From now through August, 17 states are having sales tax holidays for back-to-school shopping. Tax-free days are times when shoppers don’t have to pay state sales tax on certain items up to a certain dollar amount. That can be helpful since the average household is expected to spend around $890 on supplies this year, according to the National Retail Federation. But what if your state isn’t offering this tax relief?
It turns out that some states have pulled the plug on sales tax holidays; we’ll dive deep into this issue, cover whether sales tax-free periods help or hurt, and explore some other ways to save you and your family money.
Sales tax holiday history
Georgia, New Jersey, and Illinois have officially discontinued their tax-free holidays, yet for states that still have them, it may be impossible for residents to imagine them gone. But the sales tax holiday as we know it, is a modern trend.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
New York was the first state to hold a sales tax holiday on clothing. The idea was to stop cross-border shopping. As one of the states with the highest sales tax in the country, New York was losing revenue to its adjacent competitor — New Jersey. New Yorkers were driving across state lines to take advantage of the Garden State’s lower tax rate.
To combat this, New York offered its first sales tax holiday 27 years ago — it was an immediate success. In fact, it was so successful that then New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani announced a second sales tax holiday that same year.
In a release, the former Mayor’s office stated, “This surge in retail activity is proof that the elimination of the sales tax is a success. The permanent elimination of the tax will save New York City families hundreds of dollars each year, increase retail sales, and add thousands of jobs to our local economy.”
Local franchisees like TJ Maxx and Old Navy submitted their approval.
However, what if Giuliani’s goals weren’t transferable to other states? He wanted a permanent end to sales tax in NYC, yet his policy stayed temporary and spread. Does a temporary tax holiday hold merit?
Through a modern-day lens, data and some studies suggest sales tax holidays may not effectively promote economic growth nor significantly help families in need.
Are tax holidays effective?
Critics of sales tax holidays argue that the events don’t promote an overall increase in sales. According to the nonprofit policy organization, Institute of Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), households earning more than $30,000 in income were likely to shift the timing of their purchases to coincide with a tax holiday.
This finding is backed by a study by the Federal Reserve which concluded there was a shift in the timing of purchases, rather than an increase in purchases. So what does that mean? While a few individual households may splurge more during the holiday, tax-free weekends generally shift the timing of purchases that would have occurred anyway.
Canceled sales tax holidays in some states
Sales taxes are typically a regressive tax (one flat rate regardless of individual income), meaning folks who make less income cannot take advantage of a sales tax holiday as much as their higher-income counterparts. In other words, households with lower incomes don’t have the flexibility to shift the timing of their purchases.
Additionally, sales tax holidays are expensive — expensive for states to administer, expensive for states to hold, and potentially more expensive for shoppers. One research institute in Ohio finds that this year’s expanded tax holiday will cost the state $740 million.
Lost revenue is one of the reasons Louisiana repealed its sales tax holiday in 2018, while states like Wisconsin and Illinois only held their tax-free periods for one year.
New Jersey tax holiday canceled. Earlier this year, New Jersey also repealed its sales tax holiday. You heard correctly - despite being the reason we have this tax relief, the Garden State has officially ended its offering.
- New Jersey's tax holiday was implemented just two years ago. And it was ten days long.
- Interestingly, instead of scaling back the holiday to a weekend, the Garden State ended it thirty days before the holiday's anniversary.
State officials cite cost as the main reason the state ended the tax holiday. The total cost for 2024 was projected to be $35 million. So while New York is concerned over losing shoppers to New Jersey, NJ is not so worried about losing out to the Big Apple State.
Other reasons states might cancel their tax holidays include:
- Shoppers “border hopping” from neighboring states to take advantage of a sales tax holiday in another state (ironic, we know)
- Retailers hiking prices in response to the expected increase in sales, diminishing consumer benefit in the sale
- The administrative costs of holding the holiday becoming significant to the state
Taking advantage of potential tax credits
So if state lawmakers decide a tax-free holiday is not worth the cost in your state, what other options do you have? One way your family can potentially save on taxes is by claiming eligible tax credits and deductions. Some of these are available at the state and federal levels. Talk with a trusted tax professional to see if you qualify for the following, or other, tax breaks.
Earned Income Tax Credit. This is a refundable tax credit for low- to middle-income taxpayers. To claim this credit, you cannot make investment income over a specified amount and must meet other income qualifications.
Child Tax Credit and the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit. These are two separate tax credits. The Child Tax Credit is a tax break for qualifying taxpayers with children under 17. The Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit is for qualifying taxpayers with children under 13.
American Opportunity Tax Credit. This is an education tax credit designed to help students or parents of students pay for four years of higher education. This credit is partially refundable.
How to save on taxes
Purchase items that are sales tax-free. Many states have some form of sales-tax-exempt product, and it’s good to know yours. For instance, in North Dakota, digital products like music and video can be purchased sales tax-free. Other states are sales tax-exempt on items like textbooks, clothing, livestock, diapers, and chocolate. Yes, you heard that right - chocolate!
Another great way to save is by downloading an app or browser extension to help manage money. For example, there are investment apps like Acorns, which invests spare change on purchases you make. Or, you can try Honey — a free extension that will scan your webpage and offer coupons it finds across the internet.
Lastly, keep tabs on your local legislation. With property tax rates rising, you may be eligible for a tax break.
- For instance, New Jersey has a property tax freeze program for qualifying residents.
- Additionally, Nebraska recently proposed legislation that could cut property taxes by $145 million.
Staying abreast of state tax changes and new proposals can help you determine the next best move for your family. After all, that is why sales tax holidays began in the first place - border-hopping.
Related Content
-
Why Uber Stock Is Volatile After GM's Cruise AnnouncementUber stock is swinging this week following news that General Motors is restructuring its Cruise unit. Here's what you need to know.
-
UnitedHealth Stock Falls as Lawmakers Eye Insurers, PBMsUnitedHealth stock is continuing to fall Thursday after the introduction of bipartisan legislation targeting PBMs and healthcare giants. Here's what to know.
