A Surtax on Upper Incomes? Don't Count It Out
But don't dismiss the surtax just yet: It's still a live option for lawmakers struggling to figure out how to pay for overhauling the health care system.
A surtax on upper income taxpayers might look like an idea that's going nowhere, given the firestorm that erupted when a House committee moved to add it the health care reform bill pending in the House.
But don't dismiss the surtax just yet: It's still a live option for lawmakers struggling to figure out how to pay for overhauling the health care system. And even if Congress gives it a thumbs-down this year, be prepared: The surtax idea will be back. Top congressional Democrats have long eyed it as a hefty revenue raiser, and they see it as a way to foot the bill for middle income tax relief.
True, opposition to the pending surtax proposal has been pretty vociferous. That's partly because the proposal -- an extra 1%, 1.5% or 5.4% of income tax on top of what you're already paying, depending on your income -- would start at what opponents say are relatively low levels: Modified adjusted gross incomes of more than $280,000 a year for single taxpayers and modified AGI over $350,000 for couples. (Modified AGI is AGI less amounts that itemizers deduct for investment interest.) Critics argue that owners of unincorporated businesses -- who report their business income on their personal tax returns -- would be hit hard by the surcharge, because $280,000 of modified AGI isn't a king's ransom for a business owner.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
So House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has said she's looking at changing the proposal before it comes to a vote in the House so that the surtax would start at higher levels -- $500,000 of modified AGI for singles and $1 million for married couples. Even at those levels, the surtax faces tough going in the Senate, which has shown no inclination to use that type of levy to pay for health care reform.
But consider this: None of the other big revenue raisers being considered as offsets for the cost of health care overhaul are any less controversial than a surtax. Look at some of the other ideas on the table: Limiting the income exclusion that employees enjoy for their employer-provided medical coverage. Taxing gold-plated health insurance plans. And placing new limits on the itemized deduction for medical expenses. None are gaining any traction. So don't rule out the surtax just yet.
If a surtax does go down in flames this year, why worry that it might resurface? Because the need to raise revenues is only going to intensify down the road, when the Bush tax cuts expire. President Obama and congressional Democrats have made it clear that they want to retain those tax cuts for single taxpayers with taxable incomes of around $190,000 and couples with about $230,000. But to accomplish that goal, someone's ox is going to have to be gored. It's very likely that the ox, in this case, will be the upper-income taxpayer.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
-
These Stocks Dipped in 2025. Do They Have Value?
If you are looking to add new long-term positions to your portfolio, as you should, this is the time to examine stocks that the market shuns.
-
Striking Gold (or Gas): A Financial Pro Unpacks the Nuances of Energy Investing
Investing in the energy industry, particularly oil and gas, involves understanding the facts about how projects generate returns through cash flow and long-term asset building, while also being aware of the risks.
-
Three Popular Tax Breaks Are Gone for Good in 2026
Tax Breaks Here's a list of federal tax deductions and credits that you can't claim in the 2026 tax year. Plus, high-income earners could get hit by a 'surprise' tax bill.
-
Money for Your Kids? Three Ways Trump's ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ Impacts Your Child's Finances
Tax Tips The Trump tax bill could help your child with future education and homebuying costs. Here’s how.
-
Key 2025 Tax Changes for Parents in Trump's Megabill
Tax Changes Are you a parent? The so-called ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ (OBBB) impacts several key tax incentives that can affect your family this year and beyond.
-
2025 SALT Cap Could Hurt Top 'Hidden Home Cost'
Tax Deductions The GOP tax bill could make hidden homeowner costs worse for you. Here’s how.
-
Can Homeschoolers Save on Expenses With 529 Plans?
Savings Accounts A new so-called 'home school tax break' could change how you save for your child's homeschool education. Find out how.
-
Are Clean Energy Tax Credits Going Away This Year?
Tax Credits Now that Trump's mega tax bill has passed, some wonder when energy-efficient incentives, like solar, electric vehicle, and home improvement tax credits, will end.
-
Big GOP Tax Bill Could Change Your Estate Planning for 2025
Tax Law The GOP extended and increased the higher gift and estate tax exemption and affected AMT thresholds. What might this mean for your estate plan?
-
The GOP Wants to Auto-Enroll Your Child in a Trump Account for Savings
Tax Law The federal government will soon auto-enroll your kid in a tax-advantaged Trump Account under the One Big Beautiful Bill