Markets

Which Market Gurus Get It Right the Most?

A study finds that market pundits have less than a 50/50 chance of getting it right.

Are market seers worth their salt? When forecasters are considered as a group, the answer is no.

That's the conclusion one draws from a study by CXO Advisory Group, a Manassas, Va., provider of market research and analysis. CXO, which recently completed an eight-year examination of gurus' market calls, found that on average the prognosticators were right 47% of the time—slightly worse than pure chance. Steve LeCompte, CXO's founder, gathered the 6,584 individual forecasts single-handedly. To simplify the process, he considered only calls about the performance or direction of U.S. stocks.

LeCompte also graded individual pundits. At the top of the list is David Nassar, an author of how-to books on day trading, who scored 68% accuracy. However, Nassar's grade is based just on an 18-month period between 2004 and 2006, when he wrote a column for MarketWatch.com (gurus were graded over different periods based on when each was active). In second place, with a 67% accuracy rate, is Jack Schannep, who publishes TheDowTheory.com. He is a technical analyst, which means he forecasts market movements by studying charts and patterns. Ken Fisher, a money manager and Forbes columnist, comes in third, with a 65% score. Fisher earned points for correctly advising investors to steer clear of stocks during the worst of the 2000–02 bear market, but he lost points for being overly bullish in 2008.

Big-name gurus are scattered throughout the rankings. Mad Money host Jim Cramer posted a 47% accuracy rate (LeCompte focused on Cramer's written calls by tracking a column he used to write for New York magazine). Bob Doll, chief stock strategist for Nuveen Asset Management, beat the average with 55% accuracy. Abby Joseph Cohen, a well-known strategist for Goldman Sachs, managed only 35% accuracy based on her calls from 1998 to 2011. At the bottom of the list is Robert Pretcher, a proponent of the so-called Elliott-wave theory of technical analysis, who got it right just 22% of the time. (Read the full report.)

Most Popular

The Perfect Storm for Retirees
retirement planning

The Perfect Storm for Retirees

Today’s retirees could face a perfect storm because they are living longer and spending more time in retirement, while at the same time losing access …
April 18, 2021
The Wrong Way to Achieve Wealth
personal finance

The Wrong Way to Achieve Wealth

For some down-to-earth, basic advice on money and life, I have a book to recommend: “Your Total Wealth: The Heart and Soul of Financial Literacy.”
April 17, 2021
Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs
Coronavirus and Your Money

Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs

People have lots of questions about the new $3,000 or $3,600 child tax credit and the advance payments that the IRS will send to most families in 2021…
April 14, 2021

Recommended

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know
Investing for Income

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know

Bonds can be more complex than stocks, but it's not hard to become a knowledgeable fixed-income investor.
July 22, 2020
What You Need to Know about College 529 Savings Plans
529 Plans

What You Need to Know about College 529 Savings Plans

Do you know how much you’re able to contribute or what the funds could be used to pay for? How about how contributing affects your taxes? Check out th…
April 14, 2021
7 Ways to Save Money When Shopping Online
Smart Buying

7 Ways to Save Money When Shopping Online

Shopping online has long been a popular option. In these times, it’s increasingly a must. Here’s how to save money when filling your cart with the cli…
March 23, 2021
6 Money-Smart Ways to Spend Your Third Stimulus Check
Coronavirus and Your Money

6 Money-Smart Ways to Spend Your Third Stimulus Check

If you don't have to use your third stimulus check for basic necessities, consider putting the money to work for you. You'll thank yourself later.
March 20, 2021