| 

READERS' CHOICE 2009

The top 25 cities according to Kiplinger.com visitors:
City/Metro Area
Votes
1) Lynchburg, VA:
5230
2) Roanoke, VA:
4395
3) Louisville-Jefferson County, KY-IN:
3864
4) Huntington-Ashland, WV-KY-OH:
3744
5) Pittsburgh, PA:
1622
6) Allentown-Bethlehem-Easton, PA-NJ:
902
7) Nashville-Davidson--Murfreesboro--Franklin, TN:
724
8) Lexington-Fayette, KY:
716
9) Owensboro, KY:
509
10) Evansville, IN-KY:
423
11) San Antonio, TX:
198
12) Dubuque, IA:
176
13) Richmond, VA:
119
14) Chicago-Naperville-Joliet, IL-IN-WI:
94
15) Bay City, MI:
89
16) Portland-Vancouver-Beaverton, OR-WA:
85
17) Bangor, ME:
78
18) Boston-Cambridge-Quincy, MA-NH:
69
19) Austin-Round Rock, TX:
68
20) Charlotte-Gastonia-Concord, NC-SC:
62
21) Hattiesburg, MS:
62
22) Fond du Lac, WI:
60
23) Corpus Christi, TX:
59
24) Cincinnati-Middletown, OH-KY-IN:
55
25) New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA:
53
Total Votes Cast: 25713

Editor's Note: On June 10, we noticed that a peculiar pattern of ballot stuffing had skewed the top 25 vote count in our best cities poll. So we reset the voting tally to where it had been 48 hours earlier. (Thanks for the heads up, tweeters.) Louisville, Lexington, we feel your love. Please vote again -- just once a day, please. To the person (or people) who stuffed the ballot box, come on, let people express the excitement they feel for their favorite city. This is a reader's choice poll. No prizes. No deadline. Thanks.
Return to our best cities coverage.
 
READER COMMENTS

Post a comment
 | 
Read all comments (172)


Reader Comments (172)

Posted by: Verlyne at 05/29/2009 09:51:46 PM

I love being back in beautiful Roanoke --the "Star City of the South"!!

Posted by: Star City at 05/30/2009 02:11:12 PM

Roanoke? Come on. It is a nice "family town" but a horrible place to own and start a business. Local government (and others) is so intent on growth that they will always screw the local firms in favor of out-of-town firms. Taxes are the highest in Virginia!!

Posted by: Shelby24019 at 05/31/2009 01:31:08 AM

I came to Roanoke in 1963 and I cannot imagine living anywhere else. I have talked to several people that have moved here from other cities. I usually always ask them what brought them to Roanoke. They tell me they came here to visit, fell in love with our Roanoke Valley and moved back to live.

Posted by: Hank at 06/01/2009 06:46:26 AM

Roanoke is experiencing a rebirth. It ain't what it used to be!!!

Posted by: Sal at 06/01/2009 08:22:09 AM

Lived in Roanoke VA all my life (except for a brief time in DC) and I love it!

Posted by: Theresa at 06/01/2009 09:43:40 AM

I moved to Roanoke in 1982 and had intended on moving back to the Harrisonburg area, as it was my home. Well, it's 2009 and I cannot imagine living anywhere else and am happy that my job, the new friends that I made in Roanoke, as well as the family setting, I'm working my dream job, enjoying the beautiful mountains surrounding this area. I love "The Star City of the South", which has become my permanent home and I plan on retiring here. I now have a grandson here and I can't imagine moving anywhere else and love my home, job, family and friends here!!! I'm extremely blessed to have visited for a short time and it was the best move of my lifetime.

Posted by: PhotoVirginia at 06/01/2009 01:53:21 PM

Wow, I have lived in Roanoke practically all my life and I am old (almost) and I love it here and can't imagine living anywhere else either. I am a photographer and I never run out of interesting things to photograph in Roanoke. It is just a beautiful place to live.

Posted by: LJ at 06/01/2009 03:52:18 PM

One person can make a difference! This place is a hidden gem with the farmer's market, great restaurants, the Taubman Museum and tons of galleries. I left as a teenager vowing never to return and came back as an adult vowing never to leave. What a change a couple of decades can make!

Posted by: NewbieRae at 06/01/2009 07:09:21 PM

I chose a relo to Roanoke recently. Reasons? Quality of life: the attractive combo of rural beauty and a great downtown atmosphere. About business, though, I don't know what "firms" Star City is referring to, but I find that some local businesses appear lazy when it comes to promoting themselves or staying competitive. I see a lack of intelligent marketing, low performance standards for employees (or just lack of training -- I'm never sure which), and very sloppy customer service. I have discovered some outstanding exceptions, and guess what? They are all doing quite well here. As am I!

Posted by: treinert8920012 at 06/02/2009 07:45:40 AM

i was born in allentown. ABE gives all residents the best of both worlds. 3 great cities and many public parks and rural land.

Posted by: Don E. McKinney at 06/02/2009 10:08:12 AM

I moved to Roanoke from Southern California. Roanoke is an exceptionally beautiful city with lots to do for all ages. I find the people very friendly and helpful. I feel blessed to be living in such a wonderful place.

Posted by: ASPT at 06/02/2009 11:13:38 AM

I didn't think I'd come back to Roanoke after college because when I was growing up it seemed like there was nothing to do. But lately (in the past few years) it's changed a lot. Downtown has a bunch of new, cool urban lofts,...great bars and clubs and a sweet music venue. Plus it has some of the best mountain trails around with the AT in our backyard and the Blue Ridge Parkway like 5 minutes from the center of downtown. It's really a unique place and a lot of young people are now swarming here.

Posted by: ROA at 06/02/2009 01:00:01 PM

Agree with NewbieRae on the attitude of the local businesses. Roanoke gov't is pathetically backward thinking. However, a fantastic place to live: good schools, easy commute to DC or Raleigh.

Posted by: Dave at 06/02/2009 09:20:19 PM

Ditto on the accolades for Roanoke. I moved here in '76 and it has been a great place to live. Agree I place a high value on quality of life. The recreational opportunities are endless and with an average commute of 16 minutes, you have time to have a life!

Posted by: Sister Charlene at 06/03/2009 09:19:31 AM

Pittsburgh is a city that has arisen above the collapse of the steel industry. As the host city of the G-20 Economic Summit--Pittsburgh can show the world's economic powers (and the viewing world, as well) what a lovely place it is and how in-sync it is with biotech and IT to energy and professional services. Pittsburgh is a "green-friendly city" and a family centered town---that can look back at its great past and look forward to a bright future.

Posted by: TAH at 06/04/2009 09:16:12 AM

I'll agree with the local government assessment - they are an impediment to progress in the Roanoke Valley, however despite that, the natural beauty, big time amentities with the small town feel, it's a WONDERFULLY safe place to raise a family and such a nice climate. I came from a much bigger city and I will never leave!

Posted by: KC at 06/04/2009 11:02:25 AM

Roanoke is in the midst of a fantastic transformation. Once a sleepy railroad town, preferred by retirees, Roanoke now has a vibrant arts scene and a new medical school opening in 2010. Downtown residences, once a thing of the past, are again gaining popularity, making the downtown area a 24-hour place to be. These things, plus development of a biotech research park will change the demographic of Roanoke within the next ten years. The trick will be to keep the crime rate low, the attractive cost of living, and improve the school system while this renaissance is ongoing. Quality of life and pace is superb!

Posted by: Steeler Nation at 06/05/2009 08:01:00 AM

I have lived in both Pittsburgh and Roanoke, and I can wholeheartedly state that Pittsburgh has far more to offer from a technological, medical, and cultural aspect than Roanoke can even plan to have. The people in Pittsburgh are real people and do not cling to an alleged sense of hospitality but are as genuine as the blue collar backbone that helped raise the city from the collapse of the steel industry in the nation. Roanoke is still at least several decades behind. Just ask the artists moving here en masse from NYC and other major cities.

Posted by: K Deignan at 06/08/2009 03:09:20 PM

Louisville! All the way. VA may be for lovers - Louisville is for everyone!

Posted by: Kathy Tripp at 06/08/2009 11:39:54 PM

Louisville is a vibrant, active city! From the Louisville Waterfront Park, all the Derby festivities including "Thunder Over Louisville", the many biking paths, The St. James Art Show, the Louisville Slugger Museum, Louisville Bats baseball, Actors Theatre and all the wonderful art galleries, restaurants and entertainment...the list goes on and on! I can understand why Louisville loved by so many people!

Posted by: LOUISVILLE BOO HOO at 06/09/2009 11:24:28 AM

I moved to Louisville in the last several years and can't imagine how it makes the top 3 places. There are few job opportunities, a poor educational system, and few things to do. The people are incredibly closed-minded and there is hardly any diversity. I would definitely not recommend that anyone move here unless they come from a very small backward town and see the "big" city of Louisville as a step-up. It is a step down for anyone who has lived in a same-sized city or bigger city.

