1100 13th Street, NW, Suite 1000Washington, DC 20005202.887.6400Toll-free: 800.544.0155
All Contents © 2020The Kiplinger Washington Editors
By Kathy Kristof, Contributing Editor
| November 8, 2016
Pity investors who have held commodity stocks all the way through this long bull market. Although the major stock indexes have more than tripled since the last bear market bottomed, on March 9, 2009, stocks tied to oil, gas, precious metals and other commodities have sunk over the past 7½ years-plus, leaving shareholders with sometimes striking losses.
Of course, yesterday’s losers can sometimes prove to be the hot stocks of tomorrow. That may be especially true for energy stocks, particularly now that the OPEC oil cartel seems intent on cutting production, which could help boost crude prices. With that in mind, we took a closer look at the 10 stocks that performed the worst from the start of the bull market until mid September. We found a few diamonds in the rough, plenty of value traps and a few that could go either way.
Stocks were selected from the components of the Standard & Poor\'s 500 index by Morningstar and are listed in order of worst performance from March 9, 2009, through September 19, 2016. Prices, returns and related data are as of October 11. Price-earnings ratios are based on estimated year-ahead earnings. Returns are cumulative.
Share price: $10.23
Market capitalization: $3.7 billion
Bull-market return: -77.3%
Price-earnings ratio: 47
Dividend yield: none
The business: Transocean provides contract offshore-drilling services for oil and gas producers.
What drove the stock: Transocean shares plunged following the explosion of its Deepwater Horizon rig, which resulted in the largest oil spill in U.S. history. The shares got a short-lived bounce in 2011, before the reality of the disaster’s cost hit Transocean’s bottom line, sending up a gusher of red ink. Things began to look more hopeful in 2013, when oil briefly rose above $100 a barrel. But crude prices subsequently hit the skids and, although they’ve recovered a bit, remain at roughly 50% below their 2013 peaks. The companies that rely on high-cost production methods, such as offshore drilling, were hit the hardest and, thus, were more likely to postpone or cancel projects. Transocean was forced to discontinue its dividend in 2015.
Outlook: Sell. The offshore-drilling business is likely to face oversupply for some time, thanks to still-low crude prices and a glut of new rigs. If oil prices roar back, Transocean might, too. But with West Texas Crude still selling for less than $50 a barrel, the risks are too great.
Share price: $38.28
Market capitalization: $3.9 billion
Bull-market return: -68.2%
Price-earnings ratio: 14
The business: First Solar makes and markets solar panels.
What drove the stock: Tax credits for installing solar panels sent First Solar stock soaring in 2007, its first full year as a publicly traded company. But increased competition from both U.S. and Chinese solar manufacturers started to pinch sales growth at the beginning of the decade, and falling prices left First Solar with big losses in 2011 and 2012. The company has been profitable since then, but investors remain wary of solar companies, partly because a key player, SunEdison (SUNEQ), filed for bankruptcy protection earlier this year.
Outlook: Buy. Competition, particularly from low-cost manufacturers in China, remains a risk, but First Solar’s balance sheet is rock-solid and demand for solar energy should remain robust, giving the stock above-average appreciation potential in the long run.
Share price: $17.49
Market capitalization: $2.4 billion
Bull-market return: -59.5%
Price-earnings ratio: 24
The business: Offshore drilling for oil and gas.
What drove the stock: Unlike Transocean, Diamond Offshore wasn’t at the center of an environmental disaster. It has simply been a victim of falling oil prices, which have tamped demand for Diamond’s rigs. Sales and profits have been sliding since 2009, and Diamond recently discontinued its dividend to conserve cash.
Outlook: Sell. Oil prices have to rise sharply for high-cost offshore drilling to come back, and OPEC is unlikely to cut production enough for that to happen. As with interest rates, oil prices are likely to stay “lower for longer.”
Share price: $13.17
Market capitalization: $6.3 billion
Bull-market return: -51.0%
The business: Southwestern explores for and produces natural gas.
What drove the stock: The Fayetteville and Marcellus Shale formations, among the richest natural gas finds ever, were Southwestern Energy’s claim to fame when gas prices were high. It was also its undoing as gas prices plunged from $4.24 per million British thermal units at the end of 2013 to a low of $1.56 in March. Suffering with a $4.6 billion loss in 2015, the company sold new shares in July to pay off debt. That may have diluted the interests of existing shareholders, but the new capital helps the balance sheet.
Outlook: Hold. Gas prices are firming and Southwestern is becoming more efficient. Though another dip in gas prices remains a risk, Value Line analyst Michael Napoli says the stock has healthy recovery potential.
