What's Keeping the Jobless Rate High

Economic Forecasts

What's Keeping the Jobless Rate High

Even as the economy recovers, some jobs will never come back.

We talk to Ethan Harris, head of North America Economics at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Research. Interview by Anne Kates Smith

Economists are debating whether our stubbornly high unemployment rate is due to structural or cyclical factors. Can you explain the difference?
Structural unemployment is the level the economy tends to settle at when economic activity is back to normal. There are always some people between jobs, because they have the wrong skill sets or because it just takes time to find work. You can address structural unemployment only through education and other support programs, not through monetary or fiscal policy. High cyclical unemployment occurs during recessions, when businesses temporarily lay off lots of people. As the economy recovers, those jobs usually come back.

Sponsored Content

Which is it this time around?
In a normal recession, the period of very high unemployment is usually short -- a couple of years. This recession has been very deep, and the recovery, very weak. That means a greater risk of structural unemployment. People out of work for a year or two become much harder to employ because they lose skills. Also, this time around people are unable to move to take a job because of negative equity in their homes. And some industries have suffered a sustained shock. We think there's more of a structural loss within real estate and manufacturing that's not going to come back -- and a large group of people who have invested in skills that are much less marketable now.

So our problems are structural?
Higher structural unemployment doesn't mean it's all structural. We think one-fourth of the rise in unemployment is structural -- about 1.5 percentage points of the increase from 4.5% unemployment to about 9.5% now.


What can be done?
The quicker you get the cyclical rate down, the fewer long-term unemployeds there are. You want to break the vicious cycle. The government needs to keep both feet planted on the accelerator of easy monetary and fiscal policy. Anything to reallocate people geographically and across jobs will help -- finding ways to improve the housing picture will increase mobility. Job training is important.

When will things get back to normal?
Not for at least three to four years. And then, we may still have a 6.5% unemployment rate.