Posted by: S Peterbaum at 06/09/2009 02:49:25 PM

Looks like Roanoke is only 7th at the moment. Pretty lame! Kentucky is somehow in the lead with 2 cities. I guess those are some pretty good cities to get 5 times the votes.

Posted by: Louisville Guy 502 at 06/09/2009 03:42:43 PM

Poor Louisville Boo-Hoo :) I have to totally disagree with you. Louisville is consistently ranked towards (the) top when publications do ranking of the best cities. Sorry you don't see the good here in Possibility City. Maybe you should get out more!

Posted by: Louisville ExPat at 06/09/2009 03:51:17 PM

I am not sure what "LOUISVILLE BOO HOO" is talking about. Louisville is an excellent place to work and live. The schools are excellent, the cost of living is low, and the arts and restaurant scene is thriving! Has "Boo Hoo" been to Bardstown Road, Frankfort Avenue, St. Matthew's, Market Street, or the Waterfront! There you will find lots to do and ...lots of open minded people.

Posted by: JG at 06/09/2009 04:21:58 PM

Sory that BOO HOO is so unhappy in Louisville--what makes them stay?? Nowhere better to be??

Posted by: Louisville at 06/09/2009 04:24:11 PM

Poor education system? JCPS is one of the top public school systems in the country. Not to mention we have some very good private schools as well. You need to...look around Louisville.

Posted by: Mary Tennyson at 06/09/2009 04:25:12 PM

Louisville is the "yes we can" city. There are opportunites to advance in whatever occupation you strive for. From the vendors selling our Sunday paper, to the Executive Director of Humana, we all work together from the little man to the top man. Very impressed with our merged government as well. Look what we can do! Not to mention our athletes from high school to college! Yeah Louisville

Posted by: Loving the \'Ville at 06/09/2009 04:34:29 PM

I have lived in NYC, Philadelphia, Boston and Raleigh. Louisville outshines them all in liveability. My children are students in the public school system which is very diverse and well regarded. I am sorry that Boo Hoo's experience has not been the same as mine or the many others I know who are have been happy in their relocation to Louisville. We jokingly say that the city is like quicksand because once you move here, you never leave - by choice!

Posted by: Scott Beldon at 06/09/2009 05:03:04 PM

Louisville never ceases to amaze me, especially in its renaissance in the last 10 years. From a thriving arts community to a progressive, integrated, international school system, to a gay-friendly culture with good government policy, numerous top-line chefs, innovative thought, expansive parks and outstanding architecture, the possibilities here are endless! Come see what the buzz is all about...

Posted by: Oma G. at 06/09/2009 05:57:46 PM

I love Louisville! We lived there for many years and it is a great, liveable city that has a lot of soul! Now live in Lexington, KY -- Lexington can't compare to Louisville on quality of life. Lexington is sprawling, a horrible downtown and NO RIVER. A city just isn't a city without a river, lake, coast, something. Lexington has a spring!! lol If you're not into UK basketball, look out -- the winter is pretty long and boring.

Posted by: sloane831 at 06/09/2009 06:39:26 PM

...Louisville Boo Hoo is 100% accurate about the description of Louisville. While it has some interesting points of interest such as SOME of the things Kathy Tripp described and the Highlands and Frankfort Ave., the people are very set in their ways and clique-ish. This comes from an outsider that moved there and has experienced it firsthand. When they ask what school a person went to, they don't mean college. It's the inclusive questioning of a person's high school to judge where a person fits in. I voted for Nashville myself. Nashville and DC are two of the most friendly, fun, and interesting cities in the US as they are mostly made up of transplants. Places that thrive on outsiders moving in and visitors/tourists traveling there are generally among the most diverse and welcoming anywhere in the Nation.

Posted by: Love the Vlle at 06/09/2009 11:26:42 PM

Boo Hoo's got it ALL wrong. JCPS is an award winning school system, Louisville has a vibrant theater and arts culture, the second highest number of restaurants per capita of any city in the country and many, many of them locally chef-owned, a top notch culinary school and excellent, colleges. The waterfront is one of the best in the country. Louisville has more parkland per capita than any other city in the country. There are recreation opportunities galore. Metro government has staff dedicated to development and redevelopment of vacant properties and sponsors lots of low cost loan problems to help small businesses get started or to expand. Fabulous restaurants, friendly neighborhoods, great schools, theater, orchestra, ballet and professional children's theater, clubs, college sports - there's not much missing from Louisville.

Posted by: Steve Magruder at 06/09/2009 11:39:42 PM

Louisville Boo Hoo says there's nothing to do in Louisville. I'm a native Louisvillian, and I would say that over the past several years, I have had the problem of there being so many things to do about town, I have trouble choosing! I wonder if Boo Hoo has actually been here lately.

Posted by: Steve Magruder at 06/09/2009 11:58:04 PM

As a native Louisvillian, I agree with most of the positive things others are saying about it, although I do agree with the clique comment too. The one "positive" thing I disagree about is the career advancement thing -- If you're not in health care, the choices are rather sparse.

Posted by: Steve Magruder at 06/10/2009 12:01:34 AM

One thing is for sure: Louisville has the best city article on Wikipedia.

Posted by: \'Ville Transplant at 06/10/2009 07:47:56 AM

I moved here 17 years ago from NY - I love Louisville! From the schools to the arts & entertainment to historical sights, shopping, - Louisville Original restaurants and some fabulous job opportunities - basically everything. The people here are warm and welcoming. I'm not sure where in Louisville Boo Hoo and Sloane831 are living but don't condem the whole city based on their bad expeiences. Obviously more people have had positive experiences and love Louisville. Get out, meet some more people and I promise you will love Louisville.

Posted by: Julia at 06/10/2009 09:00:20 AM

I moved to Louisville from Chicago. I could not imagine living anywhere else. Everyone is friendly. The hippies on Bardstown road to the ultra wealthy in Harrods Creek are all friendly. I love the incredible restaurant scene and I love the late night bar scene(bars are open until 4am and can reopen at 6am). The parks are second to none. I also love the arts scene. The Opera, Ballet, Orchestra and of course Actors Theatre. I could go on forever. All I can say is.. I love Louisville!

Posted by: Rebecca at 06/10/2009 09:32:12 AM

As a person involved in the arts (fine arts and writing), I always envisioned myself leaving Louisville after high school and moving to a larger city. I decided to still though, and now that I'm in my early 30's and raising children, I'm so glad I made that decision. Louisville is very child friendly- from the choice of schools to the huge park system, farmers markets, good library system, etc. The arts are still a big part of my life, and I had no trouble this past year finding two local art galleries to display my printmaking, and have found several writer's groups and am just trying to choose the best one! Louisville, you're the best!

Posted by: TheBaron at 06/10/2009 10:25:25 AM

My wife and I moved here 12 years ago and have really enjoyed the recreational opportunities (both cultural and sport.) We have lived in Southeren California; Phoenix; Kailua, HI; Memphis, TN, and Tulsa, OK. We have always found something positive every place we have lived...it has just been easier to do here in Louisville. My wife is a Cali Girl and has set down the law "We are either staying here or moving back to Hawaii." With a 1000 SqFt home in a Kailua (not on the water and no views) going for $800,000+, I think we will be spending the rest of our lives in this part of the Bluegrass.

Posted by: ChiTownGal at 06/10/2009 10:55:50 AM

I agree 100% with the commenters who said that Louisville is clique-ish. If you didn't grow up here, you will NEVER fit in - PERIOD! The community leaders take forever to put a plan into action (how long have you been talking about the bridges?) and even refused to have a pro basketball team take up residence in the town because they are too entrenched in college ball. Shopping here is pitiful at best - thank goodness Cincinnati and Indianapolis aren't too far away. Wake up Louisville! It isn't the 1970's anymore!

Posted by: B Ehret at 06/10/2009 11:43:42 AM

My husband and I moved to the Kentuciana area thirteen years ago on a job transfer. We live just 10 miles north of downtown Louisville in New Albany, Indiana. Louisville is the best city for us to enjoy our little time off from our jobs. There is almost always something going on at the Louisville fairgrounds. We always find the events we attend to be amazing and awesome! Coming soon are the National Hot Rods 4-day weekend and the outstanding Kentucky State Fair. We are proud to invite our out-of-town friends and family to Louisville too! Our guests are impressed, as we are, with all the entertainment choices Louisville offers. From top notch concerts at Freedom Hall several times a year to monthly flea markets at the fairgrounds. We are able to please any interest our visitors have had without leaving Louisville. Louisville has many wonderful museums, Slugger Baseball Stadium, Papa John's Football Stadium, Churchill Downs and white fish restaurants galore. We personally are looking forward to the opening of the new basketball arena. UofL men's and women's basketball is exciting especially during March madness!

