America's Failing Infrastructure: A Scary Picture

Federal, state and local spending on public works projects is already woefully shy of what it should be to keep bridges, roads, dams and other infrastructure up to snuff. But the sluggish economy is forcing even more project delays and cancellations, exacerbating America’s infrastructure crisis.

Take a look at funding levels for bridges, highways, dams, subways, seaports, public schools, electricity transmission and drinking water systems. The level of attention being paid to each is also reflected in letter grades given by the American Society of Civil Engineers.

Beware: The grades aren’t pretty.

From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance

Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues

CLICK FOR FREE ISSUE

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

Bridges

Number of Bridges in the U.S.: 590,766

Number of Deficient Bridges: 152,316

Current Spending: $5.2 billion annually

Ideal Spending: $19 billion annually over a 50-year period

Grade: C

The big wave of bridge building in the 1950s and 1960s created spans built to last half a century. For many of them, time’s up. The average age of bridges in America stands at 43. And the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) says that, while still safe, nearly one in four bridges is either structurally deficient and in need of repair or too narrow for today’s traffic volumes.

Narrow bridges built for yesteryear’s traffic impede commuting and other travel times as well as the timely delivery of goods, emergency services, etc. Large interchanges and river crossings are major choke points.

The top 10 highway interchange bottlenecks in the nation -- including the crossing of Interstates 90 and 290 in Buffalo, N.Y., and I-285 and I-85 in Atlanta -- delay truck shipments by an average of 1.5 million hours a year, AASHTO notes.

Of course, the consequences of a bridge failure can be even more devastating. The I-35W bridge in Minneapolis that collapsed into the Mississippi River in 2007 killed 13 people and caused massive commuting headaches for many months.

Highways

Number of Highway Miles in the U.S.: 47,013

Current Spending: $42 billion annually

Ideal Spending: $146 billion to $310 billion annually over a 15- to 50-year period

Grade: D-

America’s highways are buckling under levels of traffic that were unforeseen by the engineers who designed them. Serving as Americans’ top mode of transportation, major highways are also vital to freight transportation.One proposed fix: raising the gasoline tax and dedicating the revenues to highway repairs. Hiking the federal gasoline tax by 10¢ a month would cost each American household about $9 per month. But such a move has never gained traction with voters, and odds of it happening remain slim to none.

Dams

Number of Dams in the U.S.: 84,000

Number of Deficient Dams: 4,400

Current Spending: $1 billion annually

Ideal Spending: $54 billion annually

Grade: D

Aging dams are another brewing problem. Over a third of the nation’s dams are 50 years old, and in 10 years, nearly 70% of dams in the U.S. will have reached the half century mark, according to the Association of State Dam Safety Officials (ASDSO).

Moreover, more dams are now deemed high risk because of population encroachment. With infrastructure aging and insufficient funds to fully back state safety inspections and safety plans, deficient dams could cause catastrophic floods that would be deadly for nearby residents and farms as well as entities that rely on hydropower.

Unfortunately, part of the problem is deciding who is responsible for rehabilitating dams. Most dams are privately owned but state regulated. The benefits a private owner may receive fall far short of the cost of repairs or complete rehabilitation. And the clock is ticking. The ASDSO reports that putting off needed repairs for 15 years would likely make them five to 10 times more costly.

Subways

Number of City Subway Systems in the U.S.: 11

Current Spending: More than $60 billion over a six-year period

Ideal Spending: $123 billion over a six-year period

Grade: D

The nation’s transit system is falling behind in repairs and scraping by with what little funds are left. Philadelphia desperately needs funds for its aging subway system, which was constructed in the early 1900s and 1920s. The system relies on power substations, most of which are close to 80 years old. If all of them fail, the whole system could go down, since there isn’t enough money to fix it. It makes Philly an example of making do with what you’ve got, not unknown in many other cities.

The subway is very important to business in Philadelphia. About 70% of the people who use the system do so to reach their offices downtown.

The only way to keep America’s subway systems operating at full speed is through fares. According to the American Public Transportation Association (APTA), 80% of transit systems have been forced to implement fare increases or defer maintenance.

