Investor Psychology

Ignore Your Gut Instincts When Investing

If you’re like most people saving for retirement, your gut may very well steer you wrong.

One of the smartest things you can do as an investor is to stop making moves based on your gut instincts. You will probably become a much better investor, because studies show your portfolio is likely to perform better if you avoid excessive trading.

It’s tough to ignore these impulses when stocks are turbulent, up one day and down the next. But if you’re trying to time the market based on hunches — your own or those you hear from friends, family or media “experts” — you could be setting yourself to make the wrong investment decisions, causing your investments to underperform.

Emotional decisions are usually bad decisions; after all, no one ever intends to sell low or buy high. But that’s what can happen to investors who are working without an investment plan or who stray from their plan because they get nervous or greedy.

According to Dalbar, the consulting firm known for its annual “Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior” studies: “No matter what the state of the mutual fund industry, boom or bust: Investment results are more dependent on investor behavior than on fund performance. Mutual fund investors who hold on to their investments are more successful than those who try to time the market.”

Every year Dalbar compares the returns of investors to benchmark indices over various periods of time, and the differences are significant. In the 30-year period ending December 2016, for example, the S&P 500 averaged 10.16%, while the average active equity fund investor earned 3.98% annually.

Now, I know what you’re thinking — and you’re right: Part of that discrepancy is due to fees. But the big difference, Dalbar points out every year, is the timing decisions investors make. Here are some of the mistakes I see investors make over and over:

1. They fall prey to “recency bias”

When it comes to investing, their gut tells them to buy when the market is going up — and to buy the funds that have been going up recently. They also tend to avoid the stocks and funds that have been doing poorly, assuming things will continue to occur just as they have been. But of course, that’s not how it works.

With a 24/7 news cycle and today’s global market, seemingly any little thing can change an investment’s value overnight. If you see a blogpost that says, “5 Funds to Buy This Year,” it’s probably based on the five funds that did the best last year. NO ONE knows how they’ll do in the future.

2. They feel the need to make adjustments

Generally, there is no need to make major adjustments over the short term. Investors should have a long-term time horizon. Otherwise, every downturn can seem potentially devastating, and the temptation to sell can be overwhelming.

During the financial crisis of 2008, there actually was a spike in Google searches for chest pains, headaches and ulcers. People became physically ill as they watched their accounts lose value. They needed to feel better, and the way to feel better was to get out of the market.

The problem with that is that most investors lack a definitive re-entry strategy. What is the plan to resume your investment strategy? When your gut tells you it’s time? When your nerves calm down after a year on the sidelines? When you see the market has been up 20% for six months?

If you don’t have an exit and re-entry strategy, your best bet is to simply sit tight and wait for your investments to rebound.

3. They don’t understand volatility or their personal risk tolerance

Managing a client’s investment behavior is a financial professional’s most important role. Your adviser should help you create a portfolio that’s adequately diversified, mitigates risk and keeps volatility low, so you can enjoy the returns from your investments instead of bailing out too soon.

How soon is too soon? The reason the S&P 500 consistently outperforms investors in the Dalbar study is because most investors are unable to endure the market’s volatility.

Warren Buffett’s advice is to “Only buy something that you’d be perfectly happy to hold if the market shut down for 10 years.”

To get the rewards of the stock market, you need to be able to ride out the volatility, but everyone has their limits. Know yours. You should understand going into any investment what the risks and possible range of returns are so that in a worst-case scenario you aren’t surprised. I believe that’s your best shot at remaining disciplined.

4. They don’t know where else to go with their money

People often think they’re “diversified” if they have a few different mutual funds. But a truly diverse portfolio combines traditional investments (with some high- and some low-volatility choices), alternative investments (real estate, commodities, private equity, etc.) and insurance products (indexed annuities and modified endowment contracts). Some investments are correlated to the stock market and some are not.

Most 401(k) plans have limited investment options, so investors may have to utilize non-retirement assets to balance out their portfolios.

5. They aren’t paying attention to their personal timeline

The closer you get to retirement, the more you’ll need to consider wealth preservation over accumulation. It’s critical that you protect the money you’ll need for income when your paycheck goes away. It’s OK to remain aggressive with some of your funds if you have other assets that will keep that income flowing when (not if) the market takes a dip. But if your savings are limited, you should be dialing down the volatility in your portfolio as you get older.

The best way to avoid these mistakes is to make and stick to a financial plan. Knowing where you’re going and how you’re going to get there can make the journey far less challenging.

Start with products and strategies that suit your needs. Talk to your adviser and assess the pros and cons. And every time you’re tempted to make a change, resist those impulses and stick to your plan.

Kim Franke-Folstad contributed to this article.

About the Author

Keith Singer, CFP, Attorney

President, Singer Wealth Management

Keith Singer, owner and president of Singer Wealth Management (www.singerwealth.com), is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™. His firm, Singer Wealth Advisors, is a Florida registered investment adviser. Mr. Singer is also a licensed Florida attorney. He is the host of the radio show "Prosper! With Keith Singer," which currently airs on five stations in South Florida.

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021
healthcare stocks

11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021

The 2020s could be the decade of healthcare stocks. Here are 10 companies and one ETF to watch not just for the remainder of this year, but well beyon…
July 13, 2021
Warning: You May Have to Pay Back Your Monthly Child Tax Credit Payments
Tax Breaks

Warning: You May Have to Pay Back Your Monthly Child Tax Credit Payments

Unlike stimulus checks, you might have to repay your monthly child tax credit payments if you get too much money from the IRS.
July 16, 2021

Recommended

Are You Itching for an Earlier-Than-Expected Retirement?
retirement planning

Are You Itching for an Earlier-Than-Expected Retirement?

Lots of folks are pulling the rip cord on their careers sooner than they had initially planned. Before you rush to join them, make sure you are really…
July 30, 2021
Readers Find Some Weird Winners
Investing for Income

Readers Find Some Weird Winners

Most of the time, I find flaws in offbeat investments with high distributions. But sometimes oddities have their day of glory.
July 30, 2021
I Still Like the Trillion-Dollar Stocks
Becoming an Investor

I Still Like the Trillion-Dollar Stocks

Unlike the highfliers of the late 1990s, these trillionaires make tons of money.
July 29, 2021
How to Play the High-Yield Rally
Becoming an Investor

How to Play the High-Yield Rally

Junk bonds have been on a tear, so this fund has shifted to defense.
July 29, 2021