Posted by: Louise Adams at 06/10/2009 11:48:24 AM

Louisville really is a vibrant river city. It has a can do attitude and is truly being transformed into a great city to work and play. Also the tourism board has done a nice job promoting this great city to conventions and general travellers. They have been on a roll lately announcing some huge conventions to the city....

Posted by: louisvillebest at 06/10/2009 12:30:24 PM

boohoo...as a substitute teacher in louisville for the past year, I have seen nothing but diversity in most schools. From Hindu, to Christians, from Jews to Muslims. From African-Americans to Hispanics, to Indians, to Russians. This is an extremely diverse city. The education system is top notch. There are several bad schools, and that may be where you send your kids, but that is in every school district. Louisville (at least a few years ago) was rated as the most livable city, and most literate, not to mention the traffic system in Louisville is the best! Imagine a city where it only takes you 15 minutes max to get most places. It is also a progressive city stuck in one of the most conservative states. Sooooo.... it's actually a really awesome town.

Posted by: Ellen H. at 06/10/2009 01:11:35 PM

I agree with Oma G.. A city without a river is like a house without a front door! Louisville is very diverse in culture. People from larger cities would be surprised. Louisville has the best of both worlds: big city amenities with a small town feel!

Posted by: Chef Dan at 06/10/2009 01:43:52 PM

I have lived and visited many cities all over the country but I'm proud to call Louisville, KY my home. It's a great city with a small town "feel". It has seven degrees of separation when you start meeting people and who they know. There is a great culinary scene, with many terrific restaurants. And there is a lot to do and see here that most don't even consider. Lot's of church picnics in the summer, our zoo, historic Cave Hill Cemetery is beautiful in the spring and summer and much more.

Posted by: Scott Clark at 06/10/2009 01:55:49 PM

Whether Louisville or Lexington rises to the top here, it either shows that Kentucky is an amazing place to live -or- that people in Kentucky have way too much time on their hands. I'm guessing the former. :-)

Posted by: AdamC at 06/10/2009 02:34:46 PM

Louisville is a great town. Comfortable, accessible, and laid back just enough to where its sleepy yet still vibrant. It's not a metropolis by any means but its not a cow town either. It's a perfect mix.

Posted by: Bob Smith at 06/10/2009 02:38:09 PM

Louisville is nice except for the good ol' boys network that you have to work through to find a job. Second that with the distinct lack of jobs unless you want to rob people in the healthcare industry or poison people working for the fast food industry. Racine has the same small town feel with actual jobs available with a decent wage.

Posted by: dustted at 06/10/2009 02:58:27 PM

Louisville is the best city. I've lived in Chicago, Dallas, Houston & Louisville. We visit Lexington for business or to go to Keeneland, which is beautiful, but Louisville still wins hands down!

Posted by: mj84 at 06/10/2009 04:11:21 PM

Im going to have to agree with everyone else BUT louisville boo hoo. Everyone I know who has moved to Louisville has LOVED it and hasnt left. And if they do leave they still love Louisville. It might not be the biggest city in the world but who honestly cares about that. The two of you need to take everyone elses advice and maybe get out a little more :)

Posted by: tokenblogger at 06/10/2009 04:48:15 PM

We moved to Lexington (Kentucky) late fall of 1996. My husband and I have enjoyed living in Lexington more than any other place we lived (in and out of the Bluegrass State). In 2004 we purchased a home in a downtown neighborhood; an area that continues to move forward in revitalization. We walk and/or ride bikes all over the downtown area and to some surrounding neighborhoods. Our lives are enriched by these areas of strong diversity. Entrepreneur activity is booming; and we've found the price of housing in Lexington and Fayette County has remained quite constant in this "downed" economy. Medical care in the area is top notch. Social/Charitable assistance is available for every need one could imagine. Educational opportunities are limitless. Entertainment styles are available in forms one might not ever imagine! Lexington is more than horses, basketball, and bluegrass --- it is home! In Lexington, Kentucky there really is something for everyone!

Posted by: Charlie Springer at 06/10/2009 07:20:08 PM

Don't know about the "Yes We Can" trite, but Louisville is a great city.

Posted by: Jim Gardner at 06/10/2009 07:43:19 PM

Having lived in one of the most hyped cities (San Francisco) in the world, I can attest to the actual charms of Louisville. No one has asked me where I 'went to school' since my return here in 2005, a bit of a myth that even when it occurs isn't in the least about being in a clique.

Posted by: Chuck at 06/10/2009 08:49:06 PM

What the Louisville people don't tell you is that the city has vast amounts of its city area that is crime infested and trashy. Approximately 50 percent of the county consists of areas that are run down...You'll find that the average job in Louisville might pay 8 to 12 dollars an hour...Louisville has 11,000 homeless people as approximated by a local homeless coalition, 15,000 are waiting for section 8 housing and the crime rate is spiraling. If you have a high school mentality in that it is more important where you went to high school than where you went to college, then Louisville is for you. Otherwise, grown ups with class and education are fleeing the city for greener pastures in other regional cities like Cincinnati, Chicago, Indianapolis, Nashville, etc. Louisville is very overrated in its cultural pursuits. While the Highlands and Frankfort avenue areas have their funky vibe, most of the city is dead outside of bars and things of that sort. Most of the restaurants during the week close at 10 or maybe 11 so you are left with fast food as your option. Don't let anyone fool you when it comes to this Kentucky metro, you are better off examining Cincinnati or Indianapolis or other cities for real life and real careers and earning potential.

Posted by: judy warren at 06/10/2009 10:13:54 PM

tomorrow is my 4th anniversary to a guy from colo. he now tells everybody he's from louisville,ky. even though we have a house still in colo. why is that? because, louisville has more heart and soul than any other state! we rock, we roll and we excite people!

Posted by: jas at 06/10/2009 10:33:49 PM

I moved to Louisville from a major city, didn't think I'd last long, and am loving it. I've met many in the same situation. Every day there is something new to admire about this city. Yes, it's still in Kentucky and that causes problems, and we still have to deal with State legislators that haven't read a book or newspaper since 1943. But all the 'complaints' of this city exist everywhere. It's truly a special place and closes later than most other cities this size and bigger.

Posted by: steve at 06/10/2009 10:35:21 PM

so there was no ballot stuffing involved in roanokes behalf....

Posted by: Allie at 06/10/2009 10:54:25 PM

I have lived in several cities (all of which are also choices) but Louisville, Kentucky is THE BEST! No other place is as attractive, friendly, easy-to-get-around and exciting. There is always something going on in Louisville and I feel like I can walk into any restaurant or bar and feel welcome. There is truly something for everyone here!!

Posted by: Scott at 06/11/2009 07:30:50 AM

Hey Chuck, it sounds like you need to move.

Posted by: David at 06/11/2009 07:58:48 AM

Chuck, thou doth exagerate. There is no fleeing to the greener pastures of Cinci, Chicago, Indy, Nashville. In fact actually most of those cities are seeing 'fleeing' themselves as evidenced by declining 'home county' populations which is not happening in Jefferson (Louisville home county). I will add that with exception of Indy, the other cities mentioned are nice to visit.

Posted by: Patty DeMarco at 06/11/2009 08:34:44 AM

Pittsburgh is the greatest city! I have lived all over the world, and chose to come back home a few years ago. This city has always had a tough gritty core, but embellished with the art and grace and aesthetic of a hundred cultures as they come here and settle in. Pittsburgh is the best of the America we are up dreaming of. The tough industrial period built the country's infrastructure, the wealth of those earliest industrialists endowed foundations that are leading and fueling the cutting edge of the green revolution. The demise of this city has been proclaimed...many many times! Yet, we rise out of tribulation with a rebirth out of innovation, and just sheer stubbornness. It is a great city, a caring city, a place where people connect to each other and to the wider world. A place where people are drawing from their past, adding the intellectual capital of eight great universities, and building the new sustainable future!

Posted by: Lisa at 06/11/2009 09:36:28 AM

Thanks Chuck for that wonderful comment on Louisville. Where do you live in Cincinnati?

Posted by: Amy at 06/11/2009 09:36:50 AM

Please let us know where Chuck lives? Could you imagine living near that guy?I've been through Louisville well over 100 times and like any large city it has some run-down areas just as the other cities you mentioned, but for the most part it's beautiful, unique and has a ton of hospitality...

Posted by: vian at 06/11/2009 10:10:29 AM

Im moving with my husband from Dubai to Louisville, Its a huge change I know but we both excited about it. I'm an Artist from Iraq and will open my own gallery there. I've been to Louisville only few times but loved the feeling there, not very big nor small and very friendly people.

Posted by: Sara at 06/11/2009 11:01:01 AM

Louisville is not infested in crime...sure there are parts that are run-down and trashy, but thats how it is in any city. I have class and a college education and I would never think of leaving Louisville. I'm not sure I have ever visited a better city to live in and I have been all over the US. Im not sure what part of the city certain people are talking about that is dead outside of the bars....they have just not found the right places!