Share price: $6.28
Market capitalization: $5.0 billion
Bull-market return: -43.4%
Price-earnings ratio: 15
The business: Chesapeake explores for and produces oil and gas, both on and offshore
What drove the stock: The collapse of oil and gas prices savaged both the balance sheet and the shares of Chesapeake Energy, which was well known under its former CEO, the late Aubrey McClendon, for paying top dollar for land and mineral rights. Under current CEO Doug Lawler, the company is cutting costs and selling assets to stem a tide of red ink, but the long-term leases it signed during McClendon’s tenure will take years to roll off the balance sheet.
Outlook: Sell. Chesapeake’s stock has nearly quadrupled since February, as the company quelled rumors of impending bankruptcy. But the rebound does not warrant taking a chance on this still-troubled company.
Roy Luck via Flickr
Share price: $11.13
Market capitalization: $3.5 billion
Bull-market return: -29.4%
Price-earnings ratio: 27
Dividend yield: 1.1%
The business: NRG is the largest publicly traded independent wholesale producer in the U.S., generating electricity from oil, gas, solar, coal and nuclear power.
What drove the stock: Big declines in in commodity prices, coupled with weak demand for electricity and overcapacity, forced NRG to sell and write down assets, particularly for its coal plants. As a result, NRG posted a $6.4 billion loss in 2015 and reported another, though smaller, loss in the second quarter of 2016. The company initiated a dividend in 2012, but early this year it slashed the payout from an annual rate of 58 cents per share to 12 cents.
Outlook: Buy. NRG is taking advantage of SunEdison’s asset sales to buy solar and wind properties cheaply, and Value Line analyst Jeremy Butler thinks that will prove to be a smart move once demand for energy picks up over the next few years. Butler thinks NRG’s stock has above-average profit potential, though investors will need to be patient.
Share price: $24.86
Market capitalization: $8.7 billion
Bull-market return: -27.6%
Price-earnings ratio: 30
Dividend yield: 4.5%
The business: Mosaic produces phosphate and potash for fertilizers.
What drove the stock: Slack demand for agricultural products has dogged Mosaic since the end of the Great Recession in 2009, depressing both sales and earnings. Value Line analyst Michael Napoli expects cost cutting and a slight pickup in demand to help reverse this slide in 2017. But, for the moment, the stock’s biggest selling point is its generous dividend yield.
Outlook: Hold. Population growth will eventually drive up demand for fertilizer products. But fierce competition and the vagaries of agriculture leave Mosaic vulnerable to pricing pressure. That said, the stock has potential for patient investors with long time horizons.
Anthony92931 via Wikipedia
Share price: $7.76
Bull-market return: -26.9%
Price-earnings ratio: 9
Dividend yield: 6.2%
The business: Staples is the nation’s number one retailer of office supplies.
What drove the stock: Heated competition in the office-supply market has kept profits paper thin. Staples planned to address that by buying competitor Office Depot (ODP), but regulators nixed the planned merger in May, triggering a plunge in Staples’ stock. Staples is now closing stores and exploring “strategic alternatives” for its European operations. Cost cutting is expected to slash annual expenses by $300 million.
Outlook: Buy. Competition in the office-supply market is likely to keep profit margins low, and that may weigh on near-term results, says Value Line analyst Oriatal Haiby. But she thinks Staples has superior long-term potential. Meanwhile, you can collect generous dividends while you wait for the recovery.
Share price: $9.87
Market capitalization: $13.1 billion
Bull-market return: -22.7%
Price-earnings ratio: 8
The business: Freeport explores for and produces oil and gas, as well as gold, copper and other minerals.
What drove the stock: Once known as Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold, the company changed its name after buying Plains Exploration and McMoRan Exploration for $20 billion, including assumed debt, in 2013. The timing couldn’t have been worse. Oil prices started falling the following year, exacerbating the impact of falling gold and copper prices. Freeport has been bleeding red ink for three years. Now it is divesting itself of many of its oil assets to repair the damage.
Outlook: Hold. Freeport has valuable mining assets, and its oil and gas divestitures should keep the company afloat. But swings in commodity prices pose significant risks.
Share price: $52.57
Market capitalization: $16.6 billion
Bull-market return: -7.7%
Price-earnings ratio: Not available (loss expected)
Dividend yield: 1.9%
The business: Hess engages in oil and gas exploration and production.
What drove the stock: Plunging oil and gas prices aren’t the only problem at Hess, says Morningstar analyst Stephen Simko. Even before oil prices started sliding, Hess was going way over budget in its quest to find and develop new oil and gas resources in foreign markets such as Denmark, Guyana, Malaysia, and Norway, as well as in the Gulf of Mexico and the Bakken shale fields of North Dakota. But the costly explorations consistently yielded less than anticipated and spurred a shareholder revolt in 2013 that led to the ousting of nine members of the board and to sales of several assets.
Outlook: Sell. A recovery in oil prices could help this laggard, as could a further shake-up in its management ranks. But the stock has jumped some 13% this year as oil prices have firmed. For now, opportunities in the energy sector look better elsewhere.