I'm a Fiduciary, But I Don't Like the Fiduciary Rule
The rule, which aims to curb conflicts of interest for those who give financial advice, could mean some small clients and advisers could get squeezed out.


I’m a fiduciary, and proud of it. I like that my clients know I always put their best interests first when I’m working with their hard-earned money, and I take that responsibility seriously.
Still, I can’t say I’m happy that the Department of Labor’s long-delayed fiduciary rule finally went into effect on June 9, a little over two months after President Trump delayed its implementation for more study.
The rule emphasizes eliminating conflicts of interest among financial professionals. Until now, some financial professionals, such as brokers, were required to act under only a suitability standard. The products they recommended needed only to be “suitable” to the client’s goals and objectives given their current situation, meaning that it was OK to recommend products that were suitable but that came with higher fees or expenses – from which the adviser could earn some extra money. Now, under the fiduciary rule, the advice they give for your retirement accounts is required to be in your best interest, not their own.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
One thing to keep in mind: The rule applies only to your retirement accounts: those funded with pre-tax dollars, such as your IRA and 401(k), but not individual brokerage accounts.
Problems from the Start
If you’re not sure what standard your financial professional is working under, ask. But there have been problems from the start with the way the rule came to be, the way companies are executing it and what it means to consumers.
That the regulation was delivered by a federal agency and pushed by the past administration, circumventing Congress’ opposition, is troubling.
It isn’t as though the problems the rule addresses haven’t been on Congress’ radar. Alternatives had already been proposed. And it’s possible there would be fewer objections if the changes had gone through the proper channels.
The financial services industry opposed the DOL rule from the beginning — arguing that it would make retirement planning too expensive for middle- and lower-income individuals seeking professional guidance. And yet, in fits and starts, the rule moved toward reality, and the industry began changing to deal with it. Large and small firms started reinventing themselves and how they do business.
Small Clients Being Squeezed Out
Already, we’ve seen companies raising their minimums; if you don’t have enough in your portfolio to make it worth the work, and you’re not paying those commissions and fees anymore, you may have a difficult time finding a good financial professional. Existing clients could have to look elsewhere for help, and new clients may have to go where their account size is welcomed or become do-it-yourselfers.
The level of advice an individual receives should not be based on the size of their retirement portfolio. And DIYers will be facing a market due for a correction. They could ruin their retirement if they don’t get it right.
And now that the rule has come to pass, I think firms will use it as a marketing angle. They’ll say, “We’ve been waiting for this, and we’re ready.” But they won’t be there for everyone.
Pressure on Financial Professionals
And every adviser won’t be around, either. New costs, compliance obligations and other issues associated with the rule will force some financial professionals out of business. And a lot of older, experienced financial professionals may decide to retire rather than deal with the educational requirements, not to mention the thought of what could happen if a client decides they should have done better and takes the case to court.
So you’ll see options disappearing for lower-income individuals, but also any individual who simply prefers working with the financial professional they’ve always had, in the manner they’ve grown used to.
My Final Take on the Fiduciary Rule
I’ve been a fiduciary for more than 20 years, and I think it’s the best way to conduct business. But there are problems with the DOL rule that I believe need fixing.
As President Trump said in his Feb. 3 memorandum ordering a review of the rule, further analysis is in order.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Christopher A. Murray is a professional financial adviser, insurance professional and president of the Maryland-based Murray Financial Group. He is a Certified Fund Specialist, Board Certified in Mutual Funds and a Certified Senior Consultant. Murray has produced and hosted the weekly "Your Financial Editor" radio show for 17 years and provides daily business and financial market updates. He is an active member of the National Press Club and has contributed to several publications, including "The Wall Street Journal."
-
Higher Summer Costs: Tariffs Fuel Inflation in June
Tariffs Your summer holiday just got more expensive, and tariffs are partially to blame, economists say.
-
Don’t Miss Alabama Tax-Free Weekend 2025
Tax Holiday Ready to save? Here’s everything you need to know about the 2025 back-to-school Alabama sales tax holiday.
-
New SALT Cap Deduction: Unlock Massive Tax Savings with Non-Grantor Trusts
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act's increase of the state and local tax (SALT) deduction cap creates an opportunity to use multiple non-grantor trusts to maximize deductions and enhance estate planning.
-
Know Your ABDs? A Beginner's Guide to Medicare Basics
Medicare is an alphabet soup — and the rules can be just as confusing as the terminology. Conquer the system with this beginner's guide to Parts A, B and D.
-
I'm an Investment Adviser: Why Playing Defense Can Win the Investing Game
Chasing large returns through gold and other alternative investments might be thrilling, but playing defensive 'small ball' with your investments can be a winning formula.
-
Five Big Beautiful Bill Changes and How Wealthy Retirees Can Benefit
Here's how wealthy retirees can plan for the changes in the new tax legislation, including what it means for tax rates, the SALT cap, charitable giving, estate taxes and other deductions and credits.
-
Portfolio Manager Busts Five Myths About International Investing
These common misconceptions lead many investors to overlook international markets, but embracing global diversification can enhance portfolio resilience and unlock long-term growth.
-
I'm a Financial Planner: Here Are Five Smart Moves for DIY Investors
You'll go further as a DIY investor with a solid game plan. Here are five tips to help you put together a strategy you can rely on over the years to come.
-
Neglecting Car Maintenance Could Cost You More Than a Repair, Especially in the Summer
Worn, underinflated tires and other degraded car parts can fail in extreme heat, causing accidents. If your employer is ignoring needed repairs on company cars, there's something employees can do.
-
'Drivers License': A Wealth Strategist Helps Gen Z Hit the Road
From student loan debt to a changing job market, this generation has some potholes to navigate. But with those challenges come opportunities.