Investor Psychology

This Market Indicator Suggests a Continued Bull Market

There’s not a lot of enthusiasm for trading with borrowed money, despite low interest rates. That’s a contrarian bullish sign.

The current bull market, which started in early 2009, has been called “the most hated bull market in history.” It seems investors have been waiting in vain for that other shoe to drop only to see the market march higher with nary a correction.

Stocks climb a proverbial wall of worry, and negative sentiment among rank-and-file investors is actually a contrarian bullish sign. It is when sentiment gets one-sidedly bullish and investors throw caution to the wind that you know a major top is near.

But with the S&P 500 now sitting near all-time highs… and tripling in value from its 2009 crisis lows… is it really fair to call this rally “hated”?

Let’s take a look at investor trading on margin. When investors are feeling bullish, they are a lot more likely to trade aggressively… and to borrow money to do it.

Thinkstock

As you can see in the chart, investor margin debt as a percentage of market cap does indeed tend to surge leading into a major market top and tends to fall dramatically during a market decline. We saw investor margin debt jump from less than 1% of market cap to nearly 2% during the great 1990s tech bubble. And it had another major spike during the bull market of the mid 2000s.

Today, we certainly don’t see a lot of investor enthusiasm for margin trading, and margin debt is actually trending lower. We’re still at levels that are high by historical standards, but much of this can be explained by two factors:

  1. Ease of margin trading with discount online brokers
  2. Falling interest rates over the past 30 years…and particularly over the past 6 years.

Remember, the Fed has kept short-term lending rates at close to zero for six years now, so it’s natural that investors will borrow more aggressively on margin. “Free money” makes carry trades that wouldn’t be profitable under “normal” conditions worth doing. Seen in this context, today’s margin debt levels are far less impressive and certainly far less indicative of investor enthusiasm.

So, at least by this metric, our bull market today really is more unloved than hated, at least by the standards of recent major tops.

About the Author

Charles Lewis Sizemore

Chief Investment Officer, Sizemore Capital Managaement LLC

Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA is the Chief Investment Officer of Sizemore Capital Management LLC, a registered investment advisor based in Dallas, Texas. Charles is a frequent guest on CNBC, Bloomberg TV and Fox Business News, has been quoted in Barron's Magazine, The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post and is a frequent contributor to Yahoo Finance, Forbes Moneybuilder, GuruFocus, MarketWatch and InvestorPlace.com.

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
Can't Sleep at Night? Consider Getting Checked Out By a Doctor
health insurance

Can't Sleep at Night? Consider Getting Checked Out By a Doctor

Older adults are more likely to suffer from sleep disorders, such as insomnia and sleep apnea. Left untreated these conditions can have dire consequen…
May 26, 2021
Midyear Investing Outlook: Where to Invest Now
Kiplinger's Investing Outlook

Midyear Investing Outlook: Where to Invest Now

After a powerful start, stocks will grind higher in the second half of 2021. But watch out for curveballs.
May 23, 2021

Recommended

What Exactly Is a Short Squeeze?
investing

What Exactly Is a Short Squeeze?

A short squeeze is a quick path to getting a lot of juice out of a stock. We explain the phenomenon, and the short selling that fuels it.
June 11, 2021
5 Retail Stocks to Dress Up Your Portfolio This Summer
investing

5 Retail Stocks to Dress Up Your Portfolio This Summer

Retailers should continue to rebound as the economy recovers, and these retail stocks are likely to get a boost as a result.
June 10, 2021
Vanguard Money Market Funds: What You Need to Know
investing

Vanguard Money Market Funds: What You Need to Know

Vanguard money market funds are a notable asset storage tool. Here, we break down what you need to know about the firm's six offerings.
June 9, 2021
12 Housing Stocks to Ride the Red-Hot Market
investing

12 Housing Stocks to Ride the Red-Hot Market

The U.S. has a housing shortage and a love affair with home improvement, both of which could create tailwinds for this group of housing stocks.
June 8, 2021