Give a Gift

What General Motors' Bankruptcy Means to Investors

Why the worthless stock may still be in play. Plus, what should bondholders expect?

By Thomas M. Anderson, Associate Editor, Kiplinger's Personal Finance

June 2, 2009
Text Size T T
  • Comments
  • Print This Article
  • Order a Reprint
  • Advertisement

General Motors' bankruptcy filing is particularly devastating for stock investors.

RELATED LINKS
What General Motors' Bankruptcy Means to Consumers

Unless the government intervenes, current shareholders in GM will be wiped out; the stock becomes worthless because shareholders have no claims on GM assets in bankruptcy court. The stock (symbol GM) was unchanged on June 1, closing at 75 cents.

The unlikely steadiness in GM's stock price on the day of the bankruptcy announcement may be attributed to two known groups of investors: speculators, who bought shares expecting that the government would bail out not only the company but shareholders as well, and short sellers, who were betting that the stock's price would fall and covered their positions to lock in gains.

Here are the next steps in the game plan: The New York Stock Exchange will delist GM shares on June 2. The shares will continue to trade over the counter on the pink sheets and the OTC Bulletin Board. Dow Jones plans to remove GM from the Dow Jones industrial average on June 8 (the company has been a component of the Dow continuously since 1925). Cisco Systems (CSCO), the telecommunications-equipment giant, will replace GM in the Dow industrials.

Actively managed mutual funds abandoned GM before its bankruptcy filing. No actively managed fund is a major holder of GM stock, according to fund tracker Morningstar. Only index funds, which track such benchmarks as Standard & Poor's 500-stock index, owned big positions in GM, relative to their other holdings.

GM bondholders will fare slightly better than shareholders. GM owes a total of $33 billion to bondholders; $6 billion is secured and $27 billion is unsecured. Secured bondholders were willing to accept lower interest payments than unsecured bondholders to be at the top of the list of creditors to be paid back if the firm entered bankruptcy.

Under the agreement GM reached with the U.S. Treasury Department and the Canadian government, unsecured creditors will receive stock in 10% of the "new" GM that will emerge from Chapter 11 if the bankruptcy court approves. "Most likely, secured bondholders will be paid in full, and the remaining $27 billion in unsecured debt will be settled with what's left over," says Cary Carbonaro, a financial planner in New York.

GM-related investments, such as GMAC bonds and Promark investment accounts, are unaffected by the bankruptcy filing. GMAC is not a part of the reorganization and says it does not intend to file for bankruptcy.

Promark funds, which are managed by Promark Global Advisors (formerly General Motors Asset Management), are offered in 401(k) retirement plans of employees of GM and other companies. The bankruptcy filing should have no impact on these 401(k) plans because they are owned by workers, not by GM. "GM's bankruptcy does not affect Promark in any way," says Promark spokeswoman Julie Gibson.


DISCUSS

Permission to post your comment is assumed when you submit it. The name you provide will be used to identify your post, and NOT your e-mail address. We reserve the right to excerpt or edit any posted comments for clarity, appropriateness, civility, and relevance to the topic.
View our full privacy policy

Reader Comments (10)

Posted by: Steve Melito at 06/02/2009 02:08:40 PM

This article states: "Unless the government intervenes, current shareholders in GM will be wiped out". What, specifically, would the government have to do to "intervene" here?

Posted by: wherbie at 06/02/2009 04:25:55 PM

GM is going to pull a KMART here...doing just what KMART did...hold on to your shorts.....

Posted by: Billie at 06/02/2009 10:38:50 PM

what about gpm?

