Can the 'Guardrails Approach' Protect Your Retirement Investments?
This investing method uses guardrails to help retirees avoid running out of money and manage volatility.


You might not have heard of the "guardrails approach," but this investing tool for retirement planning is worth considering, especially in a volatile market.
One of the biggest challenges for many people is ensuring their retirement investments last for the rest of their lives, while also leaving a bequest to heirs. It’s a tough knot to untangle.
Part of the problem is that assets such as stocks and bonds are prone to be volatile. Some years offer solid double-digit returns; others are distinctly poor with tremendous losses.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
For instance, in 2022, the SPDR S&P 500 exchange-traded fund, which tracks the performance of large-cap stocks, fell 18%. That same year, the bond market also declined, with 10-year U.S. Treasuries also dropping 18%, according to data from New York University. Yet, inflation spiked.
What can you do? Jonathan Guyton and William Klinger, a financial planner and computer whiz, respectively, developed an investment methodology known as the “guardrails approach.” It’s designed to lower the risk of retirees running out of money.
What is the 'guardrails approach'?
“Guardrails focuses on lifetime spending,” says Amy Arnott, portfolio strategist for Morningstar. “It means you are able to spend more money during your lifetime.”
It’s also likely to ensure that significant assets will be left for bequests to family and charities. She estimates that someone starting with a $1 million portfolio — taking 4%, or $40,000, in income initially and following the guardrails approach — will likely have a portfolio of $1.3 million when they die.
In the simplest terms, the amount you take out of your retirement pot each year will rise and fall based on the annual swings of the portfolio’s value and inflation.
If the portfolio grows by 40% to $1.4 million at the end of the first year, the retiree gets to withdraw $45,021, according to Morningstar. If at the end of the first year the portfolio drops by 30% to $672,000, the retiree gets to withdraw $36,835.
“It can be challenging to understand the ins and outs of the actual guardrails calculations,” Arnott says. However, financial advisers should be able to help crunch the numbers.
How to use the 'guardrails approach'
The strategy is good, but it has flaws, says Richard Rosso, director of financial planning at Real Investment Advice.
He notes that the amount of money required in retirement is not static. It tends to begin with increased spending at the start of retirement when people take overseas trips. After the trips, spending falls for a while, sometimes to as much as one-fourth of what it was the first year of retirement, he says. The money not spent could then remain in the portfolio.
Eventually, many retirees see their financial needs increase as they develop health problems and need more medical care. “Everyone’s spending varies,” Rosso says.
He also recommends that those using the guardrails approach evaluate their portfolios every quarter, rather than annually. He says most clients understand the need to spend less when markets are falling.
“This dynamic system of guardrails is not a bad thing,” he says. “It’s a good way for clients to see what’s going on with the portfolio and the spending.”
Another challenge not commonly understood is the impact of life expectancy (longevity risk), which is not included in the guardrails approach, says Nick Nefouse, global head of retirement solutions and head of LifePath at BlackRock.
At birth, Americans are expected to live to age 77 on average, according to Social Security Administration data. However, that doesn’t mean someone who is 76 only has a year to live; at that age, a man can expect to live another 10 years, while a woman has almost 12.
That’s why Nefouse includes mortality assumptions in BlackRock’s retirement planning tools. Whatever approach is taken, it’s usually advisable to have a chat with a financial adviser, he says.
Note: This item first appeared in Kiplinger Retirement Report, our popular monthly periodical that covers key concerns of affluent older Americans who are retired or preparing for retirement. Subscribe for retirement advice that’s right on the money.
Read More
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Simon Constable is co-author of The Wall Street Journal Guide to the 50 Economic Indicators That Really Matter.
-
Don’t Miss Apple and Walmart Back-to-School Tax-Free Holiday Savings this Summer
Sales Tax Select states host sales tax holidays during the summer. Here’s what you can purchase.
-
The Rule of Retirement Inversion
The rule of retirement inversion says that to have a great retirement, you must ask yourself what would ruin a great retirement — and then plan to avoid it.
-
Sibling Bonds May Wax and Wane: Here's How To Safeguard Them
Sibling Bonds May Wax and Wane: Here's How To Safeguard Them
-
A Contrarian Approach Pays Off for This Small-Cap Fund
Small-cap stocks have been hit hard by tariff worries, but this T. Rowe Price fund has outperformed thanks to its manager's against-the-tide approach.
-
The Best Stocks of the Century
As we near the 25-year mark, we looked at which stocks have returned the most. Here are the 10 best stocks of the century so far.
-
Barry Ritholtz: How to Spot Bad Investing Advice and Build a Resilient Portfolio
Barry Ritholtz, a veteran money manager, shares common investing errors we all make and how to avoid them.
-
Your Online Security: 10 Things You Should Know
Online security is more tenuous given the rise of AI. Arm yourself against internet criminals with these tips to strengthen online security.
-
We Check on Our Favorite Bond Funds Amid Tariff Volatility
Bond volatility has ramped up amid debt and inflation worries. Most of our top bond ETFs are outperforming, while one laggard presents a unique opportunity.
-
How to Tell Your Own Story
Your life told well could be the best gift you can leave.
-
The Dollar Index Is Sliding. Is Your Portfolio Prepared?
The dollar's fall has been troubling because inflation appears to be constrained and the economy has been strong. Here's what it means for investors.