stocks

Jim Cramer's Stock Picks Stink

The host of CNBC’s "Mad Money" has lagged the market dramatically over the past 15 years.

CNBC’s “Mad Money” features flashing lights, beeping horns and Jim Cramer, the screaming, fast-talking, always-in-motion host, who always has a strong opinion on which stocks you should buy and which you should sell. Right now!

It’s hard to look away from Cramer; he is terrific fun to watch. No wonder “Money Monster,” a movie that was released in mid May, centers on a thinly disguised Cramer, played by George Clooney. In the movie, an enraged viewer who was wiped out because he invested all of his money on what turned out to be a disastrous stock recommendation takes Clooney hostage.

Does life imitate art? Well, maybe not hostage-taking, but a new paper from two researchers at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School finds that Cramer’s picks have been less than scintillating. To be more specific, from August 1, 2001, through March 31, 2016, Cramer’s Action Alerts PLUS Portfolio returned a cumulative 64.5%, compared with 126.1% for Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index, including dividends. On an annualized basis, Cramer, a former hedge fund manager, trailed the S&P 500 by an average of 2.2 percentage points per year over that nearly 15-year-long period.

What’s more, the Cramer portfolio has been about 5% more volatile than the S&P over that period, the Wharton paper, authored by Jon Hartley and Matthew Olson, finds.

Cramer doesn’t dispute the paper’s findings. “We have never promised outperformance,” he said in a statement. “We have promised transparency, teaching and a way to understand how the money-management process works.” He called the subscription service “largely an educational product.”

Cramer’s picks essentially matched the S&P through 2010. But since then, they have badly lagged the benchmark. From January 1, 2011, through March 31 of this year, Cramer’s picks returned an annualized 5.0%, compared with 12.2% annualized for the S&P 500.

tax breaks for homeownership - image

Courtesy Tulane University

Launched in August 2001, Action Alerts PLUS Portfolio has been a centerpiece of the financial advice offered by TheStreet.com. The website belongs to TheStreet, Inc. (symbol TST), a publicly traded company that Cramer co-founded in 1996. PLUS Portfolio subscribers, who pay $15 a month, always get the recommendations before Cramer buys them for the portfolio, the Wharton paper reports. Likewise, subscribers get Cramer’s picks before he airs them on “Mad Money.”

In March 2005, when CNBC launched “Mad Money,” Cramer converted the portfolio into a charitable trust. All dividends and other cash distributions received by the trust are donated to charity. Cramer and Stephanie Link were co-portfolio managers until last year when Link went to TIAA-CREF. Cramer is now the sole portfolio manager, but he works closely with Jack Mohr, the portfolio’s research director.

On its website, TheStreet compares the return of the Action Alerts PLUS Portfolio to the S&P 500 plus dividends received but not reinvested. That’s because the portfolio donates the dividends to charity rather than reinvesting them. The unusual alternative calculation doesn’t help the portfolio’s relative performance much. From August 2001 through June 30, 2015, according to TheStreet, the S&P 500 with dividends received but not reinvested returned a smidgen less than the traditional calculation of the S&P’s total return (with dividends reinvested)—a cumulative 122.8% compared with 124.8%. June 30, 2015, is the last date for which TheStreet reported returns.

The Action Alerts PLUS Portfolio has lagged the benchmark woefully, no matter how you compute the numbers. The lesson for investors is, perhaps, too obvious: When someone is screaming at you to buy anything, hold tight to your wallet. Good investing, alas, is usually pretty boring.

Most Popular

You'll Save More on Green Home Improvements Under the Inflation Reduction Act
Tax Breaks

You'll Save More on Green Home Improvements Under the Inflation Reduction Act

Tax credits for energy-efficient home improvements will be extended and expanded by the Inflation Reduction Act.
August 12, 2022
Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
3 Dated Rules of Thumb Retirees Should Think Twice About
investing

3 Dated Rules of Thumb Retirees Should Think Twice About

The tried-and-true investing and saving rules of thumb retirees depend on may no longer be as reliable as they hoped. Don’t let dated “rules” steer yo…
August 11, 2022

Recommended

Stock Market Today (8/16/22): Dow Reclaims 34K as Walmart, Home Depot Stocks Soar
Stock Market Today

Stock Market Today (8/16/22): Dow Reclaims 34K as Walmart, Home Depot Stocks Soar

Both retailers reported higher-than-expected earnings and revenue in Q2 and reiterated their full-year forecasts.
August 16, 2022
The Berkshire Hathaway Portfolio: All 45 Warren Buffett Stocks Ranked
stocks

The Berkshire Hathaway Portfolio: All 45 Warren Buffett Stocks Ranked

The Berkshire Hathaway portfolio is a diverse set of blue chips, and increasingly, lesser-known growth bets. Here's a look at every stock picked by Wa…
August 16, 2022
Buffett Buys More Apple, Chevron, Occidental Petroleum, in Q2
stocks to buy

Buffett Buys More Apple, Chevron, Occidental Petroleum, in Q2

Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway topped off existing stakes in some favorite stocks, cut exposure to General Motors and Kroger, and exited its rump…
August 15, 2022
Stock Market Today (8/15/22): Stocks Brush Off China Growth Concerns
Stock Market Today

Stock Market Today (8/15/22): Stocks Brush Off China Growth Concerns

A number of economic reports released overnight pointed to a slowdown in China's economy in July.
August 15, 2022