Becoming an Investor

How Green Are Your Bonds?

Fixed-income investors can make an environmental impact, too.

If you really want to make an environmental impact with your investment dollars, buy green bonds. These securities fund projects that help the environment, delivering measurable outcomes without sacrificing returns you might earn from traditional bonds. And they are growing like wildflowers. Last year, the global market for green bonds—a fixed-income sector that’s just over 10 years old—surpassed the $1 trillion mark, putting it on par with the U.S. high-yield corporate debt market, says Vishal Khanduja, manager of Calvert Green Bond. This year, the green bond market could top $2 trillion.

Who’s issuing these bonds? Corporations, municipalities and even governments. Bank of America has issued five green bonds since 2013 totaling $6.6 billion. The bonds finance sustainable projects, such as North Star Solar, a Minnesota solar facility built in 2016 that generated enough power for 20,000 homes in its first operational year. France has issued green bonds for clean-energy projects and carbon-free public transportation; Germany issued green government bonds last year. Massachusetts, California and New York are big players. And Fannie Mae is a major issuer. The mortgage agency bundles the loans it makes to retrofit multifamily properties to be more energy-efficient.

Report cards count. In the green bond world, impact reporting is key. Investors want to know precisely how their dollars are improving the environment, says William Sokol, director of exchange-traded fund product management at VanEck. “It’s about how those dollars are being used.”

But picking individual bonds on your own can be problematic. For starters, there can be some confusion as to a bond’s particular shade of green. Green bonds by definition make positive environmental impacts. Social bonds, often lumped with green bonds, have community-oriented goals, such as affordable housing. And sustainable bonds provide both social and environmental benefits.

Green, social or sustainable bonds that are so labeled must meet specific guidelines. These parameters, set by groups including the International Capital Market Association and the Climate Bonds Initiative, define certain green bond requirements, such as what issuers must do to issue a green bond, what kinds of projects are eligible and what, when and how results need to be reported.

But it’s best not to get too caught up with the labels because there’s an even bigger market of unlabeled bonds—securities that don’t fit ICMA or CBI parameters—that make worthy, impactful investments, says Stephen Liberatore, lead manager of TIAA-CREF Green Bond fund. He invests in both labeled and non-labeled green bonds. Labeled or not, each security has to pass muster for the creditworthiness of the issuer and the assets collateralizing the bond, as well as for the use of proceeds, to figure out the beneficial outcome, he says.

It helps to go with an experienced bond picker if you’re investing in this sector. But fund choices are slim. Two of our favorites focus on bonds that help the environment; another two invest in debt that further environmental and social goals. Returns are through February 5.

Brown Advisory Sustainable Bond (symbol BASBX, expense ratio 0.54%, yield 1.25%) Thomas Graff and Amy Hauter invest in a mix of bonds—government and corporate debt, municipals, and mortgage-backed IOUs—that finance projects that make a positive impact in one of three areas: health and well-being, economic development and social inclusion, or the environment.

More than one-fourth of the fund is invested in bonds carrying the green, sustainable and social labels. But the managers also buy non-labeled bonds tied to sustainable goals and bonds issued by organizations that actively solve environmental and social challenges with innovative products or services. The fund owns debt issued by Land O’Lakes, for example, in part because the farmer-owned cooperative has a unit that helps midwestern corn farmers increase efficiency and improve soil health and water quality.

Over the past three years, the fund’s 6.0% annualized return beat the 5.5% gain in the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond index. A mortgage-backed bond the fund owns issued by Lineage Logistics helped the warehousing and logistics company (think cold storage) save $4 million in annual energy costs and cut energy consumption by the equivalent of what 240,000 home refrigerators use per year.

Calvert Green Bond (CGAFX, 0.73%, 0.85%) For every $1 invested in this fund, 38 cents goes toward renewable energy and projects that boost energy efficiency, 22 cents finances green-building retrofitting or construction, and 8 cents backs low-carbon transportation, according to the fund’s fact sheet. The firm behind the fund has a long history of investing with environmental, social and governance measures in mind. But the fund takes extra steps to verify the impact of each security it considers, says Khanduja, who comanages the fund with Brian Ellis.