Posted by: Lori at 06/11/2009 12:00:27 PM

We relocated to Louisville, from Tampa 2 years ago. Louisville's best quality is the warmth of the people who live here. The neighborhoods are welcoming and the city has spirit. We live in the Highlands and there is plenty of entertainment.I love that Louisville is unique and not a stamped out suburban town. There is history and culture here. Yes, there is a "bad" side of town, but every city has that area. Louisville is a place where you can live in peace and feel at home very quickly. If you want glitz and flash you will have to live somewhere else. This is a really down to earth community. I am done moving!!

Posted by: Marv at 06/11/2009 12:35:30 PM

I think the people who are actually living in the best cities, are too busy enjoying their lives to vote in this poll, to be honest.

Posted by: Curtis Morrison at 06/11/2009 12:44:58 PM

Louisville, KY is the kind of city that you don't have to worry about dress codes or getting a table at your favorite restaurant. You always see a familiar face when you go out. What is there to do? There's art, theater, activism, music, museums, parks, Churchill Downs, Horseshoe Casino, River Bats, the Louisville Cardinals, the Kentucky Derby Festival, St. James Art Fair, friday night Gallery hops...basically, there's always something to do. And we have the Ohio River!... Roanoke-give me a break :p

Posted by: Steve Magruder at 06/11/2009 01:36:15 PM

I'm a Louisville native who has also lived in Binghamton (NY), Atlanta, Charlotte and SF bay area. Louisville beats them all for different reasons. It beats Binghamton in weather, friendliness, shopping, things to do, etc. It beats Atlanta in that Louisvillians tend to be far less racist and much less money-oriented. It beats Charlotte in that Louisville has vast park space and protects much of its culture, whereas Charlotte has little park space and tears down historical structures left and right for the sake of "progress". Louisville is also much less "corporate" and more oriented to independent business than Charlotte is. It beats the SF bay area in terms of cost of living, by a wide margin.

Posted by: Jackie at 06/11/2009 02:13:57 PM

vian: if you need a gallery intern please let me know. louisville is a wonderful city for the arts, surprisingly so. i'm on twitter as winoforever.

Posted by: eblawler at 06/11/2009 03:34:25 PM

I've lived in Louisville most of my life. In my 20s I loved living in the Highlands and running around Bardstown Rd, then in Crescent Hill when starting family life, now we're further east in a great area for the kids. My favorite things about Louisville are the rich green grass, trees and beautiful flowers, especially in the hills near the river (they say Kentucky is as green as Ireland). I love that it only takes 20 minutes to get most places in the city. I am guilty of asking where someone went to high school but only if they are within 4 years of my age to see if we have friends in common. I do not find it cliquish - you find what you seek. Also love: incredible restaurants, the Trolley hops, art community, Waterfront park and fun events every weekend not to mention Thunder Over Louisville and the Derby!

Posted by: Karen at 06/11/2009 04:05:55 PM

I love Louisville! It's the biggest small town, wonderful Olmstead Parks, a great indie music history, Bardstown Road, UofL basketball,the Derby, and terrific libraries too. I drive all over the city for my job and even the areas that most people consider "run down" are still beautiful and rarely explored (the Northeast and West end). They are right next door to an Olmstead Park too. The best thing about Louisville is the people; they are proud of their town and I guarantee if you walk down the street, the majority of the people will smile at you!

Posted by: P-Diddy at 06/11/2009 04:19:04 PM

Asking someone where they went to High School sounds like that person wants to get to know you better. That is being open-minded. I know several people who moved to Louisville many moons ago that are still here. My best friend is from Pittsburgh and lives here now and is slowly adapting , but for the most part has his own open-mindness as well. Yes, we love college hoops, but that has a lot to do with tradition, something I was born with. I work Downtown, live in the ighlands,building a family here and have no plans to leave ever. The nightlife is great, many restaurants to boot, and c'mon man we got city-scoot! C-A-R-D-S baby!

Posted by: Walter at 06/11/2009 11:52:13 PM

....and not to mention, Louisville is close to the great city of Lexington where the Kentucky Wildcats rexide. Half, or more of Louisvillians are UK fans and do not have to drive more than 65 to 75 miles from Rupp Arena and Commonwealth Stadiu,!

Posted by: JoeyinKY at 06/12/2009 06:07:58 AM

Louisville rundown and trashy? Please! We have one of the finest examples of architecture from Frank Lloyd Write to the cast iron facades on main street. Our parks are clean and well maintained and our Operation Brightside has flower beds along many of the expressways and intersections. Sure there are some areas of town where there are folks that can't mantain spotless yards and homes, but even our "projects" have been rebuilt with nice commaon areas and townhomes for the financially challenged. Louisville is also the home to the UPS Worldport Hub. This is their International Sorting Facility and Airline home base. They offer thousands of jobs with great benefits for their workers including tuition reimbursment & healthcare. Some of their hourly technical jobs pay from $20 - $30 an hour. I can't imagine leaving this area. Lakes, Parks, museums, Broadway Shows; It's all packaged neatly with a small town feel. Come give us a chance!

Posted by: Brett at 06/12/2009 12:58:02 PM

Love seeing Louisville at the top. Louisville isn’t just "a place to live," it’s a place to really live. It’s a town without excuses, blissfully free of the hang-ups and holdups that keep things from happening. It’s a place where blue-sky thinking meets grassroots can-do. It’s a city without limits. Anything’s possible here in Louisville. Especially you. For those of you that love Louisville, make it official. Join www.friendoflou.com

Posted by: LouisvillesFinest at 06/12/2009 05:23:34 PM

...I was born and raised in Louisville, and have since lived in the Twin Cities and Phoenix. I love all these cities in different ways and will end up in one of them more than likely, however NOWHERE has a place in my heart like the Derby City...even random people that I have met across the country that have only so much as traveled there seem to understand why I feel this way...regardless of the great public and private schools, the tremendous diversity, fabulous restaurants, art scene, excellent place to raise a family, and the Derby alone (which makes Louisville superior to other cities), these are not the things that make Louisville Great. A City is only as good as the people that live there, and you will never find another city where the residents love their city and have as much pride in their city as Louisville, Kentucky!...I don't need a poll to let me know it's the best!

Posted by: alex at 06/12/2009 07:32:09 PM

...hattiesburg at number 11(?)...Evansville? Akron? are these people serious???

Posted by: TheCurrentsWillShift at 06/13/2009 07:58:21 AM

Your poll is still being skewed in ways you obviously are unaware. Isn't it ironic that KY area cities are in the top 25? I've lived all over the United States, and spent a great deal of time in other countries as well. I was born and raised within the area that constitutes: Louisville, Lexington, Nashville, Clarksville, Evansville, Owensboro, Indianapolis, and Cincinnati. Isn't it ironic that no less than eight towns specifically in the KY area are in your top 25???...Do the math--or visit the towns. I guess that's what social networking sites are for right--to ban people together in order to...prop national opinion of nowhere towns who desperately need good publicity with little because they have little resources. They deceive instead of actually making them great bastions of cultural attraction and universal acceptance like Louisville, Lexington, Nashville, Indianapolis, and Cincinnati. As for me, my vote goes to Austin, Texas!

Posted by: Ken Dunlavy at 06/13/2009 08:29:27 AM

Ky is supposed to be great??? Yeah right that's bogus...People been drinkin' way to much Koolaid in that state

Posted by: annie at 06/13/2009 04:45:16 PM

Owensboro...great place to live...not too big and not to small...Look at our numbers above.

Posted by: LOUISVILLE BOO HOO at 06/13/2009 06:03:34 PM

I genuinely enjoyed reading all of your comments and respect your opinions. In particular I enjoyed hearing from those of you who had moved here from larger cities and seemed to enjoy it. I must be missing something that you found here. I still think that the cultural amenities are quite small compared to those of larger cities, and the restaurants are rather boring (very little by way of ethnic food compared to more metropolitan cities.) People on the East End are very limited in their interests and not broad-minded. The Highlands does seem to offer the most in terms of people who have lived elsewhere, visiting elsewhere, etc. (i.e., those who have been outside of Kentucky.) However, the East End is full of people that all dress the same, furnish their houses the same, etc. Overally, Louisville feels like a city stuck in the 50's...People are outwardly friendly enough, but really I think the people who are singing the praises of Louisville (and ratcheting up the polling so Louisville beats out other cities such as Chicago that has less than 100 votes) are mostly those that were born here. Come on, even the Chamber of Commerce has to encourage people to vote for the city. If any of the other cities did that in any significant way, Louisville would certainly not be at the top of the list. So, I appreciate that many of you like it here but while I have visited many of the places you have mentioned as Louisville highlights, I still don't feel the love for this place that many of you do. To each his own.

