have until the term expires.
However, they also work best if you already have an emergency fund of at least six months and are on your way to reaching your investment goals. Keep in mind that if you need to break open your CD early, the penalties for longer-term CDs are substantial, costing you six months to a year of earned interest.
Another thing to keep in mind is that we don't know how high prices will increase in the next few years. If they rise considerably, it can lower the returns you earn on a long-term CD.
Without the flexibility to switch (unless you're willing to pay the early termination fee), you might limit your potential earnings with this approach.
This is why shopping around for the best rates and terms is essential to finding your perfect CD match. Use the Bankrate tool below to compare and select your best choice quickly:
2. Callable CDs
A callable CD is unique in that your bank might decide to end the term before its maturity date. The most likely reason a bank calls it early is if interest rates lower, as they wouldn't want to be on the hook paying higher rates.
These CDs also have what’s known as a call protection term. During this term, your bank cannot call your CD to mature, giving you time to earn some money on it.
While these CDs can offer higher rates of return than a regular CD or even high-yield savings accounts, the decision on when to end it can be out of your hands. This can limit the returns you earn compared to a regular CD, where you won’t have to worry about your term ending prematurely.
3. CDs from traditional banks
Traditional banks might not offer as high a return as their online predecessors. To demonstrate, a 12-month CD with Huntington Bank earns you 0.25% APY. Meanwhile, a 12-month CD with Prime Alliance Bank earns you 3.85% APY.
The difference is that Prime Alliance doesn’t have physical locations, meaning less overhead they have to pay. While physical banks offer convenience, that comes at a cost.
Furthermore, if you don’t feel comfortable switching to an online bank, see if your local branch has any promotional rates. They usually do these on shorter-term CDs, allowing you to maximize savings in a quicker window.
The bottom line on choosing the best CDs
CDs are a solid choice for savers with a low-risk tolerance, offering a guaranteed return. Right now, many terms pay around 4%. However, if maximizing savings is your priority, you may want to avoid CDs with traditional banks, callable CDs and long-term CDs, as they often come with lower rates, withdrawal restrictions or added risk.
If your timeline stretches five years or more, you might be better off investing, where returns have historically outpaced what CDs can offer. Not all CDs are created equal, either. Callable CDs can be redeemed early by the bank, which means your interest payments could stop sooner than expected.
CDs from traditional brick-and-mortar banks often come with lower rates than what you’ll find online.
Related content