Over the past three years, Calvert has returned 5.2% annualized, just behind the 5.5% annualized return in the Agg index. The fund carries a 3.75% sales charge, but you can buy shares for no fee or load at discount brokers, including Charles Schwab, Fidelity and TD Ameritrade.

Domini Impact Bond (DSBFX, 0.87%, 1.09%) Green bonds make up just 7% of Domini Impact Bond. One such holding is a Kaiser Foundation Hospitals bond that funds the retrofitting of existing medical facilities so they can earn gold- or platinum-level LEED certification, the highest awards in a building rating system for energy efficiency. But the fund’s other investments help the world in other ways. Manager Campe Goodman, of subadviser Wellington Management, invests across a range of themes, including access to housing, community development and health. A sustainability bond from the nonprofit BlueHub Loan Fund, for instance, finances projects that generate economic opportunity and stability in low-income communities. Over the past five years, the fund’s 4.6% annualized return beat the 3.9% average gain in the Agg index.

TIAA-CREF Green Bond (TGROX, 0.80%, 1.34%) Green investing is “still so sub­jective,” says lead manager Liberatore. In Paris, for instance, nuclear power is considered a clean energy, but other parts of the world might disagree. “What each investor wants varies, so we follow our own approach.”

He and comanagers Jessica Zarzycki invest using a framework Liberatore created with his team years ago. They buy mostly high-quality bonds that deliver a direct and measurable environmental effect. Not every bond in the fund is labeled green, but all make an impact. The fund holds a California water utility bond, for one, that uses solar panels for its wastewater treatment plant. “The panels power the plant, and the utility sells energy it doesn’t use back to the grid,” says Liberatore.

Over the past two years, the fund’s 7.7% annualized return edged the Agg index by an average of 0.7 percentage point. The portfolio’s investments in 2019 generated enough renewable energy to power 17.9 million houses for one year, according to the fund’s latest impact report.

Most Popular

Who Should Return Their Third Stimulus Check to the IRS?
Coronavirus and Your Money

Who Should Return Their Third Stimulus Check to the IRS?

Some people who receive a third stimulus check are required to send it back to the IRS. Others can return it voluntarily.
April 12, 2021
Where's My Stimulus Check? Use the IRS's "Get My Payment" Tool to Get an Answer
Coronavirus and Your Money

Where's My Stimulus Check? Use the IRS's "Get My Payment" Tool to Get an Answer

The IRS has an online tool that lets you track the status of your third stimulus check.
April 4, 2021
11 Good Reasons to Cancel Amazon Prime
Budgeting

11 Good Reasons to Cancel Amazon Prime

You probably aren't using most of the perks tucked into that $119 annual fee -- which you don't need to pay to get the free Amazon shipping you crave.
April 13, 2021

Recommended

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know
Investing for Income

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know

Bonds can be more complex than stocks, but it's not hard to become a knowledgeable fixed-income investor.
July 22, 2020
The 25 Best Low-Fee Mutual Funds You Can Buy
mutual funds

The 25 Best Low-Fee Mutual Funds You Can Buy

The key to building wealth long-term is buying high-quality, low-cost mutual funds run by seasoned stock pickers. Here are our favorites: The Kiplinge…
March 27, 2021
How the Kiplinger 25 Fared in 2020
Kip 25

How the Kiplinger 25 Fared in 2020

Our flock of actively managed funds survived a wild year and as a group delivered benchmark-beating gains.
March 24, 2021
4 Highly Rated Vanguard Dividend and Income Funds
Investing for Income

4 Highly Rated Vanguard Dividend and Income Funds

This quartet of Vanguard dividend and fixed-income funds earn high marks from CFRA. Better still: They can be had for a song.
March 23, 2021