A National Sales Tax to Pay for Health Care?
You're going to hear a lot in the coming weeks about passing a consumption tax to help foot the bill for health care reform.
You're going to hear a lot in the coming weeks about passing a consumption tax to help foot the bill for health care reform. It's going to sound like a pretty live option because it would raise a lot of money.
But don't believe a word of it. Whatever shape it might come in, whether it's a value-added tax, national sales tax, or something else, it's a non-starter. That's not a value judgment on a consumption tax. It's just a statement of political reality.
The huge amount of money that a consumption tax would raise is big enough to tempt many members of Congress, at least at first blush. One option said to be under consideration in the House would impose a value added tax of about 1.5% on goods and services, which would, by itself, raise enough revenue -- an estimated $600 billion over 10 years -- that other tax hikes might not even be necessary to foot the bill for health care reform.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Adding just a penny and a half to every dollar of goods someone buys has to be relatively painless, right? Or certainly less painful than some of the other options on the list, including: A surtax on incomes of single taxpayers making more than $200,000 a year and married couples over $250,000; taxing the value of a worker's employer provided coverage if it exceeds a certain amount; or making companies pay a tax on a portion of their health care spending.
Dig a little deeper, though, and the consumption tax may not be a slam dunk after all. Let's take that example of the 1.5% VAT. Problem is, you're only going to raise that amount of money if the VAT is slapped on virtually everything. There would certainly be complaints that the VAT is regressive, so there's little doubt that Congress would exempt basics such as food and prescription drugs, and possibly housing and utilities as well. Once you've done that, the VAT would have to be upwards of 3% to raise the same amount of money.
Problem No. 2: State and local governments' noses would be out of joint, big time. The sales tax belongs to them, they would argue, and the federal government has no business adding another tax on top of the ones they levy.
And there's also this: Where would it end? Enact a consumption tax and the camel's nose is firmly under the tent. Once a consumption tax is part of the tax code, it will be very easy to simply ratchet up the rate on the existing levy to gain the revenues for whatever big-ticket item needs to be paid for. Where would it end? Simple: It never gets started in the first place.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
-
Is Delta's New AI Pricing Bad News for Your Wallet?
Delta is using AI to "personalize" the price you pay for airfare. Here's what that could mean for your next trip.
-
The 10 Places Where Social Security Covers the Most (and Least) Of Your Expenses
On average, Social Security covers 30.11% of retirees’ spending. Fortunately, there are places where those dollars will stretch further and cover more of your spending.
-
Money for Your Kids? Three Ways Trump's ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ Impacts Your Child's Finances
Tax Tips The Trump tax bill could help your child with future education and homebuying costs. Here’s how.
-
Key 2025 Tax Changes for Parents in Trump's Megabill
Tax Changes Are you a parent? The so-called ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ (OBBB) impacts several key tax incentives that can affect your family this year and beyond.
-
2025 SALT Cap Could Hurt Top 'Hidden Home Cost'
Tax Deductions The GOP tax bill could make hidden homeowner costs worse for you. Here’s how.
-
Can Homeschoolers Save on Expenses With 529 Plans?
Savings Accounts A new so-called 'home school tax break' could change how you save for your child's homeschool education. Find out how.
-
Are Clean Energy Tax Credits Going Away This Year?
Tax Credits Now that Trump's mega tax bill has passed, some wonder when energy-efficient incentives, like solar, electric vehicle, and home improvement tax credits, will end.
-
Big GOP Tax Bill Could Change Your Estate Planning for 2025
Tax Law The GOP extended and increased the higher gift and estate tax exemption and affected AMT thresholds. What might this mean for your estate plan?
-
The GOP Wants to Auto-Enroll Your Child in a 'Trump Account' for Savings
Tax Law The federal government will soon auto-enroll your kid in a tax-advantaged ‘Trump Account’ under the 'One Big Beautiful Bill.'
-
Why You May Owe More Tax Soon on Popular Employee Benefits
Tax Law Workers could foot the tax bill for employer-provided benefits like parking, gyms, and meals.