Advertisement
Financial Planning

4 Ways the Fiduciary Rule Could Hurt (Not Help) Investors

The financial advice that retirement savers get going forward could suffer from some unintended consequences of the Department of Labor’s efforts to protect them.

Good intentions don’t necessarily guarantee good results.

The basic idea behind the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule is good: to protect consumers seeking retirement advice by requiring advisers to put their clients’ best interests ahead of their own profit when making recommendations regarding their retirement savings.

I’m a fiduciary, and I wish every person giving financial advice acted under this standard, part of which took effect June 9. But I worry the rule, as it’s written, will cause more harm than good – that advisers will be hobbled and investors could be hurt. Here’s why:

Advertisement - Article continues below

Advisers might start hedging their advice. If a fiduciary doesn’t offer the mandated level of service, there can be serious ramifications – including potential civil and criminal penalties. There’s a sense in the industry that the new rule may make investors more litigious, which means advisers could decide to shield themselves by offering advice that’s more defensive for themselves than purposeful for the investor.

Management styles could become homogenous. It’s a lot easier to fail conventionally than to succeed by differentiating yourself. Innovative ways of growing and, more significantly, diversifying a portfolio (tactical management, for example, or investments that go beyond stocks, bonds and mutual funds) could be overlooked if advisers worry clients will balk at the first sign of flatness. They’ll likely go with recommendations that seem safer and less expensive. For example, passive indexing as an investment style has performed well recently, but it’s only one option among many and may not be well-suited for every client or every economic cycle.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

“Recency bias” may become more of a factor. Investors and advisers can have selective memory when it comes to the ups and downs of the markets. Unless you’re a retiree whose nest egg was wiped out in 2000 when the dot-com bubble burst, you may not even remember the effect it had on the market. Even the 2008-2009 global recession seems to have been forgotten by many. It’s already a challenge, in this bull market, to get soon-to-be retirees to let go of a portfolio mix that’s too risky or to convince retirees that it’s better to lose less than to gain more.

The negative feedback loop could get even louder. Advisers should be prepared for the event that even if their clients don’t question what they’re doing, a friend or someone in the media likely will. (Thanks to the Internet, everyone is an expert these days – and possibly pushing their own newsletter or blog.) Let’s say an adviser recommends an active fund that pays a commission. It may be cheaper net to the client for the commission to be paid than an ongoing fee, yet if a client believes a commission is high (and not all individuals know what a high fee is) due to what he or she has seen or heard, the client may make a decision contrary to his or her best interests. Mathematically, a 5% upfront commission on a seven-year account or time frame costs a client less than 1% per year, but if a client is spooked because we now have to disclose we get an upfront commission, he or she may choose not to contribute at all, even if it’s the prescription the individual needs.

Now, will the rule change things for the better? I hope so. I hope small brokers will stay in business and all variety of clients will be able to be accommodated. This rule will cost money; it just needs to go back to the clients’ pocket where it belongs, not get invisibly deducted from their future earnings due to poor implementation of new practices. At the end of the day, people have different expectations and goals. They have different fears. And all of these different options we have were created to accommodate consumers’ various needs.

It would be a shame for an adviser to fail to do more for clients because of a rule designed to protect them.

Kim Franke-Folstad contributed to this article.

Advertisement

About the Author

Michael Fritts, Investment Representative

Investment Adviser Representative, Fritts Financial

Michael Fritts is a licensed insurance agent with Fritts Financial, based in Knoxville, Tenn. Michael is an Investment Advisor Representative with Brookstone Capital Management, a Registered Investment Adviser. He received a bachelor's degree from Columbia College in Chicago, where he graduated magna cum laude. His goal is to help create retirement strategies that are custom-suited to clients by using a variety of investment and insurance products.

Advertisement

Most Popular

How To Buy a Roth IRA When You Make Too Much To Qualify For One
Roth IRAs

How To Buy a Roth IRA When You Make Too Much To Qualify For One

With their tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals, Roth IRAs are a great deal — if you qualify. If you don’t, well, there’s still a way to get into …
September 23, 2020
Social Security Recipients, Veterans Must Act Now to Get Extra $500 Stimulus Check
Coronavirus and Your Money

Social Security Recipients, Veterans Must Act Now to Get Extra $500 Stimulus Check

The deadline for seniors and veterans to request an additional $500 stimulus check for a dependent child is approaching fast. See how you can claim yo…
September 25, 2020
High-Tech Aids for Aging in Place
Caregiving

High-Tech Aids for Aging in Place

Apple Watch and other technology provides fast feedback, comfort for older users, and a powerful assist for caregivers.
September 23, 2020

Recommended

Check Your Financial Adviser Now (and Every Year) or Regret It Later
wealth management

Check Your Financial Adviser Now (and Every Year) or Regret It Later

Fewer than 10% of investors use such free background checks as Investor.gov, BrokerCheck or IAPD to check their financial advisers’ backgrounds. These…
September 21, 2020
HSA Limits and Minimums
health savings accounts

HSA Limits and Minimums

Annually adjusted contribution limits and other requirements must be met if you're covering health care costs with a Health Savings Account.
September 21, 2020
Don’t Be Paralyzed by Uncertainty
retirement planning

Don’t Be Paralyzed by Uncertainty

You definitely need a plan, because what’s ahead could be scarier than what’s behind us.
September 21, 2020
Insurance for Long-Term Care at Home
retirement

Insurance for Long-Term Care at Home

In the wake of COVID-wracked nursing homes, increasingly more people are looking at options to age in place with long-term care insurance.
September 17, 2020