Q: I asked a local antiques dealer to come to my house and make me an offer on some old furniture and china. He bought several things, and I later heard that he sold one of them at auction for a fabulous sum -- many times what he paid me.
When I complained to him about it and asked for a share of his profit, he refused, saying that I seemed pleased with the price he offered me at the time. Was this right?
Legally? Probably. You didn't invite him to your home to do a written appraisal of your goods, which would have legally obligated him to research your antiques and tell you their fair market value. You accepted his offer without duress and were free to get an appraisal or solicit offers from other dealers.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
But did he act ethically? No, regardless of whether he knew at the time just how valuable your item was. If he discovered its true worth later (but before putting it up for auction), an ethical dealer would have contacted you to discuss what he had learned -- not offering to return your merchandise, but to share with you some portion of the future profit.
If the dealer recognized the high value of your antique the moment he saw it in your home, then he was taking advantage of you to buy it for so little. (Note, however, that reputable dealers typically pay 30% to 50% less than retail value, to provide enough markup to cover their costs of doing business -- rent, interest on inventory loans, travel, advertising and so on -- and leave them a profit.)
An ethical dealer thrives on positive feedback and referrals from satisfied customers, developing a reputation for fairness in both buying and selling. But this dealer is a sharpshooter who apparently doesn't care.
A corollary issue: Does an amateur antiques hunter who spots a rare, severely underpriced item at a private garage sale or estate sale have an ethical obligation to inform the seller of its true worth? No, but I have heard of people who do just that out of consideration for the seller, offering to pay much more than the price on the item -- but still less than full retail.
Send your own money-and-ethics question to editor in chief Knight Kiplinger.
-
Stocks Keep Climbing as Fed Meeting Nears: Stock Market TodayA stale inflation report and improving consumer sentiment did little to shift expectations for a rate cut next week.
-
Your End of Year Insurance Coverage Review ChecklistStop paying for insurance you don't need and close coverage gaps you didn't know about with this year-end insurance review.
-
Crypto Trends to Watch in 2026Cryptocurrency is still less than 20 years old, but it remains a fast-moving (and also maturing) market. Here are the crypto trends to watch for in 2026.
-
21 Last-Minute Gifts for Grandparents Day 2025 to Give Right NowHoliday Tips Last-minute gifting is never easy. But here are some ideas to celebrate Grandparents Day.
-
Texas Sales Tax-Free Weekend 2025Tax Holiday Here's what you needed to know about the Texas sales tax holiday.
-
Alabama Tax-Free Weekend 2025Tax Holiday Here’s everything you need to know about the 2025 back-to-school Alabama sales tax holiday.
-
The Sweet 23: States Where Twix and Kit Kat Avoid the ‘Candy Tax’State Taxes There’s something spooky this Halloween, and it’s not just the ghouls. Find out if your state’s sales tax takes a bite out of sweet savings.
-
Florida Back-to-School Tax-Free Holiday 2025Sales Taxes The new tax-free holiday in Florida brought month-long savings on computers, clothing and other school supplies.
-
Five Reasons You Shouldn't Shop Amazon's Prime Big Deal DaysSmart Buying Are Amazon Prime Big Deal Days still a good deal? We'll break it down.
-
Best Cash Back Credit Cards of 2025Credit Cards If you're searching for a credit card that rewards you for everyday purchases, we've chosen the best.
-
How to Spend $1,000: Find Cheap (or Free) Online Courses to Build Career SkillsSmart Buying There's a huge array of skill-building online courses that can level up your career for under $1,000.
