The Housing Market Puzzle

The worst may be behind the battered housing market, but that doesn't mean it will bounce back soon.

Reports released last week showed that housing starts, home sales and median home prices continued to fall. But so far there is no sign of a housing bubble popping, with prices collapsing in major markets, as some feared. There remain pockets of price appreciation across the U.S., even in the Northeast.

First the bad news

The number of new homes started in January slowed to the slowest pace in nine years, according to figures released February 16 by the Commerce Department. Housing starts fell 14.3% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.41 million from 1.64 million in December. The January numbers also reflect a 37.8% drop from the January 2006 pace.

From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance

Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues

CLICK FOR FREE ISSUE

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

The home price report released late last week by the National Association of Realtors also had plenty to worry sellers. The median price of an existing single-family home nationwide showed a 2.7% drop in the fourth quarter of 2006 compared with the fourth quarter of 2005 -- the biggest year-over-year drop in the nearly 30 years the NAR has been keeping track.

Plus, prices went down in more places than they went up. In 73 of 149 metropolitan areas tracked, prices declined, while five remained unchanged. The biggest drops were reported in Florida markets popular with vacationers, where investor-buyers had driven up prices in the latest boom. Hardest hit was Sarasota-Bradenton-Venice, with prices off 18%.

Among entire regions, only the West was in positive territory, buoyed by price increases in Oregon and Washington State and even a few California cities. Median prices in the West as a region edged up 0.4%. In the Midwest, prices dropped 4.2%, in the South they slipped 3.7% and in the Northeast they were 2.5% lower. See our table of home prices in 149 metropolitan areas.

More bad tidings: Nationwide, total existing-home sales, including single-family homes and condos, were down 10% from the fourth quarter of 2005 (and nearly 18% in the West).

On the other hand, nearly half of the markets gained ground in the past year, suggesting that plenty of metro areas are sidestepping the slump. Fourteen metro areas had double-digit increases, including Atlantic City, N.J. (where prices increased a robust 26%), Salt Lake City (up 23%), Trenton-Ewing, N.J. (19%) and Beaumont-Port Arthur, Tex. (15%), according to the Realtors.

Is it over yet?

The NAR put a positive spin on the numbers, stating in a report accompanying the data that all the signs point to the final bottoming out of a protracted housing slump over the last year. David Lereah, NAR's chief economist, wrote: "2006 was the year of contraction. When we get the figures for this spring, I expect to see a discernable improvement in both sales and prices."

But those outside the real estate business aren't so sure. Patrick McPherron of Moody's Economy.com sees several issues standing in the way of an imminent upswing. For one thing, Wall Street firms and banks are clamping down on mortgage lenders whose shaky underwriting has resulted in defaults, making it harder for some borrowers to qualify for a loan this year. Also, money is extra tight in the mortgage market -- ARM rates are very close to those of 30-year fixed-rate mortgages -- and the Fed is holding fast to the federal funds rate, which props up rates on ARMs.

And a recent survey by the National Association of Home Builders put builder confidence at 40. Fifty is the tipping point where more builders view sales conditions as positive rather than negative. "Though the NAHB survey bounced up, it's still the lowest optimism rating since 1991," says McPherron. "People are not as pessimistic as they were, but they're not exactly optimistic."

What's next?

Economy.com sees the market remaining flat at best throughout 2007. Buyers see it as a buyer's market, although sellers aren't necessarily cooperating with price reductions. So while buyers are waiting for prices to come down, sellers remain stubbornly attached to high home prices, hoping for their part to wait out the drought.

Numbers from March, when the spring selling season traditionally hits its stride, will be a good indicator of which way the market will go from here. One bright spot is the relatively low rates on 30-year fixed mortgages, still below 6.5%. Assuming sellers relax prices enough, buyers with good credit will have good reason to take the plunge. But it should take awhile longer for such corrections to take hold in the housing market.