Advertisement
Politics

Can Obama Survive Health Care Shock?

Other presidents have attempted to tackle health care, faced midterm losses, but prevailed.

Forget what you've heard about Social Security being the third rail of American politics, the issue that does in politicians who dare to touch it.

The real killer issue is health care. It has helped doom more political careers than Social Security ever did -- and not just this year.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Three times since the end of World War II, Democratic presidents in their first term have offered sweeping changes in the health care system. All three times, Republicans followed with huge midterm election gains, taking control of both chambers of Congress twice and winning back the House once -- this year.

First came Harry Truman. Shortly after Franklin Roosevelt died and Truman took over, he proposed universal health care. Then came the 1946 midterm elections, and the GOP picked up 55 House seats and 12 Senate seats to grab majorities in both chambers.To be sure, there were plenty of other reasons that "To err is Truman" became a popular Republican refrain: postwar labor strikes, a debate over whether and when to end price controls, and the fact that he wasn't FDR. But health care was a pivotal piece of the puzzle, as former President Bill Clinton noted decades later.

"The effort virtually destroyed Truman's presidency, driving his approval ratings below 30 percent and helping the Republicans gain control of the Congress," Clinton wrote in My Life, his 2004 memoir.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

Clinton became something of an expert on the dangers of health care, learning the hard way that a sweeping reform effort carried a huge cost. “I knew the whole enterprise was risky,” Clinton recalled. But he went forward anyway, ahead of the 1994 midterms.

And?

“On November 8, we got the living daylights beat out of us, losing eight Senate seats and fifty-four House seats, the largest defeat for our party since” -- you guessed it -- Harry Truman. Again, a first term Democratic president was left to grapple with Republicans running Congress and the prospect of his own reelection effort running into the ground.

This time, of course, it was Obama who chose to ignore the cautionary tales of health care's dangers. He got further than either Truman or Clinton, actually getting a comprehensive bill through Congress and signing it into law -- at the expense of dozens of Democrats who backed him.

Advertisement - Article continues below

There is one silver lining for Obama, and it’s potentially a big one. Although Republicans took over the House, the fact that Democrats managed to hang on to control of the Senate means Obama won't be faced with outright repeal of what was supposed to be the signature issue of his first term.

But that doesn’t mean Republicans won’t try. In fact, they’d be silly not to try, given exit polls showing about half of voters favoring repeal of all or some of the provisions -- and similar findings in postelection surveys of all adult Americans. Even if Republicans come up short, the attempt will keep the issue alive that much closer to the 2012 elections.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Obama shares more with Truman than just lopsided losses in Congress from touching health care. Both faced members of their own party wanting them to sacrifice their own careers.

In Truman's case, Arkansas Sen. William Fulbright called on him to appoint a Republican as secretary of state, then resign. Under the succession law then in place, that Republican would have become president because the vice presidency was vacant.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In Obama's case, Democratic pollsters Douglas Schoen and Pat Caddell said in a postelection op-ed in The Washington Post that Obama should, for the good of the country, announce he would not seek a second term. Less severe than quitting, no doubt, but still a career killer.

Truman ignored Fulbright's advice and won a full term of his own in 1948. Obama also should ignore Schoen and Caddell. He might not win a second term in 2012, but his numbers aren’t dismal enough to warrant pulling the plug on himself.

Consider this: In a Pew Research Center poll the week before the November elections, 47% of respondents said that Obama should run for a second term. Not a great number, perhaps, but better than the 36% who said at the same point in his term that Ronald Reagan should run again, and a tad more than the 44% who said that about Clinton.

They both cruised to reelection.

Advertisement

Most Popular

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays
Markets

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays

Is the market open today? Take a look at which holidays the stock markets and bond markets take off in 2020.
July 1, 2020
What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?
tax brackets

What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?

The IRS unveiled the 2020 tax brackets, and it's never too early to start planning to minimize your future tax bill.
June 20, 2020
Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire
Empty Nesters

Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire

We home in on two places with less traffic and lower costs. 
July 2, 2020

Recommended

Travel Planning in the Time of Coronavirus
business

Travel Planning in the Time of Coronavirus

Insurance may not cover canceled vacations, but airlines and hotels may be flexible.
June 11, 2020
13 Things That May Soon Disappear Forever (The Pandemic Edition)
business

13 Things That May Soon Disappear Forever (The Pandemic Edition)

Emerging technologies (and now the COVID-19 pandemic) are putting an end to these familiar items and practices.
June 9, 2020
Don't Let the Drama Surrounding PPP Distract You from Running Your Business
business

Don't Let the Drama Surrounding PPP Distract You from Running Your Business

If you're so wrapped up in worry about your Paycheck Protection Program loan not being forgiven, think about the worst-case scenario. It might not be …
June 5, 2020
Another Epidemic to Worry About: Identity Theft
business

Another Epidemic to Worry About: Identity Theft

Fraud losses grew in 2019 and are likely to increase in 2020.
June 5, 2020