Five Ways to Approach Impact Investing
Impact investing goes beyond your usual checkbook charity by focusing on measurable social and environmental impact as well as a financial return.
If you’re passionate about social impact and asking what you can do beyond making charitable gifts and volunteering, there’s a world of opportunity. The capital you invest for positive financial returns can also generate positive social returns, amplifying the mark you can make.
Whether you care about climate, medical innovation, women’s rights, economic prosperity or something else, there is likely an impact investment that would complement and enhance your philanthropy. The number of people making impact investments has grown significantly over the past 10 years, topping $1 trillion worldwide, according to the GIIN (Global Impact Investing Network).
In simple terms, an impact investment aims to deliver both positive, measurable social and environmental impact and a financial return. Increasingly, impact investing opportunities have grown in number and popularity across asset classes and strategies. What once was a more niche tool has gone fully mainstream, offering opportunities for the “impact curious” as well as seasoned impact investors.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
What’s more, you can make these investments out of your profit-generating investment accounts or charitable assets — a donor-advised fund (DAF) or the corpus of a foundation — ensuring that all your assets are working toward positive social impact.
Here are five essential ways to approach impact investing:
1. Seek clarity on risks and rewards.
As with any wise investment, know what you’re getting yourself into. Ask yourself: Is this a solid investment, not only for me but for all parties to the transaction? Can I afford to lose this capital? If the investment fails, what are the consequences? And ensure you are also clear about the kind of social or environmental impact the investment is likely to have.
Ask yourself: How significant is that impact? To what extent might there be some trade-off between social impact and financial returns? How ready am I to accept that trade-off?
Some impact investors may choose to accept some below-market-rate returns in exchange for a greater social impact, but most are seeking competitive market-rate returns and are increasingly seeing their expectations met.
2. Know what you own.
This is perhaps the most important mantra for investors, particularly impact investors. Every investment in a company or fund inherently has an impact — whether through the type of goods a company creates, the practices of its board and management, the nature of its supply chain or how it treats employees. The question every investor can consider is whether that impact aligns with their personal values, aspirations or charitable goals.
If you have a charitable foundation or fund that makes grants to combat climate change, for example, are your investments undermining that work? Take a close look at your portfolio. You may be surprised by what you find — good or bad.
3. Widen your aperture.
People often conflate impact investments with ESG. While managing a stock portfolio full of publicly traded companies reporting positive environmental, social and governance metrics is one type of impact investing, there are other direct investments with different types of impact profiles, time horizons or liquidity.
You can help a nonprofit, or other enterprise that meets your values, to bridge a cash flow gap by making a loan on mutually reasonable terms. There’s a burgeoning field of impact-oriented venture capital, helping to finance early-stage social enterprises that focus on a host of impactful issues ranging from healthy food products to remote health care tech to employing people left out of the traditional job market.
In addition, some impact investors offer guarantees that involve them essentially co-signing a loan (or group of loans) to de-risk the transaction, thereby reducing the interest rate or allowing the borrower to qualify for the loan.
4. Listen.
Ask the people doing the work what they need and what would be most helpful to them. They may have a better sense of what will generate a real impact than investors who are more distant from the issue.
For example, if you care about workforce development for youth in low-income neighborhoods, it may be that providing loan guarantees for the purchase of a community training center may dramatically accelerate a workforce development organization’s sustainability and scale. That might even have a greater long-term impact than a charitable donation.
5. Don’t set it and forget it.
Being an impact investor means tracking progress. Financial returns are often easier to calculate than social good. What are the social or environmental impacts you seek? What is the mechanism you are using to measure progress? The field of impact measurement is still evolving, but starting with even a simple set of impact goals and regularly checking in on their progress can make all the difference.
For those who want to take their measurement to the next level, the Impact Management Project has set informative guidelines for measurement, utilizing standards including the U.N. Sustainable Development Goals and the IRIS+ system of the GIIN in order to track impact systematically.
As you explore impact investing, there is a wide range of resources to help you deepen your understanding, find like-minded peers to share ideas and address challenges or find investable opportunities. If you’re interested in testing the impact investing waters, now’s a great time to dive right in.
About Catherine Crystal Foster: Catherine is vice president of the Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors (RPA) Advisory team. In her role, she provides strategic guidance across program areas for families, foundations, and corporations to accelerate social impact. Prior to joining RPA, she served as CEO and co-founder of Magnify Community, where she worked with Silicon Valley philanthropists to make bold and catalytic investments in the community. Catherine has led and advised philanthropic and nonprofit organizations for more than 20 years.
About Patrick Briaud: As a Principal at RPA, Patrick helps individuals, foundations and corporations use a range of assets to achieve their social impact goals. He works closely with institutional funders to make strategic shifts in order to best steward their resources and confidently deploy capital to achieve their impact goals. As lead for RPA’s Impact Investing Practice, Patrick supports mission-driven asset-owners to build investment strategies aligned to their individual values or organizational mission. This support includes education and consensus building, Investment Policy Statement development, operating plan implementation and full-service outsourcing of Program Related Investments.
Related Content
- How to Assess the Impact of Your Charitable Giving
- What to Do if Your Passion for Charitable Giving Has Flagged
- Considering Donating to Charity? Here’s a Road Map to Steer Your Choices
- How to Maximize Your Impact With Strategic Philanthropy Tools
- In Philanthropy, Gen Z and Millennials Do It Their Way
-
10 Cheapest Places to Live in WashingtonProperty Tax Is Washington your go-to ski destination? These counties combine no income tax with the lowest property tax bills in the state.
-
Healthy to 100: Secrets from Countries Where Retirees Age BestLongevity is a team sport, according to author Ken Stern. Here's the secret sauce for living long, healthy lives from countries like Italy and Japan.
-
My First $1 Million: Semiretired CPA, 68, San FranciscoEver wonder how someone who's made a million dollars or more did it? Kiplinger's My First $1 Million series uncovers the answers.
-
6 Overlooked Areas That Can Make or Break Your Retirement, From a Retirement AdviserIf you're heading into retirement with scattered and uncertain plans, distilling them into these six areas can ensure you thrive in later life.
-
I'm a Wealth Adviser: These Are the 7 Risks Your Retirement Plan Should AddressYour retirement needs to be able to withstand several major threats, including inflation, longevity, long-term care costs, market swings and more.
-
High-Net-Worth Retirees: Don't Overlook These Benefits of Social SecurityWealthy retirees often overlook Social Security. But timed properly, it can drive tax efficiency, keep Medicare costs in check and strengthen your legacy.
-
Do You Have an Insurance Coverage Gap for Your Valuables? You May Be Surprised to Learn You DoStandard homeowners insurance usually has strict limits on high-value items, so you should formally "schedule" these valuable possessions with your insurer.
-
8 Practical Ways to Declutter Your Life in 2026: A Retirement 'Non-Resolution' ChecklistHere's how to stop wasting your energy on things that don't enhance your new chapter and focus on the things that do.
-
To Retire Rich, Stop Chasing Huge Returns and Do This Instead, Courtesy of a Financial PlannerSaving a large percentage of your income, minimizing taxes and keeping spending in check can offer a more realistic path to retiring rich.
-
New Year, New Retirement Rules: Here's How You Can Keep Up as the Landscape ChangesFor a successful modern retirement, prepare for a longer life, manage high health care costs and prioritize your social life and purpose.
-
7 Creative Ways to Spend Less and Save More In Retirement, Courtesy of a Financial ProWorried you won't have enough money later in life? Try redesigning your vision of retirement, and you may find your savings go further than you thought.
