Capri Holdings (CPRI) stock plunged nearly 50% out of the gate Friday after a U.S. judge on Thursday blocked the luxury retailer's pending $8.5 billion merger with Tapestry (TPR). The deal would have brought Capri's family of brands – Michael Kors, Jimmy Choo and Versace – together with Tapestry's high-end Coach, Kate Spade and Stuart Weitzman segments.
The merger was originally announced in August 2023 and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) moved to block it in April 2024, arguing that "this deal threatens to deprive consumers of the competition for affordable handbags, while hourly workers stand to lose the benefits of higher wages and more favorable workplace conditions."
After an eight-day trial in New York, U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon sided with the FTC and rejected Capri and Tapestry's defense of the deal, according to Reuters. The companies argued that "handbags are nonessential items whose price consumers can control by not buying them if they become too expensive," which the judge said "ignores that handbags are important to many women, not only to express themselves through fashion but to aid in their daily lives."
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
"These bags are a product which millions of people rely on throughout their daily lives," Henry Liu, director of the FTC's Bureau of Competition, told Fashion Dive. "The decision will ensure that Tapestry and Capri continue to engage in head-to-head competition to the benefit of the American public."
The decision "is disappointing and, we believe, incorrect on the law and the facts," said Tapestry in a statement.
The retailers "operate in an industry that is intensely competitive and dynamic, constantly expanding, and highly fragmented among both established players and new entrants. We face competitive pressures from both lower- and higher-priced products and continue to believe this transaction is pro-competitive and pro-consumer," it added.
Capri and Tapestry said they intend to appeal the ruling.
Eric Clark, portfolio manager of the Rational Dynamic Brands Fund, disagrees with the judge's decision.
"We don’t cover the two brands because they weren't relevant enough to make our top 200 brands index, so by definition, this shocking block of the acquisition of CPRI makes zero sense," Clark said in emailed commentary. "These are two marginal brands trying to compete, so they have zero chance to control the handbag market, hurting consumers. This is a clear overreach of government."
Is Capri stock a buy, sell or hold?
Friday's negative price action is nothing new for Capri. Indeed, heading into today's trading, the consumer discretionary stock was down more than 17% for the year to date.
And Wall Street is on the sidelines when it comes to the small-cap stock. According to S&P Global Market Intelligence, the average analyst target price for CPRI is $41.50, roughly in line with its October 25 close but representing implied upside of nearly 85% to current levels. Meanwhile, the consensus recommendation is a Hold.
However, the ratings and price targets on CPRI stock could very well be adjusted in the days and weeks ahead as analysts digest the news of the blocked merger.
Related Content
-
Dow Adds 516 Points on Broad Optimism: Stock Market TodayEasing trade war tensions and promise from early earnings reports has investors looking on the bright side to start the week.
-
Dave Ramsey Tells Us the Biggest Retirement Mistake You Can MakeThe talk-show host, author and podcaster tells Kiplinger what people can do to ensure a happy retirement.
-
Dow Adds 516 Points on Broad Optimism: Stock Market Today
Easing trade war tensions and promise from early earnings reports has investors looking on the bright side to start the week.
-
I'm a Wealth Adviser: These Are the Pros and Cons of Alternative Investments in Workplace Retirement AccountsWhile alternatives offer diversification and higher potential returns, including them in your workplace retirement plan would require careful consideration.
-
I'm a Financial Planner: If You're Within 10 Years of Retiring, Do This TodayDon't want to run out of money in retirement? You need a retirement plan that accounts for income, market risk, taxes and more. Don't regret putting it off.
-
Five Keys to Retirement Happiness That Have Nothing to Do With MoneyConsider how your housing needs will change, what you'll do with your time, maintaining social connections and keeping mentally and physically fit.
-
Six Warren Buffett Quotes Every Retiree Should Live ByThe 'Oracle of Omaha' knows a thing or two about life, investing and retirement.
-
Budget Hacks Won't Cut It: These Five Strategies From a Financial Planner Can Help Build Significant WealthCutting out your daily latte might make you feel virtuous, but tracking pennies won't pay off. Here are some strategies that can actually build wealth.
-
To Unwrap a Budget-Friendly Holiday, Consider These Smart Moves From a Financial ProfessionalYou can avoid a 'holiday hangover' of debt by setting a realistic budget, making a detailed list, considering alternative gifts, starting to save now and more.
-
Stocks Rise to End a Volatile Week: Stock Market TodayThe market's fear index reached and retreated from a six-month intraday peak on Friday as stocks closed the week well.
