Saving for Retirement
Protect Your 401(k) in Turbulent Times
Don't be tempted to stop saving or cash out your retirement accounts. Take these four steps instead.
By Cameron Huddleston, Contributing Editor, Kiplinger.com
October 1, 2008
Advertisement
A solid, long-term strategy that involves a well-diversified investment portfolio should protect your 401(k) or other retirement account during rough times, Brodeski says. For example, if you have weighted your portfolio too much toward a certain stock or sector, realize you will have to wait longer to see your account recover.
If you don't have a plan, start by testing your risk tolerance. Then figure out how much you need to save for retirement, and calculate how much to set aside each month to reach that goal based on an average annual rate of return. Knowing these things will help you select investments for your retirement account.
If you're young, your 401(k) portfolio should hold almost entirely stock funds. Stocks carry greater risks but also greater returns than bonds and money-market funds. Make sure you diversify, though, among funds that invest in stocks of large, small, domestic and international companies, as well as growth stocks and value stocks.
Even if you're close to retirement, you should have 70% to 90% of your retirement portfolio invested in stocks or stock funds, says Brodeski. You still should have at least 60% to 70% in stocks when you're retired. That's because most of your portfolio should be invested to carry you through your retirement years. Any money you figure you need over the next few years, Brodeski says, should be in cash and safe assets -- an insurance policy for when stocks are down and you don't have to sell at a loss.
For more about creating a diversified portfolio that's appropriate for your time horizon, see our suggested portfolios using the Kiplinger 25 best mutual funds and Build Your Perfect Retirement Portfolio. Or consider a target-date retirement fund, which handles the diversification for you and shifts asset allocations for you as you near retirement.
Take that deep breath. If you stop contributing to your retirement plan now, you'll miss out on compounding -- that wonderful phenomenon that lets you generate earnings from your investments' previous earnings. And you could miss out on free money if your employer matches your contributions.
If you panic and cash out your account entirely, you'll have to pay a 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you aren't 59½. Distributions, regardless of your age, are taxed as regular income. Plus, people who pull their money out of the market in a panic not only sell at the wrong time, they often buy back in when prices are too high, Brodeski cautions.
Instead, use this recent market volatility as a wake-up call. "Every investment plan -- even a 401(k) -- requires periodic maintenance," Bergquist says. "If you are not invested in something like a target fund that automatically reallocates your retirement portfolio, now is probably a good time to make sure you are allocated properly." Picture yourself at retirement time if the current volatility occurs again: Would your portfolio be positioned to handle it?
Ask your employer for help. You don't have to fly solo during these tough times. Thanks to a change in the law in 2006, employers can now provide investment advice to employees who participate in 401(k)s and similar plans.
So check with your employer to see if your plan administrator can offer guidance. A recent Charles Schwab survey found that 401(k) investors who used some type of plan-offered advice earned annual returns about 3% higher than do-it-yourselfers, Bergquist says. "This can make an even bigger difference in a tough market environment."
Editor's note: This story has been updated since it originally was published in January 2008.

Reader Comments (16)
Posted by: Linda Mesnard at 01/28/2008 11:06:23 PM
...I've had three brokers "taking care" of my 40lK's over the years and three times I have lost a significant amount of money. For the last 5 years, I have decided to take care of my porfolio on my own. Not only have I made enormous amounts of money, I recently have pulled out of the market and am waiting for a more predicitable time to start trading again. My advice to all readers. Take your financial matters into your own hands. No one will look after your money the way you will. Good Luck.
Posted by: Alex at 01/29/2008 07:49:34 AM
Cash out and buy gold and silver. Or push for a self managed borkerage account so you can own bear funds, sector funds, commodity funds etc. Many 401 plans offer very undiversified choices. They'll all crash and burn together. Inflation and a declining dollar are going to ravage. Professional advisors can't predict what will happen next week, let alone 10, 20 or 30 years from now.
Posted by: D... at 01/30/2008 02:44:01 PM
...I have a court date coming up and I think I will represent myself - no one will look out for my best interest better than I would. Hopefully I will have self-diagnosed that mysterious ailment by then so I can prescribe myself the most appropriate medicine. No one cares more about my health than I do. I could go on...
