Sponsor Content Created With Canvas Annuity
Fixed Annuity vs. CD: The Math to Run Before Your CD Matures
Could you earn even more than your maturing CD?
Roughly $1.6 trillion of certificates of deposit (CDs) are expected to mature throughout 2026, according to Curinos. If you’re one of these savers with substantial deposits coming back, you have a key decision about where to put that money next.
Renewing for another CD term could certainly make sense, especially since rates are high by recent historical standards. But fixed annuities can offer that same combination of principal protection with steady earnings, often at a significantly higher rate than CDs. They also offer other benefits like tax-deferred growth.
The key is determining whether the higher returns and tax advantages outweigh the restrictions that come with a fixed annuity contract. Here's what to compare before making your next move.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
How Fixed Annuities Compare With CDs
Unlike more complex annuity products with returns tied to market performance, fixed annuities are very straightforward and follow a similar framework to CDs.
Both credit you a fixed interest rate for predictable returns and protect your balance from stock market losses. Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs), a type of fixed annuity, let you choose the length of your term and lock in your interest rate for that period.
The key difference is that a CD is a bank deposit, while a fixed annuity is an insurance contract. There are pros and cons of both.
Why Consider a Fixed Annuity Instead of a CD?
Longer available fixed-rate terms. CDs and fixed annuities guarantee your interest rate only until the end of the term. At that point, you could renew, but market rates might be lower.
CDs typically let you lock in rates for three months to five years, depending on the bank. Fixed annuities can have rate guarantee periods that last up to 10 years, giving you the option to lock in an attractive rate for up to a full decade.
Higher interest rates. Fixed annuities and CDs both base their offers on market interest rates, but fixed annuities typically pay more. For example, in October 2026, the highest five-year CD rates were around 5%, according to NerdWallet. Meanwhile, Canvas Annuity offers fixed rates ranging from 6.3% to 6.5% on its fixed annuities, depending on the term.
Let’s say you’re trying to place $100,000 in a five-year contract. At 5% annual interest, a CD would earn approximately $27,600 over five years, assuming annual compounding. A Canvas Annuity five-year fixed annuity earning 6.5% annually would generate roughly $37,000. That's roughly $9,400 more in interest from the annuity.
Tax-deferred growth. If you hold a CD in a taxable account, you owe income taxes on the interest earned each year, even if you reinvest the funds.
Fixed annuities offer tax-deferred growth. You don't owe income taxes on your earnings as long as you leave them in the contract. Delaying the tax hit gives your savings more time to grow and benefit from compound interest.
If you don't need the money when your fixed annuity term ends, you can transfer the balance straight into another annuity, extending your tax-deferred growth for even longer. In the example of $100,000 above, you would have been taxed on each piece of the $27,600 interest you earned each year from the CD, whereas in the annuity, none of the $37,000 would be taxed until the money is withdrawn. And since you can continue to roll from one annuity into another annuity, that tax may not be due until retirement, when your tax rate may be much lower.
What Are the Trade-Offs of Fixed Annuities?
Penalties for early withdrawals. Fixed annuities are designed as long-term contracts. If you cancel or withdraw money before the end of the term, the insurer can impose surrender charges. This amount depends on the contract and usually decreases over time.
For example, the Insurance Information Institute outlines a typical surrender charge schedule, with the penalty starting at 7% of withdrawals in the first year and decreasing by one percentage point each year.
However, some insurers offer more flexibility. Canvas Annuity's fixed annuities allow annual withdrawals of up to 10% of your balance without surrender charges.
CDs also charge early withdrawal penalties, but they're typically less severe. For example, you might forfeit several months of interest but not lose any of your original deposit if you withdraw your funds before the end of the term.
Additional tax penalties before retirement. If you withdraw your fixed annuity earnings before turning 59 ½, you could owe an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty to the IRS on top of income taxes on the amount since annuities are designated as a retirement savings vehicle by the IRS.
CDs don't have this additional tax penalty unless they are held in a retirement account.
Different financial protection. Unlike bank-issued CDs, fixed annuities are not covered by federal deposit insurance. Their guarantees depend on the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.
How to Decide Between a Fixed Annuity and a CD
When your CD matures, start by considering how much of that money you'll need to access over the next several years. Funds that you might need for upcoming expenses or possible emergencies are likely better kept in CDs or other bank deposit accounts.
For money you can leave untouched for three to 10 years, a fixed annuity could be the better option. Even a small rate increase can add up to substantial additional earnings on a six-figure deposit. Just be sure you have enough liquid savings elsewhere to avoid triggering surrender charges or other withdrawal restrictions.
Keep in mind that it’s not an either-or decision. You can split your money between a fixed annuity and a CD.
How to Move Your Money Into a Fixed Annuity
If a fixed annuity makes sense for your goals, you can purchase one using your existing savings as well as money that frees up from a maturing CD. You can also move money from an IRA or 401(k) into a fixed annuity through a transfer or rollover, without triggering an immediate tax bill.
If you already own an annuity, a 1035 exchange lets you transfer that contract balance into a new one without paying taxes on the accumulated earnings. Just check whether your current contract has any remaining surrender charges.
Whichever way you go, pay attention to the rates and contract terms of an annuity before signing up. They can change significantly between insurers.
Canvas Annuity offers a straightforward way to research and purchase fixed annuities directly online. Because of this model, commissions aren’t paid to brokers and Canvas can offer more competitive interest rates than traditional annuity providers. And if you have questions, they still have a team of US-based licensed representatives who can help.
To learn more about available fixed annuities and compare your options, visit the Canvas Annuity website.
Join over half a million readers using Kiplinger's insights to make smart financial decisions. Profit and prosper with our expert guidance on investing, taxes and retirement, and more. Delivered daily.
David is a financial freelance writer based out of Delaware. He specializes in making investing, insurance and retirement planning understandable. He has been published in Kiplinger, Forbes and U.S. News, and also writes for clients like American Express, LendingTree and Prudential. He is currently Treasurer for the Financial Writers Society.
Before becoming a writer, David was an insurance salesman and registered representative for New York Life. During that time, he passed both the Series 6 and CFP exams. David graduated from McGill University with degrees in Economics and Finance where he was also captain of the varsity tennis team.
-
Anthropic IPO: Live Updates and CommentaryThe Anthropic IPO is finally here, and it's likely to be one of the largest offerings ever. Follow along with Kiplinger as we report on the latest ANT news.
-
5 Steps to Take When an Inheritance Causes AnxietyReceiving an inheritance can stir up guilt, but integrating the funds into your own financial plan will help you honor your family and secure your future.
-
IRS Increases Tax Credits for Families and Workers: What Changes for 2027Tax Credits The child tax credit, adoption tax credit, and EITC will all increase next year.