Don't Trust a Pie Chart to Test Diversification

When the next market downturn comes, many investors who think they're protected may be surprised. Merely being invested in different types of stocks and bonds isn't good enough anymore.

As we approach the end of yet another incredible year of market gains, investor confidence sits at the highest it has been in 17 years, according to the recently released Investor and Retirement Optimism Index.

It is hard not to be confident, considering the S&P 500 index is up almost 300% since its low point back in March 2009. Even more incredible is the fact that 2017 has been the least volatile year in over 50 years.

But with confidence also comes complacency … and now is definitely not the time to be complacent. I meet with investors every day and ask some basic questions to identify whether I can provide any value to the current situation.

“What is your current strategy to help mitigate investment losses?”

“Can you show me some specific examples of diversity within your portfolio?”

“What is the maximum loss of money you can tolerate at this point in your life?”

These are just a few examples of how I learn about potential client priorities as well as the missing elements in their existing plans. Most investors point to a “pie chart” found on the first few pages of their quarterly statements. Sometimes they have several statements from several different companies, each with their own pie chart.

The Pie Chart Problem

What do all those slices of pie really mean? Do more pies, and more slices, imply greater diversity?

It is important to understand that diversification isn’t designed to boost returns. Unfortunately, for many investors, the pie chart can be misleading. The goal of “diversification” is to select different asset classes whose returns haven't historically moved in the same direction and to the same degree; and, ideally, assets whose returns typically move in opposite directions. This way, even if a portion of your portfolio is declining, the rest of your portfolio is more likely to be growing, or at least not declining as much. Thus, you can potentially offset some of the impact that a poorly performing asset class can have on an overall portfolio. Another way to describe true diversification is correlation. We want to own asset classes that are not directly correlated.

Unfortunately, even though a pie chart may make it look like an investor is safely diversified, it’s probably not the case. They are probably much more correlated to the market than they realize. Making matters worse, investors with multiple different families of mutual funds often own the exact same companies across the different families. We call this phenomenon “stock overlap” or “stock intersection.” You may own 10 different mutual funds, but the largest holdings in each fund are the same companies.

There was a fascinating study done in the late 1970s by Elton and Gruber. They concluded that a portfolio’s diversity stopped improving once you had more than 30 different securities. In other words, increasing from one or two securities up to 30 had a big improvement. Increasing from 30 all the way up to 1,000 different securities didn’t materially improve the portfolio’s diversity.

Consider that the next time you open up your quarterly statement. How many mutual funds do you really own? How many individual stocks are inside all of those mutual funds?

The Problem with the Stock-Bond Solution

Most investors attempt to mitigate risk by allocating a portion of their portfolio to equities and a portion to bonds. The “60/40” allocation, with 60% in equities and 40% in bonds, has been popular for decades. Unfortunately, according to Morningstar, over the past decade a 60/40 portfolio has a .99 correlation to a 100% equity portfolio.

In other words, the bond portion dilutes overall returns while providing little to no diversity. When you take into account we are in a rising interest rate environment, the 60/40 allocation makes even less sense.

How about overseas? Again, Morningstar data shows that back in the 1980s there was a low correlation (0.47) between U.S. equities and international equities. That correlation has steadily increased to 0.54 in the 1990s all the way up to 0.88 in the 2000s.

So, What Do You Do Instead?

If we can’t use bonds or overseas equities to diversify, what can we use?

Portfolio diversifying instruments (PDIs) provide actual asset class diversification by reducing correlation to the stock market.

What are some examples of PDIs?

  • Private equity. Some non-traded real estate investment trusts offer durable distributions with low volatility and low correlation.
  • Private debt. Some non-traded debt investments offer high yields and a hedge against rising interest rates. Many are secured with an asset to protect against default.
  • Interval funds. Registered as a mutual fund, these investments can be purchased daily and sold at the end of each quarter (hence the term “interval” fund). These offer distribution rates in excess of 5% with very little downside participation.
  • Some annuity solutions. Index annuities provide principal protection and guaranteed rates of return as well as low fees.

Instead of taking 40% of your life savings and investing in bonds that seem to be paying less and less and are still at risk to interest rate hikes and defaults, we prefer to invest in asset classes that thrive in a rising interest rate environment. Real estate is an example of one of these asset classes, and there are more ways to access real estate than ever before. In fact, according to a recent PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) forecast, investments in PDIs will more than double by 2025. If accurate, this can present an incredible opportunity for some investors if they want to truly diversify.

The biggest challenge for most is finding an adviser with extensive experience working with various PDIs. If your portfolio is market based, and you are hoping your “pie chart” is going to save the day, now is not the time to be complacent. As 2018 gets underway, dedicate some time and meet with an independent financial adviser with experience working with all asset classes.

Ronnie Blair contributed to this article.

Securities offered through Kalos Capital, Inc. and investment advisory services offered through Kalos Management Inc., both at 11525 Park Woods Circle, Alpharetta, Georgia 30005, (678) 356-1100. Verus Capital Management is not an affiliate or subsidiary of Kalos Capital, Inc. or Kalos Management, Inc. This material is educational in nature and should not be deemed as a solicitation of any specific product or service. All investments involve risk and a potential loss of principal.

About the Author

Mike Haffling, Investment Adviser Representative

President and Founder, Verus Capital Management

Mike Haffling is president and founder of Verus Capital Management in Chicago. Mike is an Investment Adviser Representative and insurance professional. He has always worked as an independent financial adviser, serving his clients with a comprehensive approach to retirement planning for more than a decade.

The appearances in Kiplinger were obtained through a PR program. The columnist received assistance from a public relations firm in preparing this piece for submission to Kiplinger was not compensated in any way.

Most Popular

4 Steps to a Happy Single Retirement
happy retirement

4 Steps to a Happy Single Retirement

The number of seniors who are single and childless is growing. This group needs to be purposeful as they think about their health and finances and fos…
April 8, 2021
Where's My Stimulus Check? Use the IRS's "Get My Payment" Tool to Get an Answer
Coronavirus and Your Money

Where's My Stimulus Check? Use the IRS's "Get My Payment" Tool to Get an Answer

The IRS has an online tool that lets you track the status of your third stimulus check.
April 4, 2021
37 Ways to Earn Extra Cash in 2021

37 Ways to Earn Extra Cash in 2021

We flag a wide variety of cool side hustles to earn bonus bucks to cover expenses expected and unexpected as we begin to emerge from the pandemic lock…
April 8, 2021


How to Retire Well During Difficult Times
retirement planning

How to Retire Well During Difficult Times

When the financial environment is challenging (like now) it’s important to plan ahead and avoid some all-too-common retirement mistakes.
April 11, 2021
Don’t Make the Same Mistakes in 2021 – Keep Your Retirement Plan on Track
retirement planning

Don’t Make the Same Mistakes in 2021 – Keep Your Retirement Plan on Track

Looking back at 2020 gives retirement savers a good perspective for how to proceed going forward. Staying flexible and being prepared to change course…
April 11, 2021
10 Questions Retirees Often Get Wrong About Taxes in Retirement

10 Questions Retirees Often Get Wrong About Taxes in Retirement

You worked hard to build your retirement nest egg. But do you know how to minimize taxes on your savings?
April 7, 2021
Don’t Let Retirement Planning Faze You: What to Focus on in Each Phase
retirement planning

Don’t Let Retirement Planning Faze You: What to Focus on in Each Phase

When you think about all the moving parts to planning for retirement, it can feel overwhelming. But breaking it down into four phases could help bring…
April 5, 2021