2011 Best New Car Values: Most Fuel-Efficient
Green is still a red-hot buzzword in the auto industry, with carmakers competing to showcase their commitment to fuel savings.
Green is still a red-hot buzzword in the auto industry, with carmakers competing to showcase their commitment to fuel savings. Not every winner is a paragon of green technology, but each vehicle we spotlight is the least thirsty in its class based on annual fuel cost.
The annual fuel cost assumes 15,000 miles of combined city and highway driving each year and fuel prices of $3.10 a gallon for regular, $3.25 for premium and $3.35 for diesel. Models must make our top 25 to be eligible, and no model can win the award if another trim level of that model has won in a previous category.
Let's go for a spin:
Data comes from Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com (new vehicle data from 12/28/10, resale values from January/February 2011 Kelley Blue Book® Residual Value Guide); Vincentric (service and insurance costs); and Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (Top Safety Picks). Fair Purchase Price, also supplied by Kelley Blue Book, is based on actual new vehicle transactions across the country.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Under $20,000
Honda Insight
- Sticker: $18,950 (base)
- Invoice: $17,934
- Fair Purchase Price: NA
- Five-year service cost: NA
- One-year insurance cost: NA
- Resale value after 3 years: NA; 5 years: NA
- MPG city: 40; highway: 43
The namesake of the original hybrid gets a value trim for 2011, dropping its starting price by $1,700. In addition to being ultra-green, with a combined fuel economy of 41 miles per gallon, the compact hatch is ultra-safe -- it has standard stability and traction control and six airbags.
Most Fuel-Efficient: $20,000-$25,000
Toyota Prius
- Sticker: $23,810 (Prius II)
- Invoice: $22,427
- Fair Purchase Price: $23,572
- Five-year service cost: $3,454
- One-year insurance cost: $1,133
- Resale value after 3 years: NA; 5 years: NA
- MPG city: 51; highway: 48
Our perennial Most Fuel-Efficient winner is the category’s Best in Class winner as well. Combined fuel economy is 50 miles per gallon, making the Prius number one on the EPA’s list of Top Ten Fuel Sippers. Annual fuel cost is just $937.
Most Fuel-Efficient: $25,000-$30,000
Lexus CT 200h
- Sticker: $29,995
- Invoice: NA
- Fair Purchase Price: NA
- Five-year service cost: NA
- One-year insurance cost: NA
- Resale value after 3 years: NA; 5 years: NA
- MPG city: 43; highway: 40
The littlest hybrid from Lexus enters the premium compact market with more than superb fuel economy on its resume. Though it claims 43 mpg in the city, more impressive is its roster of safety equipment: eight airbags, including knee airbags for front passengers, front seats designed to avoid whiplash, a brake override system and an optional collision-warning system.
Most Fuel-Efficient: $25,000-$30,000
Lincoln MKZ Hybrid
- Sticker: $35,180
- Invoice: $32,472
- Fair Purchase Price: $34,476
- Five-year service cost: $3,249
- One-year insurance cost: $1,408
- Resale value after 3 years: 45%; 5 years: 27%
- MPG city: 41; highway: 36
The all-new hybrid variant of Lincoln’s MKZ wins Most Fuel-Efficient, beating closest competitor Lexus HS 250h by 6 city mpg. One reason: The MKZ Hybrid can go up to 47 miles per hour in pure electric mode. It also wins Best New Car, has the lowest service costs in its segment and carries the same price as the gas-engine model.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Over $45,000
Mercedes-Benz E350 BlueTEC
- Sticker: $51,775
- Invoice: $48,212
- Fair Purchase Price: $50,740
- Five-year service cost: NA
- One-year insurance cost: NA
- Resale value after 3 years: 53%; 5 years: 32%
- MPG city: 22; highway: 33
Terrific mileage for the diesel version of this luxury icon gives it an annual fuel cost of just $1,941 -- 22% cheaper than the gas-engine model. The E-class sedan won Best New Car last year, and the addition of a turbocharged diesel engine helped it clinch Best in Class for 2011.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Sports
Hyundai Genesis 2.0T
- Sticker: $23,050 (manual)
- Invoice: $21,966
- Fair Purchase Price: $23,050
- Five-year service cost: $4,806
- One-year insurance cost: $1,131
- Resale value after 3 years: 53%; 5 years: 32%
- MPG city: 21; highway: 30
Winning fuel-sipper status for the second year in a row, Hyundai’s Genesis coupe boasts a turbocharged 2.0-liter engine that gets 30 mpg on the highway and takes regular gasoline -- a rarity in this category. Annual fuel cost: $1,915.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Small Crossovers
Ford Escape Hybrid
- Sticker: $30,175 (base)
- Invoice: $28,606
- Fair Purchase Price: $29,794
- Five-year service cost: $3,460
- One-year insurance cost: $1,109
- Resale value after 3 years: 45%; 5 years: 31%
- MPG city: 34; highway: 31
The only remaining hybrid in the small crossover segment, Ford Escape Hybrid offers loads of utility with an environmentally friendly flair. It offers nearly 30% better combined fuel economy than the base gas-engine model (32 mpg versus 25). Moderate service costs and insurance premiums keep a lid on ownership costs.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Large and Midsize Crossovers
Lexus RX 450h
- Sticker: $44,110
- Invoice: $40,218
- Fair Purchase Price: $44,110
- Five-year service cost: $4,126
- One-year insurance cost: $1,655
- Resale value after 3 years: 63%; 5 years: 42%
- MPG city: 32; highway: 28
With an annual fuel cost of $1,621, the RX hybrid bests even the greenest competition in this category (another Toyota family member, the Highlander Hybrid). Despite its fuel economy, it’s no slouch on power—it generates 295 horsepower.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Truck-based SUVs
Cadillac Escalade Hybrid (TIE)
- Sticker: $74,790 (base)
- Invoice: $69,990
- Fair Purchase Price: $72,546
- Five-year service cost: $3,421
- One-year insurance cost: $2,504
- Resale value after 3 years: 46%; 5 years: 29%
- MPG city: 20; highway: 23
Perhaps the blingy-est green vehicle on the road, Caddy’s big ute hybrid has combined city/highway mileage of 21 mpg (a considerable improvement from the gas-engine’s 16 mpg combined). Green credentials come at a high price, though: nearly 75 grand.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Truck-based SUVs
Chevrolet Tahoe Hybrid (TIE)
- Sticker: $51,685 (base)
- Invoice: $48,895
- Fair Purchase Price: $50,651
- Five-year service cost: $3,612
- One-year insurance cost: $1,918
- Resale value after 3 years: 47%; 5 years: 30%
- MPG city: 20; highway: 23
With many of the same underpinnings as the Escalade, Chevrolet’s hybrid Tahoe ties the Cadillac for Most Fuel-Efficient but offers a sticker price that’s $23,000 less. Despite its status as a big people-mover, it has reasonable service costs and respectable fuel economy (combined mileage of 21 mpg).
