Iconic Estate Flops: What Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston and Prince Did Wrong

Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston and Prince were icons whose sudden deaths shocked the world and left their families brokenhearted and burdened with fees and estate taxes. Despite having professionals manage almost every aspect of their lives, none of these artists succeeded in implementing a comprehensive estate plan, costing the heirs millions of dollars in avoidable legal fees and taxes.

An estate plan is crucial for the peaceful transfer of assets from one generation to the next. While your estate probably doesn't include things like music rights or private amusement parks, you can glean key takeaways from each artist’s situation to avoid making the same costly mistakes.

Michael Jackson

Michael Jackson died in 2009, and the exact value of his estate is still being debated in tax court today. Jackson was prepared enough to leave a will, and his business-savvy attorney and executors parlayed the estate to an estimated $1 billion in value for his heirs.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

However, at the time of his death, Jackson’s executors valued the “Michael Jackson brand” — Jackson’s name and image — at a mere $2,105 (opens in new tab). Given the widespread merchandising of Jackson’s image since his death, the IRS claimed his name and image should’ve been valued at $434 million. The dispute over the value of assets could result in a $700 million estate tax bill.

Key Takeaways:

Valuating unique assets isn’t required to be 100% accurate, but if you’re going to guess, use common sense. Everyone knows facets of the Michael Jackson brand — his face, his name, the glove, the moonwalk, etc. — would sell more than $2,105 worth of goods and products. An estate tax filing should be representative of the value of a deceased person’s assets on the day of their death. If you have unique assets within your estate, such as intellectual property, patents, art or antiques, then it’s a good idea to have an accredited third-party appraisal completed.

One thing Jackson did exceptionally well was the strategic choice of executor of his estate: entertainment attorney John Branca and music executive John McClain, a pair with the professional experience needed to get the job done. A lesson to implement is choosing the executors of your estate with careful consideration. Don’t select a person for this role solely on kinship or relationship, but consider their résumé and skills. Analyze the nature of your assets and select a capable person who has experience with those types of assets. For example, if the majority of your wealth is tied up in real estate, than choose an executor with real estate experience. A combination of law, business and/or investment backgrounds is a great starting point.

Prince

Unlike Michael Jackson, Prince’s estate assets were valued appropriately and all necessary taxes were paid without any audits from the IRS. However, Prince left no will when he died.

Since he had no known children, there was no obvious heir. As a result, more than 45 people claimed to be potential heirs — including siblings, half-siblings, nieces and even supposed children — costing the estate tremendous amounts in legal fees.

Prince’s estate also suffered from the lack of a committed and capable executor. There’s been poor management and a revolving door of administrators (three to date). This has led to decreased asset value, and the estate has been unable to monetize the renewed interest in the artist.

Key Takeaways:

When an individual doesn’t have a traditional heir or offspring, there are many alternatives available, like nieces, nephews or even charities. The key is informing them while you are still alive of your intentions and goals. This gives them time to prepare and ask the right questions.

Although Prince’s estate had enough liquid assets to pay the estate tax and hasn’t been audited by the IRS, most estates have to sell assets in fire sales to pay the required estate tax. Make sure you have enough liquid assets to pay your estate tax if you’re over the exemption (which in 2018 will be $5.6 million per individual for federal tax purposes, although for states that impose taxes, it can be much lower). Immediately paying the tax reduces penalties and interest. A unique tool that provides liquidity at time of death is life insurance, whether it's personally owned or by an irrevocable life insurance trust.

Whitney Houston

Whitney Houston’s estate planning did include a will, establishing a sole heir — her daughter, Bobbi Kristina Brown — and contingent heirs. With heirs in place, the execution of the will would appear to be cut-and-dried. However, more than five years after Houston’s death, her estate is still being settled.

Houston’s will left her estate to her daughter, but it required the money to be doled out in installments at certain ages — 10% at age 21, 30% at age 25 and the remainder at age 30. The will also stipulated that if Bobbi Kristina Brown died childless and unmarried before age 30, the remaining estate would go to the contingent heirs, Houston’s brothers and mother. Brown passed away in July 2015 at age 22, leaving behind no will for her own estate, which included the 10% she had already received of Houston’s estate.

One might assume this would not be a problem, considering Houston named contingent heirs in case of her daughter’s death, but without her own will in place, Brown’s next-of-kin — her father, Bobby Brown — has a claim to inherit her entire estate. This has caused frequent disputes between the parties involved.

Key Takeaways:

When designing an estate plan, you have to honestly analyze and assess your heirs and relatives. You should be aware of potential conflicts with and between certain parties, as well as any special-needs planning required. Houston's estate would’ve been a perfect plan, but it didn’t account for the special needs of her daughter, even though Houston was aware she struggled with drugs.

One thing Houston’s estate did well was the level of detailed language her trust had regarding when and the amount of assets set to be disbursed. Having specific language like this removes the need for interpretation and reinforces your intentions, values and goals for your heirs.

The Importance of Estate Planning

Establishing a complete estate plan, with a trust, will and qualified executors, is an important part of legacy planning. While most people do not have future royalties accruing and image rights to worry about, proper estate planning provides peace of mind, reduces intra-family feuding and saves money in terms of taxes, penalties and legal fees. Learn from the mistakes of these iconic stars, and start your estate planning today.