Secure Act Threatens 'Stretch' IRA Rules That Benefit Heirs
Some retirees are concerned about a provision that could require heirs to empty inherited retirement accounts within 10 years and pay a lot more in taxes.
The Secure Act is languishing in the Senate, and some retirement savers are hoping it withers away. The bill, which would overhaul retirement plans, is waiting for a vote by the Senate after receiving a near unanimous vote out of the House in early summer.
But since that House vote, we’ve heard from readers of Kiplinger’s Retirement Report who are alarmed about the bill’s revenue provision, which would take effect in 2020 and essentially kill the “stretch IRA” by requiring many nonspouse heirs to empty inherited retirement accounts within 10 years. For older seniors with established estate plans, “this proposed law would be similar to changing the rules of a baseball game in the eight[h] inning,” one longtime Retirement Report reader wrote.
Under current law, a designated nonspouse beneficiary of an IRA can stretch out required minimum distributions over his or her own life expectancy. The nonspouse heir must retitle the inherited IRA to include both the heir’s name and the deceased owner’s name, and the heir must start RMDs the year following the original owner’s death. That allows the heir to minimize the tax bill by taking withdrawals over his or her lifetime, and it allows more of the money to stay in the account to grow tax-deferred. (To learn more, read How Heirs Can Maximize an Inherited IRA.).
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Under the proposed Secure Act, many nonspouse heirs would instead have to drain their inherited IRAs within a decade. Accelerating inherited IRA payouts diverts thousands of dollars from heirs to Uncle Sam—a disaster in the eyes of the original owners who saved and invested to provide for themselves and their progeny. Forcing nonspouse heirs to make larger taxable withdrawals over 10 years could drive up the tax bill not only on the inherited money but also on heirs’ earned income, too. (To read more about the IRA provisions in the Secure Act, read Secure Act Calls for Changes to IRAs, RMDs).
It’s not just the potential upending of carefully laid out estate plans that worries these readers—it’s the effect on their families. Continued tax-deferred growth of inherited money helps create a sound financial foundation for the next generation. The younger the heir, the more powerful the stretch IRA is because the benefits of compounding increase over time. Another reader lamented the bill would upend his father’s wishes in passing his IRA to his young grandchildren, with his father “anticipating that they would have this money to help with college, perhaps the purchase of a home, and if they only took the required RMDs, eventually their retirement.”
While there are helpful provisions in the bill, such as raising retirement accounts’ required minimum distribution age to 72 from 70½ and repealing the age cap for traditional IRA contributions, a number of Retirement Report readers hope the Senate reconsiders how the Secure Act pays for itself. For other taxpayers who feel the same, share your thoughts with your Congressional representatives in the coming days to ensure your voice is heard before a Senate vote moves forward.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
-
Farewell Paper I-Bonds: Savings Bonds Are Going Online-Only
The last remaining way to buy a paper savings bond in the U.S. (with your income tax refund) won't be available from January 2025. Tax filers will still be able to buy I-bonds online, however.
By Lisa Gerstner Published
-
Is Medicare a Good Reason to Wait Until 65 to Retire?
The average retirement age is 62, but many people wait until Medicare starts at 65. Should health care be the key driver of your retirement date?
By Evan T. Beach, CFP®, AWMA® Published
-
The Problem With 401(k) Catch-Up Contributions for 2024
Retirement Plans New rules governing certain 401(k) catch-up contributions caused confusion and raised concern.
By Kelley R. Taylor Last updated
-
Half of Mothers Have Little or No Retirement Savings
Mother’s Day comes and goes, but many moms face future financial insecurity because they have little or no retirement savings.
By Kelley R. Taylor Last updated
-
Retirees: Cohousing is Growing. Is it Right for You?
This model of housing is designed to increase interaction. For some retirees, this is a draw. But you should know the details.
By Susan J. Wells Published
-
Caregivers Share Their Stories
Caregiving Readers' own perspectives on the struggles and triumphs of caregiving.
By Janet Bodnar Published
-
Now You Can Own Bitcoin in 401(k)s. Should You?
cryptocurrency Fidelity will begin allowing investors to put Bitcoin in their 401(k)s. But is this retirement vehicle the right place to hold crypto?
By Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA Published
-
Start the Elder Care Conversation
long term care Many people don't have a plan set where an elderly parent will go. Do you?
By Janet Bodnar Published
-
The Stresses of Being a Caregiver
Caregiving One study shows that caregiving takes a greater toll on retirees' mental health than on their finances.
By Janet Bodnar Published
-
Honey, We Need to Talk About Money
Women & Money Instead of focusing on the numbers, couples might have more success discussing their goals.
By Janet Bodnar Published