Fissures at the Fed
Policymakers are at odds over inflation. It's calm now, but how long can that last?

Despite the collegial facade, a schism is widening at the Federal Reserve. Lined up on one side: the hawks -- policymakers impatient with the Fed’s low interest rates and, at a minimum, eager to signal a change in course. On the other: the doves, worried that the economy hasn’t quite found its legs.
After 17 months, the Fed’s near-zero interest rate policy is clearly making some members uneasy. Most prominent among the hawks is Thomas Hoenig, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. As a voting member of the Federal Open Market Committee, Hoenig first dissented with the Fed’s declaration that the bellwether federal funds rate would remain “exceptionally low” for an “extended period” in January, a position he maintained at the March and April meetings. In a more recent speech, he warned about “the buildup of financial imbalances creating long-run risks” and noted that “operators and investors in the Midwest are buying up farmland and bidding up the price.”
In direct challenge to previous statements by Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, Hoenig also conceded that the previous episode of easy money played a role in inflating the housing bubble: “Exceptionally low rates, while perhaps not the single cause, played an important role in creating the conditions leading to our recent crisis.” Given the usual standards of harmony at the Fed, the public dissent is noteworthy.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
And Hoenig isn’t alone. Other card-carrying hawks include President of the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank James Bullard, who is also a voting member of the FOMC, and the presidents of three other regional Fed banks. Although Jeffrey Lacker of the Richmond bank, Charles Plosser of Philadelphia and Richard Fisher of the Dallas bank do not now have FOMC votes, which rotate among regional bank presidents each year, they all weigh in at meetings.
Joining Bernanke in the dove camp is Vice Chairman Donald Kohn and regional presidents Eric Rosengren (Boston) and Janet Yellen (San Francisco). As a group, they don’t dispute the hawks’ angst; they simply subordinate those worries to their own about the economic recovery. For example, Yellen (recently nominated to succeed Kohn as vice chairman after his retirement this June) places the emphasis on downside risks: “Even as we applaud the economic turnaround, it’s important not to lose sight of just how fragile this recovery is and how far we yet have to go before things return to normal.” As for the risk of fueling new bubbles, she notes, “Currently, simple financial market indicators provide no real sign that significant excesses or imbalances have developed in the United States.”
Through at least the end of the year, the doves will come out on top, with the record low federal funds rate persisting into 2011. First of all, Bernanke and his like-minded colleagues outnumber those who are more worried about inflation. Of the 10 current voting members on the FOMC (with two of the usual 12 seats vacant), doves Bernanke, Kohn and Rosengren outnumber the hawks 3-to-2. The five remaining members don’t come down squarely on one side or the other, usually concurring with the majority.
Yellen’s replacement of Kohn at midyear -- which is a very safe bet -- doesn’t affect the hawk/dove balance, but newly nominated governors certainly will. The administration’s nominees Peter Diamond, a scholar with little monetary policy background, and Sarah Bloom Raskin, a Maryland bank regulator, both harbor activist biases. In the current environment, that means prioritizing a return to low unemployment over a return to more-normal interest rates.
There’s also the matter of politics. Although the Federal Reserve is among the most independent central banks in the world, it isn’t immune from politics. And as financial reform measures float through Congress, each reshaping the Fed’s role to some degree, there’s an incentive not to be too hasty with the higher interest rates that legislators reflexively dislike -- especially in an election year.
Finally, there’s this: Hawks’ arguments about inflation are theoretical, emphasizing abstract potential risks down the road, while doves focus on the absence of any evident imbalances today. Despite the hawks’ legitimate points, their concerns about the future are trumped by worry about the here and now.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

-
Claiming the Standard Deduction? Here Are Five Tax Breaks for Retirement in 2025
Tax Tips If you’re retired and filing taxes, these five tax credits and deductions could provide thousands in relief (if you qualify).
-
QUIZ: Test Your Retirement IQ
Quiz Are you smarter than…everyone else? Test your retirement smarts with this quiz.
-
Apple Readies for AI Upgrade with New iPhones
The Kiplinger Letter The tech giant has stumbled when it comes to artificial intelligence, but a new batch of iPhones will help it make headway.
-
Japan Enters a New Era of Risk and Reform
The Kiplinger Letter Japan has entered a pivotal moment in its economic history, undertaking ambitious policy and structural reforms to escape from decades of stagnation.
-
How Consumers Are Tinkering with Cutting-Edge AI
The Kiplinger Letter Companies launching artificial intelligence tools are jostling for consumer attention. Some products are already building a deep connection with users.
-
After Years of Stagnant Growth, Hope Emerges for EU Economy
The Kiplinger Letter Can a German fiscal push outweigh French political peril?
-
Small Businesses Are Racing to Use AI
The Kiplinger Letter Spurred on by competitive pressures, small businesses are racing to adopt AI. A recent snapshot shows the technology’s day-to-day uses.
-
How AI Puts Company Data at Risk
The Kiplinger Letter Cybersecurity professionals are racing to ward off AI threats while also using AI tools to shore up defenses.
-
AI Start-ups Are Rolling in Cash
The Kiplinger Letter Investors are plowing record sums of money into artificial intelligence start-ups. Even as sales grow swiftly, losses are piling up for AI firms.
-
What is AI Worth to the Economy?
The Letter Spending on AI is already boosting GDP, but will the massive outlays being poured into the technology deliver faster economic growth in the long run?