Advertisement
Markets

Skill Versus Luck in Investing

Having a disciplined investment strategy in place can help increase your odds of success.

Have you ever looked through a kaleidoscope? You know, one of those tube-shaped objects with mirrors and colored glass that make beautiful patterns when you rotate it? I'm going to ask you to try looking at your world differently, and consider the various roles that luck and skill play in almost every outcome. We're going to use a new tool, a "skilleidoscope," that will help us identify where skill is actually present.

In his book, The Success Equation, Michael J. Mauboussin explains how events are affected by both luck and skill, and how to determine the impact of each on an activity or outcome. I highly recommend it to anyone with a curious mind and suggest adding it to your list of mental models. The examples the book cites are delineated by life, business, sports and investing. As a financial planner, I am primarily interested in how Mr. Mauboussin's conclusions apply to the world of investing.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Over the last few decades, theories in finance have focused on identifying factors that are predictable and can help us decide which particular investments give us a better chance at succeeding. Succeeding in investment management usually means getting a return commensurate with the risk we bear or a better return than what is expected by comparing to a reliable benchmark.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

The biggest controversy these days is the "active versus passive" debate. Passive is defined as low-cost, highly liquid investments such as index mutual funds and low-activity exchange traded funds (ETFs). These funds generally require little day-to-day management and generally just try to match a published index. Therefore, their management fees are very low.

Active funds involve managers and teams attempting to do better than their benchmarks through different strategies, such as using sector weighting, focused portfolios, segments of the market, style investing, global investing, etc. They tend to have relatively high management fees. The argument is that if you are paying those higher fees, you should expect better results. Otherwise, why spend the money paying for active management? And that is a common sense position, particularly when you realize that over periods of time, very few actively-managed funds outperform their benchmarks.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The Success Equation attempts to break out the element of skill from luck in investing. The author has developed what he calls the "luck versus skill continuum," as shown below, based on extensive statistical analysis.

Thinkstock

You can readily see where investing fits on this scale—unfortunately near the "pure luck" endeavors (as is the world of business, where he makes the case that a CEO experiencing success at one firm is hardly assured of success at his or her next venture).

Some of the factors that influence our perception of success in investing include the following:

  1. Time frame: Someone with a lousy process can end up winning in the short run due to pure luck. Our tendency is then to project this lucky outcome into the future, and the probability of failure is the same as it was prior to the last "success."
  2. Bad luck overcoming skill: An accomplished money manager with a thorough and informed process can fail in the short run due to events outside of his or her control (i.e. dividend stocks gain favor at the expense of non-dividend payers; interest rates affect the market; investors run the technology sector through the roof at the expense of more solid companies; market sentiment shifts to small companies; etc.).
  3. Limitations of good luck: A manager possessing a high skill level and is the beneficiary of good luck is suddenly faced with the eventuality of that luck running out. His or her returns are bound to revert to the mean or average.
  4. Confusing compensation with skill: Incentives and rewards can reinforce a bad process. Think of the manager who is compensated for return and associates the return with skill when it is really the result of a lucky stretch for his or her style of investing (i.e. internet stocks in the late '90s and the proponents of "new and better" valuation metrics).
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

Added to the fact that we have largely efficient markets, we also have an increasingly growing pool of highly-skilled talent in the investment business. It is therefore becoming extremely difficult for any one manager to outperform his or her benchmark on a consistent basis.

At a meeting in Chicago last year, I had an opportunity to ask Dr. Eugene Fama, the father of the efficient market hypothesis, how we can explain those few standouts, such as Warren Buffet, if the markets are truly efficient and remove any potential for outperformance (amongst all participants combined). He answered that there are those few who have the requisite talent and skill to add value over time, but the problem is that we don't know who they are in advance, nor how long their advantage will last, so trying to select them is an exercise in futility.

So where does this leave us? Is there any hope in finding outstanding managers and investment opportunities? I would answer that there is, but you have to have a repeatable and disciplined process in place, and not deviate from it. Mr. Mauboussin also recommends that you use checklists to stay consistent in your approach.

In conclusion, I highly recommend reading this book and starting to apply its concepts in your everyday life as soon as possible. It will make a profound difference in how you see the world.

Doug Kinsey is a partner in Artifex Financial Group, a fee-only financial planning and investment management firm based in Dayton, Ohio.

About the Author

Doug Kinsey CFP®, CIMA®, AIFA®

Partner, Artifex Financial Group

Doug Kinsey is a partner in Artifex Financial Group, a fee-only financial planning and investment management firm based in Dayton, Ohio.

Doug has over 25 years experience in financial services, and has been a CFP Certificant since 1999. Additionally, he holds the Accredited Investment Fiduciary and Accredited Investment Fiduciary Analyst certifications as well as Certified Investment Management Analyst.  He is a graduate of The Ohio State University and also the University of Chicago Booth School of Business Investment Management Education Program.

Advertisement

Most Popular

What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?
tax brackets

What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?

The IRS unveiled the 2020 tax brackets, and it's never too early to start planning to minimize your future tax bill.
June 20, 2020
Tax Changes and Key Amounts for the 2020 Tax Year
tax law

Tax Changes and Key Amounts for the 2020 Tax Year

Americans are facing a long list of tax changes for the 2020 tax year...and it's never too early to start thinking about next year's return.
June 22, 2020
10 Tax Breaks for the Middle Class
tax deductions

10 Tax Breaks for the Middle Class

Tax breaks aren't just for the rich. There are plenty of them that are only available to middle- and low-income Americans.
June 30, 2020

Recommended

Closing Bell 7/8/20: Tech Stocks Lead Wall Street Forward Again
Markets

Closing Bell 7/8/20: Tech Stocks Lead Wall Street Forward Again

U.S coronavirus cases continue to spike, but Apple helped lead another Big Tech rally to drive the major indices higher Wednesday.
July 8, 2020
Closing Bell 7/7/20: Nasdaq's 5-Day Win Streak Snapped
Markets

Closing Bell 7/7/20: Nasdaq's 5-Day Win Streak Snapped

A broad-market downturn Tuesday ended the Nasdaq's five-day win streak and sent economically sensitive industries to deep losses.
July 7, 2020
The Bull Run Is Over: It’s Time To Replace Luck with a Plan
investing

The Bull Run Is Over: It’s Time To Replace Luck with a Plan

It’s not hard for investors to look good during a bull market, but now comes the real test.
July 7, 2020
Closing Bell 7/6/20: U.S. Stocks Grab the Baton From China
Markets

Closing Bell 7/6/20: U.S. Stocks Grab the Baton From China

A surge in Chinese equities, as well as a massive improvement in services-sector data, lifted U.S. stocks and sent the Nasdaq to new highs Monday.
July 6, 2020