Expect Congress to up the ante for brokers. Among the hundreds of provisions in the massive financial regulatory legislation moving through the Senate is a requirement that brokers be held to the same standards as investment advisers in how they treat clients.
Traditional investment advisers are required to act in their clients’ best interests, while brokers are required only to steer clients into investments that are “suitable.” Lawmakers and regulators say sometimes those investments may be lucrative for the brokers at the client’s expense. “If someone is acting like an investment adviser, they should be subject to regulations,” says David Tittsworth, executive director of the Investment Adviser Association. “If you give all of your life earnings to someone, it matters whether they have a higher standard of care.”
Brokers make trades for clients and are paid per transaction. Investment advisers give clients specialized advice and therefore are subject to a stricter rule. But a 2008 RAND study shows that both pay structures and services for the two groups look increasingly similar. In addition, customers often find differences confusing and don’t know that they are subject to different laws.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
“If you look at commercials for brokers, they are selling trust and confidence,” says Bob Webster, director of communications at the North American Securities Administrators Association. “But people need to know when they are getting advice, whether it’s in their best interest.”
For investors, the change will have pluses and minuses. Harmonizing the standards will boost disclosure and transparency and make it easier for investors to shop around for advice and avoid brokerage house scams. But higher fees will likely be part of the bargain. Brokers say that the new requirements, which will force them to publicize disciplinary history and conflicts of interest, will be costly to implement.
Congress is still ironing out whether it will force the issue or direct the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to handle it, but the fury over Goldman Sachs’ failure to disclose conflicts of interest around a particular security has given the issue momentum in Congress. Even if lawmakers don’t pass a direct change, the SEC will eventually approve higher standards. The agency has long wanted to get tough on brokers and will soon have the authority. “The financial crisis and the shenanigans that have gone on helped focus this issue and call attention for the need for more clarity,” says Webster.
-
Stock Market Today: Have We Seen the Bottom for Stocks?Solid first-quarter earnings suggest fundamentals remain solid, and recent price action is encouraging too.
-
Is the GOP Secretly Planning to Raise Taxes on the Rich?Tax Reform As high-stakes tax reform talks resume on Capitol Hill, questions are swirling about what Republicans and President Trump will do.
-
The Economic Impact of the US-China Trade WarThe Letter The US-China trade war will impact US consumers and business. The decoupling process could be messy.
-
AI Heads to WashingtonThe Kiplinger Letter There’s big opportunity for AI tools that analyze MRIs and other medical images. But also big challenges that clinicians and companies will have to overcome.
-
The AI Doctor Coming to Read Your Test ResultsThe Kiplinger Letter There’s big opportunity for AI tools that analyze CAT scans, MRIs and other medical images. But there are also big challenges that human clinicians and tech companies will have to overcome.
-
The New Space Age Takes OffThe Kiplinger Letter From fast broadband to SOS texting, space has never been more embedded in peoples’ lives. The future is even more exciting for rockets, satellites and emerging space tech.
-
Rising AI Demand Stokes Undersea InvestmentsThe Kiplinger Letter As demand soars for AI, there’s a need to transport huge amounts of data across oceans. Tech giants have big plans for new submarine cables, including the longest ever.
-
What DOGE is Doing NowThe Kiplinger Letter As Musk's DOGE pursues its ambitious agenda, uncertainty and legal challenges are mounting — causing frustration for Trump.
-
A Move Away From Free TradeThe Letter President Trump says long-term gain will be worth short-term pain, but the pain could be significant this year.
-
The Explosion of New AI ToolsThe Kiplinger Letter Workers and consumers soon won’t be able to escape generative AI. Does that mean societal disruption and productivity gains are right around the corner?
