1100 13th Street, NW, Suite 750Washington, DC 20005202.887.6400Customer Service: 800.544.0155
All Contents © 2019The Kiplinger Washington Editors
By Nellie S. Huang, Senior Associate Editor
| February 22, 2017
Some things never seem to grow old, including the love investors have for dividend stocks. There’s a good reason we love dividends. Between 1930 and 2012, they accounted for about 40% of the total return of Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index, according to a Morgan Stanley study. Here are our favorite dividend-stock mutual funds—two index funds and five actively managed portfolios. The list, with one exception (Vanguard High Dividend Yield Index Fund), is made up of funds that invest in so-called “dividend growers”—companies that consistently raise their payouts. All of the funds have one thing in common: They have been less volatile than the S&P 500 over the past one, three, five and 10 years.
All returns and data are through February 1. Click on ticker-symbol links for current prices and more.
Expense ratio: 0.67%
Total assets: $41.8 billion
1-year return: 19.1%
3-year return: 9.3%
5-year return: 11.9%
10-year return: 6.6%
We haven’t recommended American funds much in the past, in part because they were only available through advisers. Not anymore. Now Capital Group, which sponsors and manages the American Funds portfolios, offers a share class with no sales charge or transaction fee for each of its funds at certain brokerage firms. You can buy the F1 shares of American Mutual at Fidelity, Schwab and Scottrade with a super-low minimum initial investment of $250 ($25 if you opt for monthly automatic deposits). That and the fund’s low expense ratio, are part of this fund’s draw.
But the best thing about American Mutual is its ability to hold steady in rocky markets. Since its 1950 inception, American Mutual has outperformed the S&P 500 in all 14 market declines of 15% of more, says Morningstar analyst Alec Lucas. Losing less has helped over time. The fund’s long-term returns have been above average, and its risk has been well below average. Its 15-year record, a total return of 7.2% annualized, outpaces the S&P 500 by a smidge , and the fund was 18% less volatile over that time.
American Mutual invests in attractively priced stocks of industry leaders that pay steady dividends. It has some leeway to hold preferred stocks, convertible bonds, U.S. government bonds and investment-grade corporate debt, too. About 90% of the fund’s assets are invested in stocks, plus 2% in bonds and the remainder in cash. Its top three holdings are Verizon Communications, Texas Instruments and Amgen.
Expense ratio: 0.66%
Total assets: $86.9 billion
1-year return: 19.7%
3-year return: 9.6%
5-year return: 12.8%
10-year return: 6.4%
Washington Mutual managers must follow a strict set of rules for the kinds of stocks the fund owns. But those guidelines, which target characteristics that are common among blue-chip stocks, make this fund a good fit for conservative investors looking for dividend stocks. One rule, for example, requires a company to have paid a dividend in eight of the previous 10 years. (Up to 5% of the fund’s assets can be in non-dividend payers, but they must pass even stricter requirements.)
Over time, the unique stock-picking strategy has delivered above-average returns with below-average risk. The fund’s 10-year annualized return, 6.4%, doesn’t beat the S&P 500, but it’s better than 77% of similar funds that invest in bargain-priced, large-company stocks. And the ride was 13% less bumpy than that of its peers.
Don’t let the fund’s size worry you. American Funds and its sponsor, Capital Group, employ a multiple-manager approach that cuts unwieldy funds down to size. Washington Mutual has eight managers, with each one running part of the fund separately from the others.
Expense ratio: 0.98%
Total assets: $52 million
1-year return: 20.4%
3-year return: 12.3%
5-year return: --
10-year return: --
Buffalo Dividend Focus launched in 2012, which makes it the youngest fund among our picks. But we’re drawn to its nimble size: It has just $52 million in assets. And so far, managers Paul Dlugosch and Scott Moore have performed well. The fund’s three-year record beats the S&P 500 by an average of 1.4 percentage points per year.
Dlugosch and Moore focus on generating income by investing mostly in dividend-paying stocks that have a history of increasing those payments. They start with stocks with a market value of $1 billion—the fund can invest in companies of any size but favors large firms—and a minimum yield of 2.0%. The managers then zero in on bargain-priced companies that are leaders in their industry and that generate enough cash to support and raise dividends over time. Apple, for instance, is its top holding.
