Money Smart Kids

Build Credit Without a Credit Card

There are alternative ways you can establish credit and learn financial responsibility before getting your first card.

By Janet Bodnar, Editor, Kiplinger's Personal Finance

March 19, 2008
Text Size T T

Advertisement

  • I am a senior in high school. How can I get a credit card when I turn 18?

  • I need a computer for college. It's going to cost about $2,000. I don't have the money, so I was thinking about getting a credit card.

  • I am 18 and am planning to move out, but I still don't have a bank account. What can I do to apply for a credit card?

I'm always amazed that so many young people think they're automatically entitled to a credit card when they turn 18. If we've learned anything from the credit woes afflicting so many Americans, it's that credit isn't an entitlement; it's a privilege and a responsibility.

And judging by the questions I get (like those above), it's a responsibility that most 18-year-olds aren't mature enough to handle. If you can't afford to buy a computer with cash, you can't afford to buy it on credit.

And if you don't know how to manage a bank account, you aren't ready for a credit card. As readers of this column know, I firmly believe that young people need to learn how to manage cash before they get credit, first with an ATM card, then with a checking account and a debit card. (See Financial Milestones for Kids and Best Time for First Credit Card for more.)

Getting credit generally isn't a problem for college students. Card issuers are happy to sign them up because Mom and Dad are still in the wings to bail them out if necessary.

It can be tougher if young people are on their own and have no credit history, but it's getting easier. Fair Isaac, which compiles the FICO credit score, has also developed its Expansion Score, which uses nontraditional information, such as how an applicant pays for rent and other recurring bills.

You can also build your own payment history at Payment Reporting Builds Credit, an alternative credit bureau that gathers data on rent and recurring payments for cable, cell phone, insurance, utility and other bills. Enter your info into a Web file, which PRBC charges a fee of $15 to $20 to verify, or set up an automatic bill-payment system through your bank or credit union and have the records sent to PRBC.

The surest way to get credit if you don't have it is to apply for a secured card at a site such as Credit.com or CardTrak.com. With a secured card, you make a savings deposit equal to your credit limit. Secured cards generally charge high interest rates plus an annual fee. Steer clear of cards that have setup fees.

But after paying your bills on time for about a year, you could qualify for unsecured status and better terms. Or you can apply for a different card. And putting money into a savings account reinforces the point that credit isn't an entitlement.

Discuss

Reader Comments (6)

Posted by: Tim Wilding at 03/19/2008 04:52:00 PM

Why worry about "building a credit score" A credit score is a "I love being in debt" number. Plan ahead, do a monthly budget, save your money and pay cash for everything (yes even a car). When you go to buy a house, go to a bank that does manual underwriting and you will get the best rate, because you are not in debt. This has worked GREAT for me for over 15 years.

Posted by: Janet Bodnar at 03/19/2008 06:45:59 PM

Thanks for your comment, Tim. Would you be willing to be interviewed for an upcoming story Kiplinger's is doing on living debt-free?

Posted by: Charles A. at 05/01/2008 04:45:43 PM

How does one even begin to find a bank that does manual underwriting?? -- I've spent my entire life on a cash-only basis, and now that my (newlywed) wife & I are looking to buy a house, we can't seem to get anywhere. Her credit is terrible and mine is non-existent! Any insight that can be offered would be greatly appreciated.

Posted by: jennifer at 09/04/2009 08:46:20 PM

Hello charles, i have the same problem, we had credit cards and quickly lived without them but now that we are much more educated about credit than before now we have the same issue that you guys are facing, i have a credit score but hardly any credit and my husband has about $1,000 in debt and none of them are credit card debts the largest one was from a loan company. We can't get any credit now and don't know how to go about it. It seems that everyone gets advice if you have credit cards but what if you don't?

Posted by: Kitty W at 09/30/2009 04:56:40 PM

I have always felt like I never got any credit for paying rent. It's not really fair, because I can't get "credit" for paying my rent in order to qualify for a mortgage. It is like you have to go into debt just to build credit. Seems silly. I just signed up for a rent payment service - you pay your rent through them and they report the payment automatically to a credit bureau. It is called williampaid.com.

Posted by: Joya at 11/01/2009 04:33:02 AM

hi I just wonder why I'm still not approved to get credit card like sears...My father in law get loan for me in the bank to build my credit for almost 3 years now. And I make a payment on time and never late payment...but I really try to get a credit cards to build more credit but they dont approve me what can i do to get credit cards i dont really care how much the limit as long i can start build my credit more...but i had public records I already disputed it...its say deleted on my credit history...

Today's Video More Videos >>

Extra Cash for the Holidays

E-mail Alerts: Select the Kiplinger columns and topics to be delivered to your inbox:

Advertisement