A Health Care Temptation to Avoid
It's understandable that the Obama administration and some Democrats find the idea of using a parliamentary tactic to try to push a health care reform bill through Congress nearly irresistible.
It's understandable that the Obama administration and some Democrats find the idea of using a parliamentary tactic to try to push a health care reform bill through Congress nearly irresistible. Using the peculiar budget device known as "reconciliation" means they would need only a simple majority in the Senate -- rather than the filibuster proof 60 needed in most cases. And it would be perfectly fitting since the same Republicans who are screaming "foul" about the tactic now had no problem using it in 2001 and 2003 to pass the Bush tax cuts that most Democrats opposed.
But it's a bad idea that could poison ties with Republicans, including many of those willing to work with Democrats on health care and other issues, and potentially produce a bad law.
Perhaps the strongest argument against using reconciliation is the obverse of the only reason to use it -- requiring that a health reform plan have broad support. When it comes to legislation of such significance every effort should be made to build a broad consensus. And while many Republicans may be crying crocodile tears, simply using a tactic because the other guys did it is playground logic, not legislating. Beyond that, it borders on arrogance to spurn the support and ideas of Republicans who have worked on health care issues for years. Sen. Bob Bennett of Utah, for example, has drafted a bipartisan bill with Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., that could be drawn on for reform legislation. For the record, Bennett says using reconciliation would "sour" relations.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
If reconciliation were used as the vehicle for a health bill, it would only be authorized for the life of the budget -- 10 years. That is why many of Bush's tax cuts are expiring next year. That would be a terrible constraint on a measure that is supposed to change the shape of health care reform for decades to come.
Fortunately, Senate Democrats seem far more leery of the prospect than those in the House. The Senate Budget Committee hasn't included it in the early drafts of the budget, and several influential Democratic senators flatly object to including health reform under reconciliation.
That said, it's easy to see why Obama and the Democrats want don't want to take reconciliation off the table just yet. The threat of using it if Republicans refuse to engage on health care can be a useful bargaining chip. And keeping the option on the table also underscores the central message that Obama wants to send while Congress works on the budget -- any number of things can be modified or cut, but not health care.
To continue reading this article
please register for free
This is different from signing in to your print subscription
Why am I seeing this? Find out more here
-
Stock Market Today: Nasdaq Soars Ahead of Tesla Earnings
The EV stock rose nearly 2% ahead of its highly anticipated Q1 earnings report, due after tonight's close.
By Karee Venema Published
-
GM Stock Accelerates After Earnings Beat
General Motors beat expectations for the first quarter and raised its outlook for the year. Here's what you need to know.
By Joey Solitro Published
-
How Three New Supreme Court Rulings Impact Your Money
Supreme Court U.S. Supreme Court decisions could directly impact your bank account privacy, student loan payments, home equity, and property taxes. Here’s what you need to know.
By Kelley R. Taylor Published
-
Are Student Loans Being Forgiven or Not?
Student Loans The House and Senate voted to repeal President Biden’s student loan forgiveness plan, but does it even matter?
By Katelyn Washington Last updated
-
Etsy, eBay, PayPal Want IRS 1099-K Relief for Online Sellers
Income Tax Companies like eBay, Etsy, and PayPal want Congress to raise the $600 reporting threshold for IRS Form 1099-K to give relief to millions of sellers who use their sites.
By Kelley R. Taylor Published
-
Student Loan Forgiveness Blocked For Now Due to Court Rulings
Biden's student loan debt forgiveness program is on hold until the U.S. Supreme Court weighs in.
By Kelley R. Taylor Published
-
Student Loan Refunds Are Real, But You Might Not Be Eligible
student loans Since President Biden announced student loan debt relief, there has been a lot of talk about student loan refunds, which surprisingly have been around for a little while.
By Kelley R. Taylor Last updated
-
Student Loan Forgiveness: What You Need to Know
Student Loans Millions of people with student loans will not receive Biden's student loan forgiveness due to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling.
By Kelley R. Taylor Last updated
-
How Congress Might Ease the Pilot Shortage
travel Congress is debating how to fix the current pilot shortage, and one idea revolves around retirement age.
By Sean Lengell Published
-
Forgiven Student Loan Debt Will Be Tax-Free
Coronavirus and Your Money President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion stimulus package lays the groundwork to forgive some student loan debt.
By Emma Patch Published