Most Fuel-Efficient: Truck-based SUVs
GMC Yukon Hybrid (TIE)
- Sticker: $52,150 (base)
- Invoice: $49,334
- Fair Purchase Price: $51,107
- Five-year service cost: $3,623
- One-year insurance cost: $1,919
- Resale value after 3 years: 47%; 5 years: 31%
- MPG city: 20; highway: 23
GMC’s Yukon hybrid is more or less the twin of the Chevy Tahoe, with a few badging and interior differences. Annual fuel cost is $2,189 ($512 less than the gas-engine model). All of GM’s big-SUV hybrids can seat seven or eight, depending on whether you get a second-row bench or captain’s chairs.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Minivans
Honda Odyssey
- Sticker: $28,580 (LX)
- Invoice: $25,976
- Fair Purchase Price: $28,580
- Five-year service cost: $3,995
- One-year insurance cost: $960
- Resale value after 3 years: 54%;5 years: 34%
- MPG city: 18; highway: 27
Category sweeper Odyssey LX improves highway mileage over last year’s model by 17% (with a five-speed transmission). Step up to the Touring model ($41,535) and you get a standard six-speed transmission that boosts combined mileage by another mile per gallon, to 22 mpg. New across the Odyssey lineup for 2011: a wider stance that ups interior space -- the second row can be expanded horizontally to give more seating room or create a pass-through for cargo.
Most Fuel-Efficient: Wagons
Audi A3 2.0 TDI
- Sticker: $31,125 (Premium)
- Invoice: $29,009
- Fair Purchase Price: $30,658
- Five-year service cost: $5,075
- One-year insurance cost: $1,176
- Resale value after 3 years: 56%; 5 years: 33%
- MPG city: 30; highway: 42
The diesel-powered A3 picks up a Most Fuel-Efficient plaudit again, with an annual fuel cost of $1,460. It also has high resale values and low insurance costs, and it’s one of only three wagons (Subaru Outback and Jetta SportWagen are the others) rated a Top Safety Pick by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
More From Kiplinger
Best New Car Values 2011: Best in Class
Best New Car Values 2011: Best Resale Value
Best New Car Values 2011: New Models
Best New Car Values 2011: 10 Cheapest Cars to Own
-
Use An iPhone? You May Be Hearing From A Class-Action Lawsuit Group
A handful of suits against the iPhone maker seek to crack down on everything from app store purchases to messaging.
By Keerthi Vedantam Published
-
Capital One/Discover: What's In Their Wallet For You?
Push back on Capital One's planned merger with Discover is growing with one group of consumer advocates calling for a public hearing.
By Keerthi Vedantam Published
-
7 Things Medicare Doesn’t Cover
Healthy Living on a Budget Medicare Part A and Part B leave some pretty significant gaps in your health-care coverage. But Medicare Advantage has problems, too.
By Donna LeValley Last updated
-
The 10 Cheapest Countries to Visit
Despite inflation, there are some areas where the strong dollar will definitely work in your favor.
By Quincy Williamson Last updated
-
15 Ways to Prepare Your Home for Winter
home Now that fall is officially here, it's time to prepare your home for cold weather.
By Donna LeValley Published
-
Six Steps to Get Lower Car Insurance Rates
insurance Shopping around for auto insurance may not be your idea of fun, but comparing prices for a new policy every few years — or even more often — can pay off big.
By Donna LeValley Published
-
10 Things You Need to Know About Retiring to Florida
Making Your Money Last If Florida is part of your retirement plan, we offer up a few tips to help you find your way.
By Bob Niedt Last updated
-
6 Ways to Boost Your Credit Score — Fast
Tips for boosting your credit score quickly, starting with paying down your credit card debt.
By Lisa Gerstner Last updated
-
Gas-Saving Tips That Actually Work
Buying & Leasing a Car When fuel prices rise, all kinds of gas-saving schemes get floated. We separate the serious from the silly for you.
By David Muhlbaum Published
-
Hurricane Insurance Claims: 10 Things You Should Know
Becoming a Homeowner Hurricane damage? Know what’s covered, what isn’t, and how to make the most of your policy if you need to file a claim.
By Kimberly Lankford Last updated