Posted by: RMM at 06/03/2009 01:37:38 PM

Let’s get this straight. We taxpayers paid nothing for the GM bailout. All the money came from deficit spending, and by definition, deficit spending does not use our tax money. That’s what makes it deficit spending.We taxpayers do not own 60% of GM stock. The government owns the stock, which it can sell or vote as it sees fit. As taxpayers, we neither can sell nor vote our shares of the stock. If the stock goes up in value, we taxpayers will not receive a profit. If it goes down, we won’t take a loss. We didn’t buy it and we don’t own it. If GM ever is able to repay the government’s investment, we taxpayers won’t see a penny of that money. The government’s payment to GM stimulated the economy, by increasing the money supply. Similarly, GM’s eventual repayment to the government will hurt us by removing money from the economy. That payment will function as a gigantic tax on GM, hurting everyone. The government never should have bought GM stock. The notion that “we are the government, and what the government owns, we own, and what the government pays, we pay” is silly on the face of it. The only cost to taxpayers is taxes...The media and the government should stop referring to federal payments as using “taxpayers’ money.” That terminology is false, misleading and hurts efforts to cure the recession....

Posted by: John at 06/03/2009 03:06:14 PM

RMM - I agree with many comments made in your post below, but don't understand how the government spending is not taxpayer dollars. How else would the government 'earn' money?

Posted by: GRRRR at 06/03/2009 03:19:49 PM

"Let’s get this straight. We taxpayers paid nothing for the GM bailout. All the money came from deficit spending, and by definition, deficit spending does not use our tax money." OH, OK! Then if I buy a big screen on my credit card, since its money I don't really have (and not in my budget), then I did not really pay for anything and should therefore owe nothing for it. Any interest should't be for my account either. I like these new economics. Stimulate the economy by pouring money into a company that will go into bankruptcy anyway! Unless I am bailing out a UNION (for political payback) that makes no sense.

Posted by: PAS at 06/03/2009 07:00:48 PM

RMM -- ALL government money comes from the taxpayer. Sure they are printing it and spending it like there's no tomorrow, but I disagree with you. Eventually, the bill will come around and will be squarely passed to the taxpayers. When the top tax rates go to 90%, let me know what you think at that point, ok?

Posted by: Joe Honick at 06/03/2009 10:37:35 PM

RMM's protestations are dead on accurate. Worse than any of this is the reality that there has so far not been one piece of job creating exercises by the administration no matter what the efforts are called, bailouts, stimulus or anything else. The gigantic public works promise of December 8, 2008, has yet to see daylight. The concern is whether the administration will use the levers of its biggest recipients in manufacturing, finance and automotive to become de facto levers to control smaller units of manufacture and housing and sundry other areas of business. Considering the hugely public yielding to the non-democratic Saudis et al who have had the benefit of our armed forces to act as their surrogates in war, we may have yet to see what exercises will emerge.

Posted by: Ruger Defender at 06/04/2009 11:44:24 AM

I direct this to the workers of GM and Chrysler who belong to the UAW. If you loose your job make it a fun thing - PRETEND YOU ARE ON STRIKE...I know how it is because when I was young I spent every dime I made but after the Recession of the 80's. I learned a lesson and planned for bad times. Only you are responsible for your own destiny. I know it is tough to have nothing saved. In 1982 when I lost my job I mowed yards and dug in old ladies' flower beds for change and it was sure not fun but I made it. It is a good feeling to be out of debt and have money in the bank but no one did it for me. IT IS CALLED PLANNING --- While your union was talking you into demanding higher wages and benefits that only drove up the price of automobiles so only wealthy people could buy them or putting others in debt up to their you know whats, many of you were living like kings and queens and now you are crying, go ask your union for help.... I've owned GM's and I've owned Chryslers but In the future I will never buy another of either. Good Ol' FORD started this automobile thing and I am sticking with them...PLANNING PLANNING PLANNING...

Posted by: Ruger Defender at 06/04/2009 11:47:33 AM

If you think it is bad now, wait 6 months. You will think today was wonderful.......



Featured Videos From Kiplinger





Connect With Kiplinger

E-mail Updates: Select the Kiplinger columns and topics to be delivered to your inbox.

email-sign-up

facebook
twitter
RSS