1100 13th Street, NW, Suite 1000Washington, DC 20005202.887.6400Toll-free: 800.544.0155
All Contents © 2020The Kiplinger Washington Editors
By Marc A. Wojno, Contributing Writer
| December 22, 2017
The schools on our list of best college values have earned high grades for generous financial aid awards, which reduce the amount students must borrow to pay the bills. But some schools go even further, eliminating loans from their financial aid packages.
The number of schools that have no-loan policies, whereby scholarships and grants replace loans in their financial aid packages, has increased from just a handful of schools over a decade ago to 70. Some colleges limit no-loan packages to students whose family income falls below a certain level (such as $60,000 a year), while others have cut out loans for all students who are eligible for financial aid.
The programs don't necessarily eliminate all loans. Even at schools where borrowing isn't part of the deal, a student's financial aid package is based on what the school estimates a student's family can afford to pay. Some families can't or choose not to pay the full amount, which means students may have to borrow to make up the difference. And some students borrow to pay for things that aren't included in the budget covered by their financial aid package or to avoid having to take an on-campus or summer job.
The 10 schools on this list, most of which appear on our list of the top 10 overall best colleges, earned top marks in our combined 2018 rankings (which include private liberal arts colleges and private universities as well as public colleges). All 10 exclude loans from all their financial aid packages, regardless of family income.
John Phelan via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Princeton, N.J.
Total annual cost: $61,140
Average need-based aid: $47,497
Total net cost: $13,643
Kiplinger's combined rank: #1
Students with loans: 18%
Princeton University was the first school to institute a no-loan financial aid policy back in 2001, awarding all accepted students 100% of their demonstrated financial need in the form of scholarships and grants. Less than one in five students borrow, and the average debt at graduation among students who take out loans is $8,908, the third-lowest of the 300 schools in our rankings.
Its long-heralded academics, combined with generous financial aid, secure Princeton's first-place finish on our combined list (it also nabs the top spot on our list of private universities for the fourth time in a row). Princeton accepts only 7% of applicants and boasts a five-to-one student-faculty ratio. The average need-based aid award of nearly $47,500 cuts the school's annual sticker price by 78%.
Dacoslett via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Davidson, N.C.
Total annual cost: $64,903
Average need-based aid: $41,998
Total net cost: $22,905
Kiplinger's combined rank: #2
Students with loans: 26%
Strong academics help Davidson College, located about 20 miles north of Charlotte, N.C., excel in our rankings. But the school also stands out for what it doesn't do: saddle students with financial aid that must be repaid. In 2007, Davidson became the first liberal arts college to eliminate loans from all financial aid packages.
While Davidson's endowment is considerably smaller than that of the Ivy League schools with no-loan programs, the school meets 100% of each student's demonstrated financial need through scholarships, grants and campus jobs. Nearly half of Davidson students receive need-based financial aid, and the average award for students who qualify cuts the school's sticker price by 65%. Only 26% of students take loans, and the average debt at graduation among those who borrow is about $12,000 less than the national average for students who attend private colleges.
Ugen64 via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Swarthmore, Pa.
Total annual cost: $67,110
Average need-based aid: $45,536
Total net cost: $21,574
Kiplinger's combined rank: #3
Students with loans: 31%
Swarthmore's 425-acre campus, located just 11 miles southwest of Philadelphia, attracts academically gifted students. The school accepts just 13% of applicants; 61% of incoming freshmen score 700 or higher on the critical-reading portion of the SAT, and 63% score top marks on the math section. The small liberal arts college's no-loan financial aid awards reduce the average cost of attendance for those who qualify to one-third of the sticker price. The average debt of students who do borrow is 28% less than the national average for students who attend private colleges.
This 154-year-old school offers more than 600 courses in more than 40 areas of study, ranging from ancient history and medieval studies to public policy and theater. Students can also select additional courses offered through an agreement with nearby Bryn Mawr and Haverford colleges (#45 and #31, respectively, on our combined list) as well as the University of Pennsylvania (#41).
Location: Cambridge, Mass.
Total annual cost: $66,609
Average need-based aid: $48,598
Total net cost: $18,011
Kiplinger's combined rank: #4
Students with loans: 23%
The country's oldest institution of higher learning has been awarding financial aid to students since shortly after its 1636 founding. In 2007, Harvard sweetened the deal by taking loans off the table and replacing them with grants. But competition for admission to this Ivy League institution is fierce. Harvard's ultra-competitive 5% admission rate ties only with Stanford University's as the most competitive of all 300 schools in our rankings.
Families of admitted students won't have to drain the coffers to cover their portion of the bill. The school generally expects families with an annual income of between $65,000 and $150,000 to contribute no more than 10% of their income. The school meets 100% of students' demonstrated financial need and awards need-based aid to 55% of students. The average need-based aid award cuts the school's annual sticker price by 73%, making a Harvard education surprisingly affordable. More than three-fourths of families avoid borrowing—and the average debt at graduation for students who do borrow is about half of the national average for private school students.
officialpomonacollege via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Claremont, Calif.
Total annual cost: $68,125
Average need-based aid: $46,039
Total net cost: $22,086
Kiplinger's combined rank: #6
Students with loans: 36%
This small liberal arts college in southern California makes the top 10 of our combined rankings for its stellar academics and generous financial aid awards, which do not include loans. The average need-based aid award is roughly $46,000, which cuts the school's sticker price by 68%. About one-third of students borrow, but the average debt at graduation of $18,738 is just over half the national average among private school borrowers.
