Switch in May and Go Away? A New Twist on an Old Investing Strategy
Taking advantage of seasonal market anomalies could boost your stock returns.
For years, investors have puzzled over a striking stock market anomaly. Stocks tend to make their healthiest gains in the six months from November through April. In the other months, stocks tend not to do so well. Thus, the aphorism, “Sell in May and go away.”
Since 1926, Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index has returned an average of 13.4%, including dividends, from November through April. From May through October, the S&P 500 has returned just over half as much, averaging 6.8%. (All returns in this article are through April 30, 2017, unless otherwise noted.)
The strategy, which I’ve written about before, has been noted by investors at least since 1935 and has been shown to work in 81 of 108 stock markets around the world.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
A big drawback to Sell in May: What do you do with your money in the seasonally weak six months? After all, stocks, on average, do still rise in those months, just not as dramatically.
Now, there’s another, more practical strategy. It involves investing in the S&P 500 for the seasonally weak six months and owning small-cap stocks the other half of the year. It turns out that the seasonal tendency of stocks to outperform in the winter and early spring is much stronger in small-company stocks than in large-company stocks.
Since 1926, an index of small-cap stocks tracked by the Leuthold Group, a Minneapolis investment research firm, has returned an average of 21.2% from November through April. That’s a huge gain. What’s more, small caps have averaged a puny 2.1% the other half of the year. (All the numbers in this article are courtesy of Leuthold. The small-cap returns are from Ibbotson, a Morningstar unit, through 1979; the Russell 2000 index thereafter.)
By investing in a small-cap index from November through April, then switching to the S&P, an investor would have earned an annualized 13.8% since 1926. By comparison, investing in a small-cap index for the full year returned an annualized 11.3%; the S&P returned an annualized 10.1%.
Such a switching strategy would have outperformed the S&P in 56 of the last 91 years. The average outperformance in the winning years works out to 12.3 percentage points, and the average underperformance in losing years is 7.0 percentage points. Last year, the strategy was up 15.4% versus 12.0% for the S&P.
But there’s still a dilemma: I know that virtually no one will really implement the traditional Sell in May strategy. The same goes for the Switch in May strategy outlined in the last few paragraphs. Why? Let’s face it: The anomaly makes no sense. It’s as crazy as the old (and now failed) Super Bowl anomaly that called for a good year in stocks if a team from the old National Football League won. What’s more, there are taxes and trading costs to consider.
“Fascinating,” says Doug Ramsey, Leuthold’s chief investment officer, of the switching strategy. “But not something we currently use for managing money.”
Still, you can profit from this anomaly by tilting your portfolio more toward large caps during the seasonally weak months and more toward small caps during the seasonally strong months. That’s easier to do in a retirement account where capital-gains taxes aren’t an issue. Or, you can tweak your contributions to favor small caps in strong months, or your withdrawals to reduce large caps over the same period. That’s something any investor can do.
But maybe not for long, says Ramsey: “By the time the behavioral-finance people figure out why it works, it’ll probably disappear.”
Steve Goldberg is an investment adviser in the Washington, D.C., area.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
-
Stock Market Today: Dow Logs Longest Losing Streak Since April
The November Producer Price Index showed that inflation remains a tough beast to tame.
By Karee Venema Published
-
Why Uber Stock Is Volatile After GM's Cruise Announcement
Uber stock is swinging this week following news that General Motors is restructuring its Cruise unit. Here's what you need to know.
By Joey Solitro Published
-
Fed Cuts Rates Again: What the Experts Are Saying
Federal Reserve The central bank continued to ease, but a new administration in Washington clouds the outlook for future policy moves.
By Dan Burrows Published
-
Fed Goes Big With First Rate Cut: What the Experts Are Saying
Federal Reserve A slowing labor market prompted the Fed to start with a jumbo-sized reduction to borrowing costs.
By Dan Burrows Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Retreat Ahead of Nvidia Earnings
Markets lost ground on light volume Wednesday as traders keyed on AI bellwether Nvidia earnings after the close.
By Dan Burrows Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Edge Higher With Nvidia Earnings in Focus
Nvidia stock gained ground ahead of tomorrow's after-the-close earnings event, while Super Micro Computer got hit by a short seller report.
By Karee Venema Published
-
Stock Market Today: Dow Hits New Record Closing High
The Nasdaq Composite and S&P 500 finished in the red as semiconductor stocks struggled.
By Karee Venema Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Pop After Powell's Jackson Hole Speech
Fed Chair Powell's Jackson Hole speech struck a dovish tone which sent stocks soaring Friday.
By Karee Venema Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Drop Ahead of Powell's Jackson Hole Speech
Sentiment turned cautious ahead of Fed Chair Powell's highly anticipated speech Friday at the Jackson Hole Economic Symposium.
By Karee Venema Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Rise After Jobs Data Lifts Rate-Cut Odds
Preliminary data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows job growth was lower than previously estimated.
By Karee Venema Published