Posted by: Joe at 01/31/2008 02:57:00 PM
...go ahead and pay 5% of your returns to an "expert" who will handle your money. I'm going to invest in index funds and pay a whopping .2% to .5%, and I will beat most actively managed funds.
Posted by: Maurice at 02/07/2008 05:00:59 PM
There is only one sure way of protecting your retirement from the uncertainty of the stock market. Investing in an Index Universal Life plan. It's way better than a 401 (K) plan because your money is safe, you can't lose it and you're guaranteed decent returns when the market appreciates. I think it's a bad idea to put so much money in 401(K) It's inflexible and there are too many penalties along the way...
Posted by: Shane at 02/08/2008 03:49:50 PM
...most managed funds (the bulk of 401k funds available) UNDER-PERFORM the market. Joe is exactly right, the fund managers take 1-5% right off the top. It's IMPOSSIBLE to beat the market over the long haul by 5% a year to make up for these fees. Joe isn't talking about picking individual stocks, he's talking about just buying into these index funds...You'd be very smart to move most or all of your 401k money away from managed funds and into index funds if your plan offers them. And if it doesn't, you should suggest to your HR dept that they consider the option.
Posted by: james m. at 04/26/2008 10:36:58 PM
I have been retired for about 3 years and at present don't need any of my 401k to get by. When or should I do anything with my 401k? Thanks any input will be greatly appreciated.
Posted by: Henry at 05/29/2008 11:14:14 AM
James M. The IRS requires you to take money at 70 1/2 years old.
Posted by: audrey at 06/01/2008 08:33:04 PM
James M--Every situation is different. You should not take random advice...
Posted by: Linda at 08/15/2008 01:50:51 AM
I have the same question as James M. If you are retired and will tapped into 401K in the next year, what is the best thing if anything to do with your current 401K? Linda
Posted by: Cameron Huddleston at 08/15/2008 02:24:10 PM
To Linda: Hi again, this is the author of the story. You have to start taking withdrawals on 401(k) accounts once you turn 70/12 or you'll pay a penalty. If you're 701/2 and still working, you don't have to take minimum distributions until you actually retire. The exception doesn't apply to 5% owners in a company. Use our search option to find my story entitiled How to Tap Your Retirement Accounts. (Type in that title, and you will get a link to the story.) Hope this helps.
Posted by: Lea at 10/02/2008 11:51:20 AM
I heard that if you cash in some of your 401K to pay for college you don't have to pay the 10% for cashing early is this true?
Posted by: Rick at 10/06/2008 03:32:22 PM
I'm 54, voluntarily unemployed, and have been taking a monthly 72(t) distribution from my IRA for the last few years. I know I need to take "substantially equal" distributions each year, but I'd like to stop taking the monthly distributions for the remaining months of '08, then take the three months' distributions towards the end of December, with the hope that the markets will have recovered somewhat by then. Likewise, if things are still shaky in early '09, I'd like to not take the monthly distributions until things (I hope) recover somewhat, realizing I'll still have to take an annual distribution sometime during the year. Thoughts?
Posted by: Shirley at 10/25/2008 11:31:15 AM
I am 41 yrs old and my 401K had $19,000.00 in Feb 2008, today I am down to $15,000.00, What should I do, transfer to an IRA or hold it out, I am the sole provider in our home, my husband has been unemployed for 2 yrs, we have no children and a credit card dept of $10,000.00.,
Posted by: Catherine at 11/13/2008 01:53:10 PM
My company just made cut backs and I was let go this week. I am 32 years old and have $14,000 in my 401K. I also took out a 6K loan from my 401K that is not fully paid back. I was told it would be recorded as a loan default and not go on my credit report. Should I roll over my 401K into an IRA? I want to put the money into the safest option possible until the stock market bounces back. Should I put it all into bonds until a later date?
Posted by: Jeff at 12/29/2008 11:55:34 AM
I have a $20,000 loan against my 401K. I was laid off over a year ago and I am trying to make payments on my 401k loan. Wouldn't it make sense for the govt to allow a "freeze" on the payments (back to myself), until I am employed again. Why make matters worse for me by hitting me with penalties, taxes and a now less funded 401k. Just give me a little time to get back on my feet. Not asking for a handout - just time.