Posted by: Chrissy at 06/15/2009 01:42:21 PM

All of us from the 'burgh got together and decided not to win this one. It would be selfish of us being that we have the best football team in the world and now the best hockey team in the world. first time ever that Lord Stanley and Vince are in one city at the same time.

Posted by: Solamon at 06/15/2009 06:26:24 PM

Evansville, number 7? What's that all about?...Evansville shouldn't even be on the list, unless last.

Posted by: Debbie at 06/16/2009 01:52:54 PM

I moved to Louisville 6 years ago after growing up on the East Coast and living in NY, Boston, outside of Philly, in Bethesda, in Cleveland and other locations. I love it here. The city is manageable in size with many big city amenities but without the hassle of terrible traffic and crowds. We have great arts and entertainment, excellent college sports, laid-back/friendly people, a great business environment, amazing restaurants, and are within driving distance to Indy, Cincy, Nashville, St. Louis, Chicago, the Smokies... so it's easy to get away if you desire. I definitely think we're #1.

Posted by: Doug at 06/18/2009 11:40:38 AM

I moved to Louisville from California about a year ago. The city has much to offer to be a mid-size city. Arts, College sports, Great Food, Friendly people and the clubs are open to 4am (shocked me)! I think Louisville is the best city!

Posted by: Nancy at 06/18/2009 09:08:09 PM

Pittsburgh is already THE winner, we are THE City of Champions - we need nothing else and we should give another city some kind of bragging rights. PITTSBUGH IS #1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Jean at 06/23/2009 03:12:36 PM

Pittsburgh ROCKS!!!!!

Posted by: Chuck at 06/25/2009 05:17:19 PM

I lived in Orlando, Houston, Dallas, Modesto (CA) and San Francisco prior to moving to Louisville. There is absolutely no comparison. Louisville is the best by far.

Posted by: KAY at 07/01/2009 11:56:02 AM

I live OUTSIDE OF THE ROANOKE VALLEY, UP IN THE MOUNTAINS, WHAT I SAW LAST NIGHT, JUST BLEW ME AWAY, THE VIEW FROM BENT MOUNTAIN ( IN ROANOKE COUNTY), WAS ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL, SAW 4 COUNTIES IN ALL DIRECTIONS ANS EVEN THE HUGE MAN MADE LAKE ABOUT 70 MILES AWAY...THE CRYSTAL BLUE SKY, AND THE BUSTLING CITY BELOW, WITH BRIGHT LIGHTS, AIRPLANES TAKING OFF, AND LANDING FROM A DISTANCE....THIS IS IT FOLKS, ELEVATION 3200 FEET UP IN AIR, LOOKING DOWN ON ROANOKE, BUT LIVING IN A PLACE CLOSE TO HEAVEN, I WOULD IMAGINE!

Posted by: Dan and Kay Roanoke at 07/01/2009 12:12:52 PM

both Roanoke natives...lived in 4 other places, wouldn't trade the Roanoke valley, its friendly people, safe neighborhoods, natural resources that surround us, the Bluesiest Blue Ridge mountains! Small towns everywhere, the Blue ridge parkway , 2 miles from my house The cleanest natural creek in Virginia ( a stones throw from my house) horses grazing all around me excellent medical facilities with 15 minutes, 5 excellent educational institutions..., rivers, creeks and streams full of native trout, the home of bluegrass music, just 18 miles down the road, a strong conservative value State and local government...clean air, community involvement, the highest standard ( educational scores)rating in Virginia for our own, 4 classroom school ( yes, I said only 4 classes in elementary school here). (teacher ratio 7-1) and a fully functionally public library where everyone knows your name....We have never locked our doors at night, or when we left for a month....the only breakin we had, was one of our 5 lab dogs learned how to open the deck door, all we found were many happy dogs inside...facebook Kay Moore in Roanoke va

Posted by: Derek Rubin at 07/04/2009 12:24:16 PM

I'm going to be honest, this list is horrid. I take pleasure in seeing names like 'Portland', 'Austin', 'Pittsburgh', or 'Chicago', but... Atlanta? Owensboro? Richmond? and Louisville? Bunch of close-minded churchgoing areas. Their religiosity and passive-aggressive, artificial 'hospitality' has always kept me away from the Bible states. If you want REAL people in the 21st century, try some of the cities I mentioned like Pittsburgh and Portland, or some others that SHOULD'VE been on the list. Where the heck is Seattle or the Twin Cities? They are A-Class 21st century cities without doubt as well.

Posted by: Sharon at 07/10/2009 09:42:42 AM

I moved to Louisville one year ago, not knowing anyone except my realtor Charlene and the welcoming has been outstanding. People are warm and friendly always wanting to help you and the driving is a dream. People actually let you in and use their turn signals. The drinking water is the very best and the seasons short and mild. And Louisville has basements and coming from Florida that really is a treat. I love it here and have had many visitors in the last 11 months.

Posted by: larry hammons at 07/24/2009 03:35:49 PM

Huntington West Virginia; The best kept secret! A small town on the move in a postive direction!

Posted by: Nathan Beam at 07/28/2009 08:26:49 AM

"Bunch of close-minded churchgoing areas. Their religiosity and passive-aggressive, artificial 'hospitality' has always kept me away from the Bible states." Hi Derek, while I agree with you that the list is a bit lacking (I was rather surprised that our area of the country ranked so high) I found your remarks a bit scathing? My wife and I recently moved to Huntington, WV and were rather surprised by the warmth and friendliness of the people (granted primarily a Church going crowd) that we have found. I understand that Christianity has gotten a bad rap because many tend to be shallow and judgmental, but please don't do the very thing you despise by stereotyping everyone that is Christian as passive-aggressive and close-minded. If you are unable to keep your mind open to people that would label themselves as Christian, haven't you done the very thing you are railing against? Huntington, WV isn't one of my "Top 10" places to live but honestly it has been that "Church going crowd" that has made it bearable :). Granted, my wife and I do label ourselves as "Christian" and perhaps someone who did not wouldn't receive that kind of warm welcome... but from the friends we have made and keep I would be very surprised if that was the case? I don't say all of this to "bust your chops" and I hope you don't take it as such. I understand where the mentality comes from and that's "ok." But you could be writing off some quality people and missing out on some decent relationships by holding on to that mentality.

Posted by: Sue at 07/28/2009 04:10:06 PM

With Pullman Square and Marshall University, Huntington is a great place to live that is enjoying a turnaround.

Posted by: DR at 07/28/2009 06:52:12 PM

Not sure who on this poll is voting for Huntington, WV. This is a crappy town with nothing to do and no job opportunities, unless you are into telemarketing, then Huntington has a job for you. I...have read some of the comments about Louisville, KY and for someone that has lived in Louisville, New York City and Huntington WV, I would take Louisville any day of the week and twice on Sunday.

Posted by: Richard Mobayed at 07/30/2009 10:16:01 AM

Huntington, WV, situated along the beautiful Ohio River, tree lined streets and comfortable temps year 'round...a football town, new downtown features include loft apartments especially for college and younger youth as well as those who are "young in heart". Three hosspitals with the newest technology of all stripes and doctors/nurses dedicated to their craft. Our secondary school teachers are among the most dedicated, many receiving yearly national awards. As for the Arts: the Huntington Museum of Art is among the top 400 celebrated in America; we have several professional and near-professional theatre and choral groups; this coupled with our high schools presenting musical/drama yearly; we also four movie houses featuring multiple 'shows'; and yearly features such as "Hot Dog Festival, Pork Rib Festival...As for the retired folk in addition to clean, well managed care programs, many give their time in volunteer activities. Come join us in the fun activities in Huntington, WV.

Posted by: RON at 07/30/2009 12:21:30 PM

DEAR DR, HUNTINGTON WV IS A GREAT CITY TO RAISE A FAMILY, ENJOY FOUR SEASONS, HAVE GREAT WATER SPORTS, LOW CRIME RATE, EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES,COLLEGE SPORTS, ARTS,REASONABLE TRAFFIC,REASONABLE COST OF LIVING AND GREAT PEOPLE. PERHAPS YOU SHOULS MOVE ON TO SOMEWHERE WHERE YOU WOULD BE HAPPIER. SAFE TRAVELS!!

Posted by: LaDonna Anderson at 07/30/2009 03:15:56 PM

I think huntington is a super place to live. I enjoy WV and its people. DR keep yourself in NY or anywhere else. I could use a 28 hour day and not get everything there is to do done...

Posted by: MC at 07/31/2009 11:25:09 AM

I LOVED Huntington, WV when I lived there. However, what DR said is right...there are no jobs in Huntington. Unless you want to work in the Medical Field at 2 amazing hospitals or work at Marshall you are out of luck. I would love to move back to the area but sadly, there are no jobs.