Expense ratio: 0.64%
Total assets: $6.9 billion
1-year return: 18.0%
3-year return: 10.4%
5-year return: 13.1%
10-year return: 7.2%
Manager Tom Huber calls Dividend Growth an “all weather” fund. Since he took over the fund in 2000, he has seen a few stormy periods. Throughout the aughts, for instance, the S&P 500 lost an annualized 1.0%; Dividend Growth, a Kiplinger 25 member, gained 2.8%. In 2008, the fund’s 33.3% loss was 3.7 percentage points better than the S&P 500 and beat 85% of similar funds. In good times, the fund has lagged the benchmark, but only by a little. Over the years, providing ballast in bad times—and largely keeping up in good times—has made for a good overall record. Since Huber stepped in as manager in March 2000, Dividend Growth has returned 6.8% annualized, ahead of the 4.5% return in the S&P 500.
Huber focuses on large, sturdy firms that throw off lots of cash and thus have the capacity to consistently raise their dividends. “If companies are raising dividends, that means earnings and cash are growing, too,” says Huber. “These kinds of companies tend to be durable.” Top holdings are JPMorgan Chase, Microsoft and UnitedHealth Group.
Expense ratio: 0.26%
Total assets: $25.4 billion
1-year return: 19.0%
3-year return: 10.3%
We recently added Vanguard Equity-Income to the Kiplinger 25. It is run by two outfits. Wellington Management’s Michael Reckmeyer manages two-thirds of the fund’s assets; Jim Stetler and Michael Roach of Vanguard’s in-house quantitative group, which uses computer models to pick stocks, run the remainder.
Both firms focus on generating income and share-price gains by investing in large, high-quality companies with above-average yields. But the managers go about picking stocks in different ways. Reckmeyer favors large firms with superior growth prospects and an ability to boost the dividend over time. And he likes to buy when stocks are out of favor or trading at low prices. Stetler and Roach employ computers to home in on companies with strong balance sheets, consistent earnings growth and managers who make shareholder-oriented decisions (such as raising dividends), among other factors.
The two teams have been working together for almost a decade (since August 2007). Since then, the fund has returned 7.8% annualized, which beats the 7.5% return of the S&P 500.
Expense ratio: 0.19%
Total assets: $22.6 billion
1-year return: 15.9%
3-year return: 8.7%
5-year return: 11.1%
10-year return: 6.7%
There is no scarcity of choices when it comes to dividend-oriented index funds. But we favor Vanguard Dividend Appreciation because it focuses on companies that regularly boost their dividends.
The fund tracks the Nasdaq US Dividend Achievers index, but eligible stocks include any U.S. security listed on Nasdaq or the New York Stock Exchange. The main qualification is that a company must have increased payouts for at least 10 of the past consecutive years. Limited partnerships, real estate investment trusts and financially troubled firms are excluded. Currently, 186 stocks make the mark (other proprietary screens help to winnow the list). The securities are weighted by market value; the bigger the company in market capitalization (share price multiplied by shares outstanding), the bigger its position in the fund. The fund is recalibrated once a year in keeping with the index. Its top three holdings are Microsoft, Johnson & Johnson and PepsiCo.
Expense ratio: 0.16%
Total assets: $17.1 billion
1-year return: 20.0%
3-year return: 11.3%
5-year return: 13.6%
10-year return: 6.9%
In general, we prefer companies that consistently raise dividends to firms that simply pay a high dividend yield. But Vanguard High Dividend Yield doesn’t sacrifice quality for yield. The index that the fund tracks focuses on projected dividends, and firms with no payout expected over the next 12 months don’t make the cut. While the index’s construction methodology starts with companies of all sizes, in the end it is made up mostly of large, established firms. Holdings in the fund have an average market value of $83 billion. All told, the fund holds more than 400 stocks that have been screened for yield and then weighted in the fund by market value.
Over the long haul, the fund has delivered more return for the risk than its typical peer (funds that invest in large companies with growth and value characteristics). Its 10-year annualized return outpaces 89% of its peers.
Skip This Ad »
View as One Page