Schools

Number of Public Schools in the U.S.: 94,000

Current Spending: About $20 billion annually

Ideal Spending: At least $254 billion to fix all schools

Grade: D

They don’t transport people or goods, but public schools constitute a critical segment of America’s physical infrastructure. The quality of the nation’s future workforce depends on the education being provided in thousands of public schools right now.

Unfortunately, the physical condition of the country’s public schools leaves much to be desired. Many are old and decrepit, needing significant renovation or outright replacement. A 2008 study prepared by education finance experts David C. Thompson of Kansas State University and Faith E. Crampton, president and CEO of education consultancy Crampton & Associates in Milwaukee, Wis., pegged the cost of replacing or refurbishing America’s public schools at $254 billion.

And in light of the sharp recession of 2008 and 2009, Crampton figures that the number has only gone up, as school budgets have tightened and necessary maintenance work often gets deferred. Local tax increases -- the usual source of funding for school construction -- are a particularly tough sell, she says.

Ports

Number of Commercial Seaports in the U.S.: 360

Current Spending: About $850 million annually

Ideal Spending: About $1.8 billion annually

Grade: D-

President Obama hopes that strong growth in U.S. exports can help the economy out of the doldrums. But unfortunately, many of the nation’s ports aren’t keeping up with routine maintenance needed to keep their channels wide and deep enough for current shipping. Kurt Nagle, president of the American Association of Port Authorities, sees “dramatic shortfalls” in spending on channel dredging and other vital navigation work.

The Army Corps of Engineers handles those duties, and the federal government taxes all incoming cargo to fund the corps’ work keeping shipping lanes cleared of silt and deep enough for big freighters. But Uncle Sam routinely holds back half the funds that the tax generates to make the federal deficit look smaller, meaning the corps often has to delay channel dredging and widening.

The shortfall, which Nagle pegs at more than $500 million per year, doesn’t even account for new port projects, such as deepening channels so they can handle the giant container ships expected to reach the Atlantic Ocean from Asia when the Panama Canal is expanded in 2014. If U.S. seaports aren’t ready to welcome those giant freighters, other nations’ seaports will, Nagle warns.

Drinking Water

Number of Public Water Systems in the U.S.: 52,000

Current Spending: $29 billion annually

Ideal Spending: At least $335 billion to update all systems

Grade: D-

The pipes that deliver drinking water to most American homes are usually buried underground. So most folks probably don’t realize just how old some of them are: Many drinking water systems in Eastern cities date back to the late 19th century. Upgrading them is paramount, and that will spell higher water bills for businesses and homeowners. But Tom Curtis, deputy executive director of the American Water Works Association, warns, “We ignore this at our peril.”“It’s a public safety issue, it’s a public health issue, and it’s an economic issue,” Curtis says. Water main breaks can cut pressure to fire hydrants and hoses and cause other problems, such as the risk of bacteria and toxins creeping into a city’s water supply as well as flooding. For example, a broken water main in Bethesda, Md., in 2008 led to travel disruptions and school closings.

The Electric Grid

Miles of High-Voltage Transmission Lines in the U.S.: 157,000

Current Spending: About $30 billion annually

Ideal Spending: $338 billion to modernize the grid

Grade: D+

Most folks think of power outages as minor inconveniences -- times to fumble in the dark for flashlights and to worry about milk in the fridge going bad. But the U.S. electric grid is vulnerable to far larger disruptions, either from failures in America’s aging electric infrastructure or from deliberate cyberattacks by computer hackers looking to cause mayhem. Either way, a massive blackout could potentially cripple large portions of the country and cost billions of dollars.

There’s lots of talk about making the electric grid “smarter” by upgrading to new transmission equipment that can quickly detect and respond to outages while fending off online infiltrators. But building a truly smart grid would take years, and the price tag would be steep. However, the costs of not bulking up the electric grid are steep, too. For instance, the Electric Power Research Institute calculates that major blackouts, like the one that hit much of the Northeast in 2003, cost $10 billion each, and that total costs related to “power disturbances” sap the U.S. economy of at least $104 billion per year due to factory outages, work interruptions and the like.