Posted by: William at 08/03/2009 03:09:50 AM

Louisville doesn't have all that much to offer. If you like working for temporary agencies for jobs or lower wage jobs in the service industry, then more power to you...I've found more unfriendly people here than just about any other city I have been to...The best parts of the far SW of Louisville is Valley Station and Pleasure Ridge Park. Most of the rest of the city over to Bardstown Road is run down. Anything east of Bardstown Road is very nice areas and quite expensive. The overall area is severely lacking in jobs and economic opportunities. If you are in medical jobs, that's a great place to be but it doesn't work for everyone. Professionals here get low pay and less respect...It is a service industry economy here with the typical 8-12 an hour jobs. The people that are touting Louisville mostly are well established in some career track or in cahoots with those in the corner office...Sure, the houses are 85-130k for decent housing but when jobs pay 15.00 hr and less you can't expect to get ahead that way...The Highlands is vastly overrated as far as music or food or anything else. It is beautiful but most of it is getting old and increasingly shoddy. Be careful when thinking about making Louisville your destination for the future. Other cities have much more to offer including Cincinnati, Nashville, Charlotte, Atlanta, Indianapolis, Chicago, etc. Better jobs, better futures, and better retirements when you get to that point. Don't sell yourself short by moving to the 46th ranked state of Kentucky in personal income as well as bottom five in every socioeconomic factor such as poverty, education, etc.

Posted by: back to wv at 08/07/2009 03:58:42 PM

I am surprised someone would say there are no jobs in Huntington -- I've had better jobs here than suburban Philadelphia.

Posted by: NewToHuntington at 08/07/2009 11:42:02 PM

I've only lived in Huntington for a few years. It is a great place to fold into. The people are welcoming, the city has much to offer and is ever improving!

Posted by: Carl Ducci at 08/09/2009 08:51:42 AM

I've lived in Huntington WV for three years. It is an entrepreneurs dream place , because no one has brought the big chains in here. The River is beautiful, and some of their new restaurants could compete nationally for taste, value and ambiance. I especially like the new smoked rib place that opened across from the river. Retirees could make out like bandits here.

Posted by: UNCLE PETE at 08/11/2009 01:52:16 PM

I AM FROM NEW YORK CITY MY WIFE IS IN HUNTINGTON I GO THERE TWO OR THREE TIMES A YEAR AND IT IS THE BEST PART OF MY LIFE WHEN I AM IN HUNTINGTON WEST VIRGINIA...ME & MY WIFE JOANNA SEXTON AND HER MOM JUNE SEXTON HAVE THE BEST TIME EATING AT ROCCO'S RESTAURANT. I CAN EAT THERE EVERY NIGHT, & FOR THE AM WE EAT AT BOBBY EVANS RESTAURANTS. SO COME ON DOWN AND HAVE LOTS OF FUN....

Posted by: Denise Pittenger at 08/12/2009 06:22:31 PM

I moved to Huntington a year ago and am amazed by the wonderful quality of life here. In my judgment, we are the best!

Posted by: Fred in Huntington at 08/13/2009 07:58:31 AM

...Local newspaper reports massive get out vote effort in WV.

Posted by: Mack in Texas at 08/13/2009 02:00:24 PM

If you travel in mostly a straight line through Roanoke -Huntington/Ashland - Lexington across the Bluegrass Parkway and south into Nashville you will fine that the entire region is full of small beautiful cities and towns.

Posted by: Dee at 08/13/2009 03:33:41 PM

First question to Denise, when you moved to Huntington, from what city did you move from to think that Huntington is the best Second: Carl, what smoke rib place across the river are you talking about. The only reason Huntington, WV is ranked high in this poll is because the newspaper is lobbying for everyone to vote for this town.

Posted by: Rita at 08/14/2009 04:17:03 PM

Ritter Park in Huntington is an absolute treasure, and I think it's really unusual for a city of Huntington's size to have such a park. It's a great place to walk or run (the distances are marked off), to take the kids to play, to walk the dog, to play tennis. You always meet someone you know at Ritter Park. Huntington also has a really great YMCA.

Posted by: UNCLE PETE at 08/16/2009 02:18:28 PM

THEY ALL SO HAVE A GREAT ANTIQUE STORE IN HUNTINGTON WEST VIRGINIA...HATTIEAANDNANS ANTIQUES ON WEST 14 STREET OPEN FOR 15 YEARS MY WIFE AS THE STORE SHE STARTED IN NEW YORK CITY 20 YEARS... JOANNAS MOM... WORKS THE STORE AND SELLS MOST OF EVERY THING MY WIFE HAS IN THERE TO SELL....UNCLE PETE ON THE STREET FROM NEW YORK CITY.

Posted by: Linda at 08/17/2009 07:15:19 AM

DEE - The name of that smoked rib place across the river is - West Virginia Rib Station - it is located in the new CVB Visotor Center across from Harris Riverfront Park. Open 11-7 every day but Sunday from 12-5. GREAT FOOD!

Posted by: Katie at 08/18/2009 09:50:49 AM

As an engineer, I have lived all through the US (Pittsburgh, St. Louis, Houston, Miami, Philadelphia, Rochester, Atlanta, etc.) and wound up in Huntington about 5 years ago. I am proud to call Huntington home! We have beautiful historic neighborhoods, with wonderful architecture, 100 year old oak trees, and brick streets. The people are great, the cost of living is low, and we are close to some of the best outdoor recreation in the country! Huntington faces many challenges, just like every other post-industrial city in the US. These are being overcome and we have some of the most dedicated and committed grassroots volunteer movements I have ever seen!

Posted by: Jim at 08/18/2009 11:12:16 AM

...Louisville is a declining city of 700,000 people. Low wage jobs abound, low educational test scores, 118th of 154 among KY school districts. Temporary agencies running the city and its increasingly poor job market...They spent nearly 1 million dollars giving an out of town company money to renovate a bowling alley into a bar with no oversight of how funds were spent. The city is anywhere from 60 to 100 million dollars in the hole because the mayor violated union contracts. They just spent 238 million building a 22000 seat basketball arena for a college team that might play 15 to 20 games a year there. No pro sports, no real civic events except a fireworks show, etc. The streets are falling apart in most areas of the city...The roads are littered with garbage...The city looks like a glorified trailer park anyway...Louisville is not the city that some people want to brag about...

Posted by: Dee at 08/19/2009 06:26:15 PM

Jim, and where is it that you currently live. Louisville is fantastic. No pro sports team because it is and always will be a college sports town. That is the way we like it.

Posted by: Citizen at 08/20/2009 08:18:29 AM

I think it's funny how people can turn this whole poll around. Instead of being proud of where they live, they have to put down and insult other cities.

Posted by: Jon at 08/26/2009 08:25:08 AM

Concerning Louisville, I used to travel there often and was very impressed with what the "greater metro area" (i.e., the entire community) had to offer. Like any metro, it has its strengths and weaknesses, but was a place I would have easily move my family to. In the current economic environment, a lot of cities are struggling financially and I wouldn't single out Louisville's challenges as being unique.

Posted by: Don Witt at 08/27/2009 09:02:22 AM

Roanoke is a well kept secret for its fantastic quality of life. The mountains are beautiful, the greenways that ribbon the valley are wonderful, and the people are warm and freindly. Roanoke has the benefits of a small city yet has the amenities of many of the large cities. Most can comute to work in less than 20 minutes. There is an active growing younger generation who have the energy and drive to make the area vibrant and exciting. Its natural amenities include the Blue Ridge Parkway and Appalachian Trail traversing the valley and nearby Smith Mountain Lake with its 500 miles of shoreline. We love it here!

Posted by: Maria at 08/27/2009 12:27:15 PM

Okay, as I understand it, this poll is asking you to vote FOR not AGAINST the place you believe is the best place to live. So far, I've read a lot negative comments criticizing some of these wonderful places that have been getting a lot of votes. I was born and raised here in the Huntington area, went to Marshall University and work in downtown Huntington. I've lived other places but always called this area "home," becuase it was, in my heart. Huntington is and always will be a college town, with it's loyal sports fans, a town that took a huge loss in 1970 when the MU football team and many prominent citizens died in a tragic plane crash, but has risen up from those ashes to become what it is today. But looking beyond Huntington to the greater tri-state area, there are MANY opportunities to a lot of things. We have some of the finest colleges and secondary schools to be found anywhere, hospitals with the most up-to-date technology in the country, beautiful city and state parks where families can get involved in many activities, Carter Caves in KY, great fishing and hunting, beautiful campgrounds, great churches, libraries, and a host of other ways to get active in the arts. Ashland is home to the Paramount Arts Center where there is always something going on, and where some of the top entertainers in the country perform. Huntington is home to the Huntington Symphony Orchestra, the Keith-Albee theater, and the Huntington Museum of Arts. Huntington's Collis P. Huntington Historical Railroad Society hosts the day-trips to Hinton twice each October for you to feast on the beautiful New River Gorge and the fall foliage. Like white-water rafting? The tri-state is within 3-4 hours easy drive to any number of major cities and other great places to go in Ohio, Kentucky and Almost Heaven West Virginia. Am I proud to call this "home?" You betcha! Huntington, WV, Ashland, KY and Ironton, OH - I wouldn't trade this place for any other. Come see what we have to offer - bet you won't want to leave either!

