Tax Breaks

How to Measure the Impact of Your Charitable Donations

Apply the same due diligence to giving as you would to investing.

If a mutual fund sales rep called during dinner to give you his spiel, you’d probably hang up or insist that he send a prospectus outlining the fund’s management, portfolio and performance relative to its peers.

A group of former hedge fund managers, tech entrepreneurs and academics have applied the same no-nonsense approach to philanthropy. Effective altruism focuses on charities doing the most good for the least amount of money.

The movement was pioneered by GiveWell, a nonprofit founded in 2007 to support underfunded organizations that can provide evidence that their programs produce results. One of its top charities, Against Malaria Foundation, buys and distributes insecticide-treated malaria nets. The nets, which cost AMF between $5.30 and $7.50 each, save thousands of lives in developing countries. And AMF can scale up quickly. “It’s easy to see that if you give them more money, they’re going to spend it on more bed nets,” says GiveWell research analyst Sean Conley.

Supporters of effective altruism tend to favor small charities such as AMF because it’s easy to determine whether they’re making a difference. They also prefer charities that focus on the developing world because small amounts of money can make a huge difference in the lives of people who may live on less than $2 a day.

Whether you give to charities across the street or around the world, you can adopt some of GiveWell’s ideas to make your own philanthropy more effective.

Limit your disaster giving. Major natural disasters, such as earthquakes and floods, trigger an outpouring of donations. But in the aftermath of a catastrophe, aid organizations are often unable to use all the money. Within days after the 2011 tsunami in Japan, for example, the Japanese Red Cross said it didn’t need donations. A better idea: Give to charities that provide treatment for chronic diseases, such as malaria and tuberculosis, that kill thousands of people every day.

Focus on impact, not overhead. Charity watchdog groups often rate organizations based on the amount they spend on administrative costs versus programs. That seems logical: Donors don’t want their money used to pay for excessive salaries and plush offices. But such ratios (which are usually self-reported) discriminate against charities that invest wisely in tools and expertise. When you invest in a company, you look at whether it makes a good product, not how much it spends on operations, says Oxford University professor William MacAskill, author of Doing Good Better: How Effective Altruism Can Help You Make a Difference.

Overhead is only one of several measures that Charity Navigator, the largest watchdog site, uses to evaluate a charity, says chief executive Michael Thatcher. A planned update of the site’s rating system will include a way to quantify whether a charity gets results.

Look to the future. Savvy investors know that past performance is no guarantee of future returns. That applies to charities, too. A charity may already have enough in reserve to fulfill its mission, or it may be so small that it’s unable to spend more money effectively. Whether a group has “room for more funding” is one of the criteria that GiveWell uses to rate its top charities.

Most Popular

Don’t Be Tricked Into Voluntarily Paying Higher Taxes on Your IRA
IRAs

Don’t Be Tricked Into Voluntarily Paying Higher Taxes on Your IRA

Traditional IRAs are set up in a way that basically incentivizes you (and your heirs) into paying the highest tax bill possible. Don’t fall for it. Co…
July 4, 2022
Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
Retirees, Make These Midyear Moves to Cut Next Year's Tax Bill
Tax Breaks

Retirees, Make These Midyear Moves to Cut Next Year's Tax Bill

Save money next April by making these six hot-as-July tax moves.
July 1, 2022

Recommended

Should I Hire an Estate Planning Attorney Now That I Am a Widow?
estate planning

Should I Hire an Estate Planning Attorney Now That I Am a Widow?

Many estates are simple enough where no help is needed, but there are several situations where anyone would be much better off getting some profession…
July 5, 2022
How to Use Your Estate Plan to Save on Taxes While You’re Still Alive!
estate planning

How to Use Your Estate Plan to Save on Taxes While You’re Still Alive!

Upstream basis planning is a trust strategy that can save wealthy people on their capital gains taxes and income taxes associated with highly apprecia…
July 3, 2022
Retirees, Make These Midyear Moves to Cut Next Year's Tax Bill
Tax Breaks

Retirees, Make These Midyear Moves to Cut Next Year's Tax Bill

Save money next April by making these six hot-as-July tax moves.
July 1, 2022
Biden Proposes Gas Tax Holiday, Urges States to Do the Same
Tax Breaks

Biden Proposes Gas Tax Holiday, Urges States to Do the Same

The proposed three-month federal gas tax holiday would bring down the price of gasoline slightly, while state gas tax holidays could reduce the price …
July 1, 2022