Can Your Car Insurance Add Strangers to Your Policy? A Florida Class Action Lawsuit Could Decide
A Florida driver says GEICO added complete strangers to her car insurance policy and jacked up premiums as a result.
In January, a Florida resident filed a class action lawsuit alleging that GEICO added two strangers to her car insurance policy as named drivers without her consent. The additions increased her premiums as a result.
The complaint filed last month alleges that many other drivers nationwide have experienced the same thing with GEICO and is now seeking refunds for all customers impacted by this practice.
For GEICO's part, the insurance company argues that it acted in full compliance with the terms of its car insurance policies. So, what exactly happened and how can you avoid ending up in a similar situation? Here's what we know so far.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
What is the GEICO class action lawsuit about?
According to the complaint filed on January 28, GEICO used a third-party source to match licensed or permitted drivers to addresses. Based on that data, GEICO sent an email to the policyholder stating that another driver was associated with her home address. The email gave her 15 days to respond and noted that if there was no response, the driver would be added to her policy.
The email read, in part, “If this person is insured elsewhere and should not be listed on your policy, please contact us at the number below with the name of the insurer and the policy number.”
The problem? The policyholder says she had no idea who the person was. GEICO was effectively asking her to provide insurance information for someone she did not know.
In December of that same year, the same thing happened again, with another unknown driver added to her policy. In both cases, her premiums increased as a result of the added drivers.
According to the complaint, the policy does not allow GEICO to add unknown drivers to a customer’s car insurance policy and does not include any provision stating that silence — meaning a lack of response to the emails — can be treated as consent.
In a motion to dismiss filed in 2025 related to an earlier version of the case, GEICO argued that it followed standard practice and did not breach any specific provision of its policy. The policyholder did not respond to either email within the 15-day window and continued paying the higher premiums.
However, as the complaint notes, because car insurance is required in every state, canceling coverage immediately after a rate increase may not be a practical option.
Because the case is still in its early stages, it’s unclear who will ultimately be included in the class action lawsuit or how much any potential payout might be if the court rules in the plaintiff’s favor. The legal team is seeking to expand the case nationwide, alleging that similar issues have affected customers outside of Florida.
If you’ve experienced a similar situation, you may want to monitor the case or consult an attorney to better understand your legal options.
What can you do to avoid this situation?
Something similar happened to me with a different insurance company a few years ago. The company found my siblings' information and sent me a notice that they would be added to my policy unless I could prove that they didn't live at my address.
While they weren't strangers as they are in this case, my siblings live in different states and already have their own car insurance. Still, the burden of proof was on me if I didn't want to pay extra to cover drivers who did not live at my address.
So, what's your best course of action to avoid ending up in a similar situation? Here are a few tips:
- Check your insurance policy regularly to make sure the details, including the drivers listed, are accurate. This is one of many reasons an annual insurance review is so important.
- If you receive a notice stating that additional drivers are associated with your address, contact your insurance provider directly using the phone number or website listed on your policy. Even if you don’t have documentation yet, ask what information would be required to resolve the issue.
- If you know the drivers, reach out to them and ask for the information or documents requested by your insurance.
- If you don’t recognize the drivers, contact your insurer and ask what proof is needed to remove them.
- Even if you never receive a notice like this, it’s important to keep an eye on your monthly spending. If your car insurance is set up on autopay, you could miss a premium increase because the payment is automatically deducted.
Whether the Florida courts determine that GEICO breached its contract or not, you certainly shouldn't be paying extra to cover drivers you don't know. But the outcome of this lawsuit could determine whether or not it's your responsibility to make sure the drivers listed on your policy are correct.
In the meantime, consider shopping for new car insurance after resolving the issue or before your next renewal. Comparing quotes can help ensure you’re not overpaying, especially if your premium increased unexpectedly. If you decide to switch, you can provide feedback to the insurance company that did this, explaining precisely why they lost your business.
Related content
-
Vanguard Cuts Fund Fees Again. Here's Why That's Important for YouVanguard recently cut fees on dozens of ETFs and mutual funds, which is great news for investors. Here's why.
-
Ask the Editor: Questions on Tax Returns and DecedentsAsk the Editor In this week's Ask the Editor Q&A, Joy Taylor answers questions on how to file a tax return when someone has died and resources you can use to find more help.
-
The 1% Club: In These States, a $743,000 Income Isn't Enough to JoinBeing a top earner is relative: Why trading a high-tax zip code for a low-cost state is the ultimate retirement power move.
-
Life Loves to Throw Curveballs, So Ditch the Rigid Money Rules and Do This InsteadSome rules are too rigid for real life. A values-based philosophy is a more flexible approach that helps you retain confidence — whatever life throws at you.
-
The Best Short-Term CD for Your Cash in 2026This strategy can help you earn thousands in months.
-
Thinking of Switching Phone Carriers? Do These 8 Things FirstSwitching carriers is easier than ever, but overlooking the fine print could cost you. Here’s what to check before you make the move.
-
Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra: What to Know Before You UpgradeThe Galaxy S26 Ultra brings new features and strong launch deals, but whether it’s worth upgrading depends on what you already own.
-
What Is an Assumable Mortgage and Could It Save You Thousands?With mortgage rates still elevated, taking over a seller’s existing home loan could lower monthly payments — if the numbers work.
-
Have You Fallen Into the High-Earning Trap? This Is How to EscapeHigh income is a gift, but it can pull you into higher spending, undisciplined investing and overreliance on future earnings. These actionable steps will help you escape the trap.
-
I'm a Financial Adviser: These 3 Questions Can Help You Navigate a Noisy Year With Financial ClarityThe key is to resist focusing only on the markets. Instead, when making financial decisions, think about your values and what matters the most to you.
-
Where Olympians Store Their Medals is a Great Lesson For Your Valuables and CashWhat you can learn about protecting your cash and values from where Olympians store their medals.
