Advertisement
investing

How One Bad Year Can Wreck Your Investing Results

My 2015 setback has had a dramatic impact on my cumulative returns. On that basis, I trail my bogey by 31 percentage points.

When evaluating a mutual fund’s performance, I’ve always focused on year-by-year results. In doing so, I have typically brushed off a bad year here and there, as long as the fund did better than the market (or an appropriate index) in most years.

But managing the Practical Investing portfolio has made me realize the folly of my approach. That’s because I’ve seen firsthand how one especially rotten year can sink long-term results and make it difficult to catch up. Moreover, what looks like a relatively minor difference in annualized returns caused by an occasional bad year adds up to far more than you’d expect when you look at results on a cumulative basis.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The math is pretty simple. And yet, if I had not been forced to compare my own portfolio’s returns with a market index, I don’t think I would have examined my results closely enough to take stock of the damage.

Dig into the data with me to get a better sense of the problem. My portfolio is with Vanguard’s brokerage arm. By using the “balances over time” feature, I calculated year-by-year results for my portfolio, as well as for my small position in Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (symbol VTI), the exchange-traded fund that serves as the portfolio’s bogey. In all but one year of the portfolio’s 5½-year history, its performance has been relatively close to that of the index.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

In the first four months of 2017, for example, my portfolio earned 9.7%, compared with 6.8% for the ETF. In 2016, my investments earned 16.7%, and the ETF gained 12.8%. In 2014, I netted 16.0%, versus 12.5% for the index. In 2013, both the index and I gained 33.4%. And in 2012, the year I gradually finished filling out my portfolio, I earned 10.1%; the ETF’s return for a comparable period was 13.0%.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The outlier. You may have noticed that I haven’t said anything about 2015. Thanks to a few awful picks—as well as my bent toward value stocks, which hurt during a year when large growth companies led the way—my portfolio performed abysmally in 2015. It lost 20.0%, while the overall market essentially broke even. Because of that miserable year, the portfolio’s annualized return through April 30, 2017, stood at 10.3%, compared with 13.5% annualized for the benchmark. Not great, but not a disaster, either.

But the impact of my 2015 setback becomes far more dramatic when you look at cumulative results. As of April 30, my portfolio had gained a total of 74.1%—a shocking 31 percentage points less than the ETF.

How did one 20% loss land me 31 percentage points behind? The short answer is compounding. At the end of 2014, my portfolio and the index were neck-and-neck. The actively managed part of my portfolio had earned a cumulative 69.8% and was worth $322,640 (compared with an initial stake of $189,998), while the ETF was up 69.7% and was worth $18,430 (versus an initial investment of $10,863).

Advertisement - Article continues below

But by the end of 2015, the value of my portfolio had shrunk to $258,382. And that meant I needed to earn 25% in 2016 to simply restore the portfolio’s end-of-2014 value. Instead, I earned 16.5%. That was not a bad year’s work, but my investments were still worth less than they were on December 31, 2014. As for overtaking my benchmark, the chances of that happening anytime soon are remote, even if I can beat it by three to four percentage points per year.

So why bother to buy individual stocks at all? I can’t speak for others, but a few things make it worthwhile for me. Investing a small portion of my net worth this way helps keep me abreast of valuations, both on an individual and a market-wide level. That knowledge helps me stay calm when one of my stocks or the overall market stumbles. Besides, I suspect that the humility engendered by comparing my results with the index is good for the soul.

Advertisement

Most Popular

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays
Markets

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays

Is the market open today? Take a look at which holidays the stock markets and bond markets take off in 2020.
July 1, 2020
What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?
tax brackets

What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?

The IRS unveiled the 2020 tax brackets, and it's never too early to start planning to minimize your future tax bill.
June 20, 2020
Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire
Empty Nesters

Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire

We home in on two places with less traffic and lower costs. 
July 2, 2020

Recommended

3 Municipal Bond Funds for Rich, Tax-Friendly Yields
Investing for Income

3 Municipal Bond Funds for Rich, Tax-Friendly Yields

Municipal bond funds allow you to enjoy the benefits of tax-exempt income. By investing CEFs, you can sweeten the pot even further.
July 2, 2020
Is the Stock Market Closed for the Fourth of July?
Markets

Is the Stock Market Closed for the Fourth of July?

Independence Day falls on a Saturday in 2020. As a result, the bond and stock markets are closed for a long holiday weekend. Here's a look at the mark…
July 2, 2020
2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays
Markets

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays

Is the market open today? Take a look at which holidays the stock markets and bond markets take off in 2020.
July 1, 2020
13 Best Vanguard Funds for the Next Bull Market
mutual funds

13 Best Vanguard Funds for the Next Bull Market

Optimistic that the bounce since March is indeed the start of the next bull market? Here are the 13 best Vanguard funds to help you make the most of i…
June 25, 2020