Posted by: judy at 08/27/2009 02:38:10 PM

roanoke is a beautiful place and a good place to raise children.being able to travel around town and feel safe is a major issue and also feeling like you know the political figures personaly is a plus.that's how small a place it is

Posted by: Hannah at 08/28/2009 11:25:49 AM

Lynchburg, VA is a great place to live. You can feel safe down town in the middle of the night even. It is kept clean and always has a beautiful sunset at the end of each day. The people are polite even when you re driving. There is also so much history in and around Lynchburg. Many events are going on around town. You can find something to do for any age any weekend. The economy struggles are not seen around Lynchburg. I don't even know of any businesses that have closed down this past summer. Lynchburg is the best in every way!!

Posted by: Gregory at 08/28/2009 04:14:51 PM

I agree with Maria, Evansville is a great city and has become a univerity city with UE & USI. We suffered greatly when a plane crash took the lives of the UE Basketball team, coaching staff, and supporters. We are proud of our accomplishments and have one of the highest Veteran populations in the country. I really like to read from the people who are proud of their communities and only wonder why, the dissatisified people, don't move if it is that bad?

Posted by: Tory at 09/01/2009 09:21:56 PM

Where is Boone, NC?

Posted by: Aubrey Brown at 09/01/2009 10:06:10 PM

Lynchburg, Virginia is the most delightful city and beautiful. Very safe for raising a family. And the weather is great. The view of the Blue Ridge Mountains are spectacular. Lived there for 2.7 years and want to go back Lord willing.

Posted by: Kathy Ridgeway at 09/02/2009 12:46:29 PM

I agree with Aubrey Brown in every aspect about life in Lynchburg. I lived there six years and hope to someday return. I LOVE the mountain views.

Posted by: Beth White at 09/03/2009 07:51:31 AM

I absolutely love Lynchburg. I moved here from NH 25 years ago and have watched some of the changes take place. The closeness of the mountains, lake and various historical attractions make it very special.

Posted by: Charisse Eggleston at 09/03/2009 11:04:04 AM

I just love Lynchburg! It's so much bigger from where I come from!

Posted by: Alison at 09/03/2009 11:59:43 AM

I love Lynchburg! I was born and raised here and wouldn't think of leaving. It is such a nice place to raise a family, everyone is friendly and we are certainly growing.

Posted by: John Wolhfert at 09/06/2009 11:08:25 AM

Lynchburg,VA is greatest city in America!

Posted by: George Caylor at 09/07/2009 06:39:54 PM

Moved to Lynchburg, VA from Heidelberg, Germany in 1987. Wanted a place about the same size, climate, low crime, great river. Found it all in Lynchburg! Just gorgeous here.

Posted by: FirstVette at 09/09/2009 11:35:46 AM

I have lived all over and was raised 'Down-River', as Detroiters call SE MI, but (for 26 yrs) I live in and raise my family in Lynchburg, VA. SE Michigan has turned into a concrete jungle and urban sprawl now reaches 2/3rds the way up the state, but Lynchburg draws you eyes up toward beautiful mountains, fast-moving streams and some of the most beautiful real estate in the lower 48. Pair that with urban amenities on a much smaller scale and you've got a great place to live. I love the Victorian history and charm, warm receptions on the street, over abundance of world-class educational opportunities and sports venues, and the 'Don't quit' optimistic grit that makes its residents stand out as Salt of the Earth patriots. No place better!

Posted by: Becci at 09/09/2009 11:37:59 AM

Roanoke is a beautiful city with alot to offer. I relocated from the midwest and I really enjoy it.

Posted by: MtnLover at 09/10/2009 10:14:31 AM

There's nothing better than being surrounded by the Blue Ridge Mountains. If you love the outdoors, polite people, college towns and a steady pace of life, the Roanoke area is the place to be for sure. Go 'noke!

Posted by: Jo Ann at 09/10/2009 11:12:06 AM

Roanoke is a wonderful place to live. I have lived here since my teen years and have watched the growth of this area. Roanoke is conventiently located in the lovely Blue Ridge Mountains and is also close to the beaches. We are near historical areas and have a wealth of offerings by the local colleges. The Farmers' Market is located in the heart of Roanoke. There are excellent restaurants on the Market as well as bakeries. There are also excellent restaurants within the valley. The new Taubman Museum is also located in the Market Area. There are other sources of entertainment including the Jefferson Center, Center in the Square and the excellent Roanoke Symphony Orchestra. We are close to National Parks and the Applachian Trail. There are four seasons in the year to enjoy the beauty of this valley. There a various religious denominations within the valley as places of worship. The Roanoke Valley has many assets that make it a delightful place to live.

Posted by: Norm Noble at 09/10/2009 11:42:03 AM

Do you find it strange that there is not one Western city in the mix (except for Portland)? Not one? Has anyone from the west been asked to vote?

Posted by: Fran at 09/12/2009 03:55:09 AM

The best thing about Roanoke is its close proximity to Smith Mountain Lake, the beautiful jewel of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

Posted by: Esther Wood at 09/14/2009 11:15:54 PM

The best thing about Roanoke, VA is that it is only an hour from Lynchburg. : )

Posted by: Barbara Bostic at 09/15/2009 01:08:18 PM

Since I can't vote for BEDFORD, I cast my vote to our bedroom community of Lynchburg!

Posted by: Israel Jackson at 09/17/2009 05:25:42 PM

Lynchburg is a great Christ-centered environment. The atmosphere is incredible and it is undoubtedley best city.

Posted by: Vanessa P at 09/18/2009 07:27:31 AM

I love the entire state of VA, but Roanoke doesn't get recognized for how great it is. There is always something going on to get involved in. Our downtown area is really great, not to mention Mill Mountain and all the great parks in the area. Yay Roanoke!

Posted by: love Roanoke at 09/18/2009 03:23:45 PM

I was born and raised in Louisville and lived there for decades. I moved away from Louisville to the Roanoke area in 2007 and could not be happier! The people in Roanoke are much friendlier, less concerned about money and status than Louisvillians and there is WAY less crime, drugs and BS here than Louisville. I thought Louisville was okay until I moved away and experienced a better place! The only thing Louisville has an advantage over Roanoke in is public tranportation to outlying counties.

Posted by: Grace at 09/21/2009 01:28:00 PM

Lynchburg is a great city that is a melting pot that celebrates diversity and still has a southern feel.

Posted by: Ann at 09/24/2009 11:05:49 AM

Roanoke is nice, yes, but Lynchburg . . . Lynchburg is great! We have a little bit of everything to offer a lot of folks! Come see for yourself sometime! You might just stay with us. Lots of people do!

Posted by: Des V. at 09/28/2009 09:22:10 AM

I have lived just about everywhere, and I love it in the Roanoke area. Yeah, sure there are bigger cities, with more to offer, but Roanoke has a great middle ground, with beautiful nature all around. And Salem Va, the most amazing small city ( home to Roanoke College) is right next door :)

Posted by: MIchelle Brower at 09/28/2009 04:23:13 PM

For anyone who hasn't visited Pittsburgh, you should allow yourselves to be pleasantly surprised. It is a very pretty city believe it or not (very scenic). In addition to being a low-crime big city, it has excellent schools, very affordable housing (low foreclosure rates) is very friendly, has great art galleries, wonderful museums(largest fossil collection in the world) at Carnegie, great restaurants and most importantly has a great future because of the diversification of its economic base. Technology, health care, medical research,and finance are very much in Pittsburgh's future.

Posted by: Susan at 10/07/2009 02:30:36 PM

The fact that Phoenix, Arizona, is not on this list surprises me. Looks like word about this survey may not have spread to the Southwest yet. Gallup recently completely a poll which showed that Arizonans are remarkably committed to and proud of their home. It's no wonder considering the Phoenix area's 320+ days of sun, 7 professional sports teams, and a plethora of museums and cultural events!

Posted by: heidi krone at 10/15/2009 07:12:18 PM

I love the Lynchburg area and the surrounding areas! I moved here in 1994. It is a great place to raise your kids in. There are many things to do to iclude hunting fishin, hiking @ Peaks of Otter, movies, bowling. I do shop in Roanoke!! This is an amzing place for raising your family!

