It's no secret that many Americans have not saved enough for retirement. But here's the flip side of the coin: retirees who don't spend enough of their savings.
A recent study by the Employee Benefit Research Institute found that the majority of retirees are spending down their assets surprisingly slowly during the first two decades of retirement. People who retired with $200,000 to $500,000 in savings, not including their homes, had spent a bit more than one-fourth of their assets, EBRI found. Those with more assets -- $500,000 or more -- had parted with even less, spending down less than 12% of savings over a 20-year span. And about one-third of the retirees in the study increased their savings over the period.
EBRI theorizes that retirees might spend at slow rates because they're uncertain about how much money they'll need, how long it will have to last or what a safe rate of spending might be. But conversations with financial planners and behavioral finance experts suggest that another of EBRIs theories is more relevant than you might think: Some people have a behavioral roadblock that simply makes it hard to spend their money.
Nature and nurture. People are reluctant spenders due to both personality and habit, says Meir Statman, a professor at Santa Clara University, in Santa Clara, Calif. Successful savers have prospered by living below their means, and over time, that frugality becomes a matter of preference—hardwired, sometimes to an excessive degree. "Tightwads are usually disciplined in many other areas of their life," says certified financial planner Ann Reilley Gugle of Charlotte, N.C. "Spending can be associated with weakness or recklessness." Frugality can also develop into a competitive pastime, she says. Picture a millionaire many times over who obsessively clips coupons.
Planners report that inherited money can pose a challenge if heirs feel that they don't deserve to spend money they didn't earn. Those who have always lived modestly may fear that a more lavish lifestyle will change their relationships with neighbors and friends. Some folks just need to adjust to a new phase of life. "I work with a lot of people who have trouble turning their saving plan into a spending plan," says CFP Benjamin Rickey of Yakima, Wash. "Occasionally, they're hoarding money. But most just have a hard time rewiring themselves."
The first step is to find appealing spending options. "I can afford a $300 meal, but it makes me feel stupid -- like the chef is in the back laughing uproariously," says Statman. You may have zero interest in fancy restaurants or luxury cruises. But like Statman, you might discover that flying business class is worth every penny. Or you may gain the confidence to continue driving by upgrading to a car with the latest safety features.
People unaccustomed to and uninterested in spending on themselves often find it more palatable to help children or grandchildren, or to donate to charity. Gifford Lehman, a CFP in Monterey, Calif., has a client who is a retired teacher, whose modest appearance belies a hefty inheritance. "Her passion is philanthropy, which is a form of consumption for her," Lehman says. A charitable remainder trust will eventually benefit a charity she has selected. It generates income in the meantime, allowing her to make other donations, mostly anonymously.
It helps to set up a spending strategy. See Make Your Money Last Through Retirement for ways to make your income last a lifetime. If you're more than set but spending still troubles you, consider the alternative, says Rickey: "Clients are acutely aware of the risk of running out of money. There's also the risk of dying on a large pile of beans that never got put to good use."
Anne Kates Smith brings Wall Street to Main Street, with decades of experience covering investments and personal finance for real people trying to navigate fast-changing markets, preserve financial security or plan for the future. She oversees the magazine's investing coverage, authors Kiplinger’s biannual stock-market outlooks and writes the "Your Mind and Your Money" column, a take on behavioral finance and how investors can get out of their own way. Smith began her journalism career as a writer and columnist for USA Today. Prior to joining Kiplinger, she was a senior editor at U.S. News & World Report and a contributing columnist for TheStreet. Smith is a graduate of St. John's College in Annapolis, Md., the third-oldest college in America.
How Much Does It Cost to Move?
Finding out how much it costs to move and budgeting correctly is essential when you're planning to buy or rent a property. Here’s what you need to know.
By Tom Higgins Published
Retirement Planning in a Time of Inflation and High Interest Rates
Today’s challenges make retirement planning even more complicated than usual, but it’s not all doom and gloom.
By Ken Moraif, MBA, CFP®, CRPC® Published
The Psychology Behind Your Worst Investment Decisions
investing We can torpedo our portfolios without even realizing it. Avoiding these seven traps will allow you to make rational investments.
By Katherine Reynolds Lewis Published
A Psychologist's Fear-Fighting Tips for Investors
Investor Psychology To make good financial decisions, you need a clear head, and fear can get in the way. Instead, beat your fears with these behavioral strategies.
By Daniel Crosby, Doctor of Psychology Published
Investors' Worst Enemy in 2021 Could Be Their Own Brains
Investor Psychology Hindsight bias, recency bias and sunk cost fallacy are just three of several cognitive biases that investors need to overcome to achieve their financial objectives this year. To beat these biases, take your emotions out of the mix.
By Jonathan I. Shenkman, AIF® Published
Make Time for a Retirement Checkup
Investor Psychology Retirees are inclined to invest more conservatively, so chances are you don’t have as much money in stocks as you should.
By Janet Bodnar Published
Pessimists Never Prosper: Try an Abundance Mindset Instead
Investor Psychology Even if you're a perpetual pessimist, there are ways to channel your thinking into a more positive direction, and that can help reap benefits for yourself, and for society in general.
By Deborah L. Meyer, CPA/PFS, CFP® Published
The Psychology of the Stock Market and Investment Decisions
Investor Psychology Investors are people, not robots, and people can be swayed by emotions like fear or excitement. And in the investing world, that can be a big problem.
By Patrick B. Healey, CFP® MBA Published
What to Do Now If You’re Losing Sleep Over the Stock Market
Investor Psychology Do you fear a bear market? Here’s how to handle your portfolio when ‘staying the course’ isn't enough.
By Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA Published
7 Golden Rules for Investing and Advanced Estate Planning
Investor Psychology You've worked hard to build your nest egg. To protect it, for yourselves and for your heirs, follow this set of golden rules.
By Craig Kirsner, Investment Adviser Representative Published