Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.

Mutual Funds

Other Players in the Field

More funds to make your money last.

Several other top players in the retirement-income market offer funds, each with its own spin.

Charles Schwab
Products: Three Monthly Income funds.
Underlying Investments: Schwab and Laudus stock and bond funds.
Goals: Moderate Payout (SWJRX): 3% to 4% annual payout, with highest growth potential. Enhanced Payout (SWKRX): 4% to 5% annually with moderate growth potential. Maximum Payout (SWLRX): 5% to 6% annually with lowest growth potential.
Expenses: 0.73% annually (Maximum Payout fund) to 0.88% annually (Moderate Payout fund). Expense ratios include fees of underlying funds. Schwab is waiving management fees beyond those of the underlying funds through February 2009.
Minimum Investment: $100
Term: Begun March 2008, they run indefinitely.
Bottom line: Similar to Vanguard products, but more expensive.

RELATED LINKS

New Ways to Tap Savings

An Income to Last a Lifetime

Investments That Pay You Every Month

DWS Investments
Product: LifeCompass Income (INCAX) fund
Underlying Investments: Stock index funds, zero-coupon bonds, short-term instruments.
Goal: To make regular, semiannual distributions that add up to an 8.25% yield based on the fund's initial $10 net asset value. A warranty from Merrill Lynch protects the distributions and insures that investors get at least $1.75 per share or the fund's NAV at the end of the fund's life, whichever is higher. However, if the fund has to use the warranty to make a distribution before 2017, the fund ends with a final payout.
Expenses: The warranty helps make this an expensive fund -- 1.87% annually.
Minimum Investment: $1,000.
Term: Begun December 2007, it expires in 2017, unless it has to tap the warranty to pay distributions before the fund expires.
Bottom line: Complicated and pricey.

Russell
Products: Three funds: 2017 Retirement Distribution (RRDAX), 2017 Accelerated Distribution (RADAX) and 2027 Extended Distribution (REIAX).
Underlying Investments: Stock, bond and real estate portfolios managed by a variety of top fund companies, including Marsico and Wellington.
Goals: To make annual distri-butions of 6% (Extended), 7% (Retirement) and 10% (Accelerated).
Expenses: Class A shares charge a 5.75% load, and annual expenses run 1.23% to 1.34% annually.
Minimum Investment: N/A
Term: Begun December 2007, the products expire in the year named, at which time they hope to return "a portion of the capital initially invested."
Bottom line: Cherry-picking top fund managers should make for good returns, but the funds are expensive. High sales fees make them inappropriate for do-it-yourself investors.