Posted by: Dave at 10/16/2009 09:46:59 AM

Lynchburg, Virginia is a great college town. Yes, you heard me right - a college town. Lynchburg is home to Randolph College and Lynchburg College (both small private liberal arts and sciences colleges) and Liberty University, a large Christian affiliated school. Lynchburg is a beautiful town nestled in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. The area offers a host of activities for the outdoor enthusiast - hiking, biking, boating, canoeing, golf, skateboard park, white water rafting, or fall leaf peeping on the Blue Ridge Parkway. Liberty University recently opened the country's only year-round ski slope and also hosts an ice skating rink. The area is replete with historical attractions including the National D-Day Memorial, Booker T Washington's birthplace, the end of the Civil War at Appomattox, and more. Culturally, the Maier Museum of Art at Randolph College offers a world class collection of American art while the Amazement Square children's museum offers hours of educational fun for kids. Wine enthusiasts will delight in the numerous vineyards in the area which offer regular tours, tastings, and festivals....Bed and breakfasts both in town and in the country offer a relaxing alternative to the many full service hotels in the area.

Posted by: Rick at 10/17/2009 01:51:05 PM

Please quit telling everyone about Lynchburg VA. Others might want to come . . . and stay. Please select another town.

Posted by: Christian DePaul at 10/18/2009 11:51:03 AM

Lynchburg is the heart of central Virginia. From here you can go back in time through our museums, the Old City Cemetary, Point of Honor, Historic Sandusky and so much more. You can look to the future with our progressive businesses such as AREVA, B&W Nuclear Technologies, our green initiatives starting with the Blackwater Creek biking and hiking trails and other progressive approaches with transit and the promotion of Young Professionals.

Posted by: Laura at 10/19/2009 09:00:39 AM

I am from urban DC and lived for 5 years in the rural Finger Lakes, and I absolutely love Roanoke. I have been here a year, started my own business, have kids in the city schools, walk to school/work/church/shopping/movies/everything! It's a lovely little city that has just enough of everything to satisfy the city girl in me, and surrounded by so much natural beauty that the solitude-seeking hiker/camper in me is happy too.

Posted by: Jane at 10/19/2009 11:02:08 AM

We have it all! Mountains, Lake, weather, low cost of living, easy drive to d.c. or Va beach. Amtrack has great service to DC and NYC. Our airportis easy and lower fares in recent times. The best part of Lynchburg is the people.We are friendly and care for each other. It is a great place for nature lovers and to overall live and raise a family.

Posted by: John at 10/19/2009 02:05:00 PM

. . . worth noting that Lynchburg is adjacent to other great cities/metro areas, including Charlottesville, Lexington and Roanoke, VA . . . with 360 degree/pananoramic views of the Blue Ridge Mountains, and people who are the embodiment of southern hospitality

Posted by: Jill at 10/19/2009 03:51:43 PM

I was born and raised in Good-Ol Lynchburg and would rather be nowhere else! I am so proud of our city and how much it has grown and changed for the better over time!

Posted by: Sandra at 10/21/2009 09:17:55 AM

We chose Lynchburg and moved not knowing anyone. Great public schools, beautiful mountains, close to Smith Mountain Lake, close to numerous rivers for canoeing and fishing, area colleges that provide excellent lecture series and other cultural opportunities, highly diversified business community, a rich history going back to the 1700's, a fabulous architectural history, very low population density due to the hilly nature of the city, and an outstanding medical community. There is beauty everywhere and the people are terrific.

Posted by: John Piercy at 10/21/2009 09:32:57 AM

Lynchburg has undergone a wonderful transformation over the past ten years that has left the good traits intact and re-vitalized the downtown area so it is now vibrant and current once again. With 5 colleges in the immediate area (Randolph College, Lynchburg College, Sweet Briar College, Liberty University, and CVCC) Lynchburg has become a 'happening' little city. Cost of living is hard to beat and great new restaurants are coming up every day. Check out places like Milano's, Robin Alexander, Isabella's, Mangia, Waterstone Pizza, Rivermont Pizza, dish, Bull Branch, Neighbors, Oakwood Country Club, Crown Sterling, and so many more... I expect huge things for this city over the next 10 years and I can't imagine a better place to raise your children.

Posted by: LovesLouie at 10/21/2009 11:00:59 AM

My job keeps me in Texas, but I would move to Louisville in a heartbeat. It has the warmest, friendliest people, awesome restaurants, and there are 1000s of things to do! This city has it all. It's the BEST!

Posted by: Almettie Colston at 10/21/2009 07:53:42 PM

My husband and I have traveled all over the world and have found Louisville is the absolutely best place to live. Louisville has great parks. The best dinning in the world, once you have tried Vincenzo’s you will agree. Louisville has great theaters, museums and shopping. The best place to raise a family. Located in the mid south eastern section of the United States, Louisville has easy and fast access to Chicago, Nashville, Atlanta, Florida, and South Carolina. Louisville has low crime and lots of friendly people. Once you have visited here you won’t want to leave.

Posted by: Pam at 10/21/2009 11:27:48 PM

Our family relocated to Louisville from CT - we have been exposed to the theatre, arts, wonderful resturants, and of course some of the nicest, most friendly people ever - A truly and wonderful city with lots to offer and provide!!!!

Posted by: Tim Stephens at 10/22/2009 05:30:25 PM

I have lived in Nashville, Tallahassee, Hilton Head, Fayetteville; but Louisville is absolutely my favorite place to live by far. In Louisville you have a relatively low cost of living, you can enjoy all 4-seasons,(the Fall leaf colors are spectacular), there are more Parks here than any other town its size in the country, its a great sports town, you have the arts, fabulous restaurants, friendly people, good expressways for easy traveling, and it's centrally located.

Posted by: cho at 10/22/2009 10:19:56 PM

I have lived in Louisville for a few years now. It is friendly, low-stress, and has some culture and character, but not worthy of the ballot stuffing going on here. The economy is weak and dependent on grunt labor (UPS, GE, Ford), the political leadership is moribund, and the infrastructure overall is in absolutely horrendous condition. U of L appears to exist only for basketball.

Posted by: Joan Foster at 10/23/2009 04:36:27 PM

Posted By: Lynchburg Mayor(October 23) Lynchburg rocks!!! It is located in Central Virginia and has a great sense of community and is an awesome place to live, work, play, view art, cultural activities, and view wonderful historical architecture. We are the best place to raise a family!!!!!

Posted by: Sally Ann Schneider at 10/26/2009 12:11:14 PM

After traveling all over the US and out of country for 27 years while my husband was in the Navy, we chose Lynchburg to retire, because of the people, the downtown revitalization movement, the effort to "Preserve the Past for the Future" by the preservation of Lynchburg's History and the four seasons! We think we are in Camelot. Sally Ann Schneider, Executive Director, Lynchburg Historical Foundation

Posted by: The Cruz Lady at 10/30/2009 09:49:49 AM

I moved away twice when I was younger, and have continued to return back ! The mountains in the distance (like Alaska), are beautiful to view. We don’t have a lot of snow, but just enough to see it’s beauty ! And the leaves this time of year are gorgeous. It’s so easy to get around within our city, leaving our faster pace highway on the edge of the city. We have many great colleges to be proud of ! People really care about each other, leaving a great opportunity for making new friends, to include a lot of volunteering, to help build the strength and bond in our community.

Posted by: mtnlover at 11/06/2009 12:10:06 PM

Roanoke is OK

Posted by: Ann at 11/10/2009 09:40:50 AM

I love Lynchburg. It's just right for me. Thomas Jefferson frequented Lynchburg and built his home, Poplar Forest, in the area as a retreat from Monticello. Jefferson remarked, "Nothing would give me greater pleasure than to be useful to the town of Lynchburg. I consider it as the most interesting spot in the state."

Posted by: Adam at 11/16/2009 11:11:49 AM

Moved to Louisville five years ago from Chicago. Chicago is a major, multi-cultural city, so it would be difficult to match that in another city. Sure enough, Louisville matches Chicago, just on a smaller scale. Louisville is a large city that offers most everything that Chicago offers, including diversity, job market, education, entertainment, art, and dining. Friends from Chicago love Louisville because of the same reasons I love the city. I LOVE LOUISVILLE!

Posted by: Mollie at 11/16/2009 11:30:00 PM

When does this competition end?

Posted by: Matt at 11/17/2009 08:14:03 PM

Louisville is a great city. Diversified, fantastic restaurants, growing downtown and entertainment, lower cost of living. Best city I have lived in thus far.

Posted by: Nicholas G. at 11/17/2009 08:21:16 PM

Louisville is the only city I've visited that has the best restaurants, culture, and arts scene in the Midwest. The restaurants are incredible. The new Waterfront Park is a wonderful addition. Must visit.

Posted by: David Allen at 11/18/2009 09:18:27 PM

Louisville's traffic is 2nd worst in country comparing to other large cities, but other than that, great city, especially during derby.

Today's Video More Videos >>

Extra Cash for the Holidays

E-mail Alerts: Select the Kiplinger columns and topics to be delivered to your inbox:

Advertisement