Pomona's idyllic campus, located within an hour's drive of Los Angeles, attracts students from around the country for its broad liberal arts curriculum. Students can select from about 600 classes (or nearly 2,700 through Pomona's partnership with other colleges in the Claremont consortium) in 48 majors in the arts, humanities, social sciences and natural sciences. The school's 92% four-year graduation rate—the highest on our list of 300 colleges—keeps most families from having to fork out money (or borrow) for an extra year.
Tom Hart via Flickr
Location: Nashville, Tenn.
Total annual cost: $64,542
Average need-based aid: $41,331
Total net cost: $23,211
Kiplinger's combined rank: #7
Students with loans: 21%
Vanderbilt University, located on 330 acres of parklike campus a mile and a half from downtown Nashville, racks up points in our rankings for its strong academics. The school's competitive 11% admission rate, high test scores among incoming freshmen, and eight-to-one student-faculty ratio help the school break into our top 10.
Vanderbilt eliminated loans from students' financial aid packages in 2009. The school's $4.10 billion endowment helps Vanderbilt meet 100% of students' demonstrated financial need. Nearly half of students qualify for need-based aid, and the average award of more than $41,000 slashes 64% from the school's sticker price. Vandy also awards non-need-based aid to 21% of students who don't receive need-based financial aid. The average debt at graduation among the roughly one-fifth of students who do borrow is $24,122.
Bobak HaEri via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Lexington, Va.
Total annual cost: $63,880
Average need-based aid: $42,292
Total net cost: $21,588
Kiplinger's combined rank: #9
Students with loans: 33%
Washington and Lee's bucolic campus, known for a student-run honor system and the "speaking tradition" of saying "hello" to fellow classmates, has attracted students throughout the country seeking a quality liberal arts education in an atmosphere of civility and respect. With an intellectual student body (88% scored in the top tier of the ACT), a competitive admission rate of 24% and a student-to-faculty ratio of eight-to-one, it's no surprise that this Mid Atlantic university makes our overall top 10 list for quality education and affordability. In fact, 95% of first-year students return to W&L for their sophomore year and 88% graduate in four years.
The school's motto, "Non Incautus Futuri," stresses a mindfulness toward the future, but W&L is also mindful of providing an affordable education for all its students. The school provides a combination of university, federal and state grants and a $2,000 work-study award to its students. Only one-third of undergraduates borrow. The average need-based aid of nearly $42,500 enables undergrads to save an average of 66% off the sticker price, making it one of the most affordable liberal arts colleges in the Mid Atlantic. Although the average debt at graduation among students who do borrow is more than $26,000, an average of 67% of students graduate debt-free.
Nick Horn via Wikimedia Commons
Location: New Haven, Conn.
Total annual cost: $70,570
Average need-based aid: $50,565
Total net cost: $20,005
Kiplinger's combined rank: #13
Students with loans: 14%
Yale's respectable academics and generous financial aid programs help this Ivy secure its spot at #13 on our best college values list. The school's $27.2 billion endowment allows it to meet 100% of financial aid for students who qualify, without including loans in financial aid packages. And Yale's definition of financial need is broader than you might expect. Families with an annual income of $200,000 or more may still qualify for some financial help. Half of students receive need-based aid—the only kind that Yale offers—and the average award cuts the school's annual sticker price by 72%.
The trick, however, is getting in. The school's 6% acceptance rate is among the most competitive of all of the schools in our rankings. Among incoming freshmen, 80% score 700 or higher on the critical-reading portion of the SAT, and 81% do just as well on the math section. And 69% of students who are offered admission enroll. Once on campus, Yalies can choose from among roughly 2,000 courses each year in more than 100 academic departments and programs.
Daderot via Wikimedia Commons
Location: Amherst, Mass.
Total annual cost: $69,500
Average need-based aid: $50,380
Total net cost: $19,120
Kiplinger's combined rank: #19
Students with loans: 22%
Located on 1,000 acres in the heart of Massachusetts's Pioneer Valley, Amherst College attracts academically gifted students. More than two-thirds of incoming freshmen score 700 or higher on the critical-reading portion of the SAT, and 67% score top marks on the math section. The school's 14% admission rate ties with Pitzer College as the fifth-most-competitive liberal arts college on our list. Students can choose from more than 850 courses on campus or more than 6,000 offered through Amherst's partnership with Hampshire College, Mount Holyoke College (#69 on our combined list), Smith College (#37) and the University of Massachusetts Amherst (#178).
Amherst eliminated loans from students' financial aid packages in 2008, replacing them with scholarships and grants. Last year, the school awarded more than $50 million in financial aid to nearly 60% of its students. The average need-based-aid award of more than $50,000 cuts the school's annual sticker price by 72%. Fewer than one-fourth of students borrow, and the average debt at graduation among those who do borrow is $18,662, just over half of the national average for private school borrowers.
Location: Brunswick, Maine
Total annual cost: $66,820
Average need-based aid: $42,206
Total net cost: $24,614
Kiplinger's combined rank: #23
Students with loans: 27%
Nestled between the mountains and the coast of Maine, this quaint liberal arts college is home to about 1,800 students. Bowdoin accepts 15% of applicants, and nearly half of those who are accepted choose to enroll. Need-based aid awards slash the school's annual sticker price by 63% for students who qualify. And students who attend Bowdoin, whose mascot is a polar bear, won't have to take the plunge when it comes to student loans. The school eliminated loans from its financial aid packages in 2008, replacing them with scholarships and grants.
Once on campus, students can choose from more than 40 majors, ranging from computer science and economics to environmental studies and neuroscience. When they're not in class, students can explore other interests through the more than 100 student groups and organizations. The school's nine-to-one student-faculty ratio means students regularly engage with their professors.